Toxicology🦠 Flashcards
What are 4 key strategies used to look for new drugs?
- follow-on compounds
- computational modelling + sequencing
- serendipitous discovery
- evergreening
What are follow-on compounds?
example?
- a drug originally discovered for one purpose, but found to be incredibly effective for another purpose
- e.g. sildenafil originally for CV issues, now treats erectile dysfunction
- i.e. luck method
What kinds of drugs are produced from serendipitous discovery?
- structurally similar to previously reported drug
- AKA “fast followers” or “me too” drugs
serendipitous discovery drugs have same mechanism as which?
2 examples?
- Same mechanism as the prototype drug but different enough to be considered novel
- e.g. captopril, enalapril
Why are drugs found by serendipitous discovery appreciated by regulators?
- provide professionals & patients with multiple options
- contribute to keeping prices low
What kind of drugs are discovered through evergreening?
- Extreme form of a “me too” drug
- Practically extending the duration of a patent with minimal chemical intervention or changes
computational modelling + sequencing: name of project used and what does the process achieve/entail?
human genome project
increasing num of solved protein x-ray crystal structures
whens computational modelling + sequencing ideal/used?
when step 1: follow on compounds from natural drug doesnt work to get lucky
computational modelling and sequencing requires understanding of what?
the target!
How does esomeprazole relate to omeprazole, and how was it discovered? (3)
- pure enantiomer of omeprazole where alcohol points forwards
- discovered through evergreening
- improved properties: PK profile, resistance to metabolism, conductive to a longer duration
Process to find new drugs
Where do we start when discovering new drugs? (hint: t_ v_, h_ i_)
target validation: explore relationship between pharmac.l modulation of a target and pathological condition. Correlation is not enough… causality must be established
hit identification: chemically accessible (synthesised easily) compound displaying initial activity towards target; can be done individually in lab
What are the characteristics the of the ‘hits’ identified?
affinity? MW? cLogP? number of rings? HBAs? HBDs?
- moderate affinity (nM - µM)
- low MW (150 < 400)
- cLog P < 4.5
- 1-4 rings
- <8 HBA
- <5 HBD
where to look for new drugs? 3 designs
rational design
high throughput screening
natural products
What type of design is where we look to find hits?
rational design
whats rational design based on and what does it utilise?
- can be based on physiological binders (substrates, co-factors)
- starts w molecule known to be active, attempts to improve on it
- Generally utilises structural information to improve ligand interactions in binding site
- attempts to improve what we can do at binding site using structural information
- e.g. protein kinases are target, so develop sunitinib similar to ATP, its substrate
and Ad -> propanolol
Instead of rational design, what could you use when you don’t know much about your target?
high-throughput screening - screening as many compounds as possible and hope to get lucky
What are 2 types of screens used in high throughput screening?
- unselected screens
- selected (directed) screens
What are the disadvantages of using unselected screens in high-throughput screening?
• Hit rates likely to be ~ 1%
• need to screen millions of compounds -> decent num of hit families to follow up
• Limited by budget, time, resources and intrinsic throughput:
limited to a number of compounds at a single concentration; generates noise
What are selected (directed screens) used in high-throughput screening?
- sometimes enough info about target to inform screening
- combo of rational design and unselected screening
What are the advantages of selected (directed) screens?
- faster
- reduces costs
- easier identification of true activity
high throughput screening:
2. selected (directed) screens
num of compounds large -> small
gradual scale
diversity based property based (rational design): target class/ privileged strucs pharmacophore based libraries target specific libraries
What are natural products?
3 examples
- also looked at for when discovering new drugs
- chemicals produced by organisms (commonly fungi, bacteria, plants)
- e.g. salicylic acid, geldanamycin, paclitaxel (Taxol)
Why are natural products difficult to synthesise?
- they are often very complex structures, with multiple stereocentres and macrocycles
- this makes it difficult to control the synthesis
What are PAINs?
Pan-Assay Interference Compounds:
- Positive hit compounds which turned out to be due to non-specific binding (artefacts)
- false positives (e.g. quinones)
- Compounds consistently identified as promising hits against different proteins
- Defined structures, covering several chemical classes
Why are PAINs problematic?
Time and research money wasted, none could be progressed further
Fragment screening:
What is the rule of 3 (RO3) in regards to lead-like compounds?
it describes the key attributes of a lead-like compound:
- Log P < 3
- MW <300 Da
- No more than 3 HBAs
- No more than 3 HBDs
- No more than 3 rotatable bonds
- recent extension: polar surface area less than or equal to 60 Angstroms (Ų)
What is fragment screening?
A method of reducing ligand complexity to increase the chance of a match with target site
What are the advantages of fragment screening? (3)
- delivers highly effective chemical diversity from smaller libraries
- can sample chemical space at finer resolution
- fragments can bind targets in multiple ways (though usually with relatively weak affinity for the target)
Describe the process of fragment screening (4)
1) start with initial library of mismatched fragments which are chemically diverse and SCREEN them
2) identify low affinity hits; ideal dissociation constant/ binding affinity will be in millimolar/high micromolar range
3) OPTIMISE strucs to generate a higher affinity compound
4) FURTEHR OPTIMISE until dissociation constant is in nanomolar range
Fragment Screening case study: 7-azaindole
- Target: mutated form of the kinase B-RAF (V600E) which is present in ~50% of melanomas
- Library of 20’000 fragments (150-350 Da) screened at fixed conc 200 µM → 238 hit fragments
- Further characterised through protein-inhibitor co-crystallography to ensure for selective binding
- 7-azaindole group consistently led to high binding affinity for active site
When is a compound likely to be produced by rational design?
any molecules that look like enzyme substrates/macromolecules:
- proteins: a peptide-like structure with amino acid residues, amine bonds
- sugars: carb like structure (6-membered cyclic ethers at centre of molecule with a lot of O atoms)
- nucleic acids: adenine, sugar and phosphate group
- rotatable bonds
When is a compound likely to be produced by a high throughput screen?
flat: few rotatable bonds and high number of sp2 centres
When is a compound likely to be a natural product?
- lots of stereocentres/rotatable bonds
- complex structure
Pan-assay interference compounds are what?
and what are positives from non-specific binding called?
false-positive hit compounds
artefacts
The first stage of turning a hit into a drug is ?
The first stage of turning a hit into a drug is hit-2-lead
What are 4 meaningful prerequisites before starting an optimisation campaign?
- structure must be chemically acceptable
- hit must respond to chemical modulation to generate quantifiable SARs
- need freedom to operate
- favourable ADME profile
What is meant by a hit needing to be chemically acceptable?
the reaction needs to be able to be performed large scale
What is meant by a hit needing to respond to chemical modulation and therefore generating a quantifiable structure activity relationship?
need to be able to change + manipulate (chemically modulate) structure to generate quantifiable structure-activity relationships
What is meant by a hit needing freedom to oeprate?
in terms of intellectual property, the drug needs to be marketable
When does the ADME profile of a hit become clear?
when cross-referenced with toxicology
Once a suitable hit is identified, optimisation occurs across multiple what? Why is the problematic? (3)
multiple dimensions
= means multiple parameters need to be optimised all at once
- end up with a trade-off to strike a balance among multiple conflicting priorities
What percentage of drug candidates entering clinical trials become marketed products?
10%
What ADME process does the low water-solubility of a compound limit?
absorption, as the compound needs to dissolve and be in solution before it can be absorbed
When optimising a compound’s ability to cross the blood brain barrier, what can we modulate?
Example: difference between hydroxyzine and cetirizine
pKa (hence the functional groups)
- cetirizine has the free OH group in hydroxyzine changed to COOH, changing the compound’s pKa and hence preventing it from crossing the BBB as pKa decreased from 15 to 5-10?
lead optimisation: affect of changing free OH (primary) to COOH?
hydroxyzine -> cetirizine
pka goes from 15 to 5-10.
can no longer cross BBB
Example of imatinib and how changing its structure improved its pharmacokinetics
- amide
- methyl
- extra R group
- adding amide enhanced selectivity
- methyl group increases selectivity by eliminating protein kinase C activity
- extra R group increases sol and oral availability
4 possible strategies used to make changes to a compound to optimise it?
homologation
disjunction
conformational constraining
bioisostere substitution
What is a homologous series?
Series of compounds that differ by a constant unit e.g. CH2
How do we use homologation to optimise a lead?
what does it help us identify?
- identify structure-activity relationships (SARs) for the particular position of substitution
- e.g. the highest affinity compound has a medium chain length in example
can be affinity/selectivity/ solubility/ half life
describe the second strategy (d…) we use to determine what changes to make to a compound to optimise it?
disjunction:
- identify minimal structure associated with activity at the sought target and remove the rest
- hence working backwards from something complex to find out what the important section is
What is the aim of disjunction?
- simplify synthesis
- ‘engineer-out’ activities at unwanted targets and hence rid of side-effects
Example of disjunction: morphine
- begin w complex structure
- in 1st step, rid of 5-membered O ring as well as some OH groups as they’re not needed - loss of stereochemistry
- we still need some kind of substituent for R2 and R3
- rid of ring as it’s not important, then rid of hydroxy group and replace X with heteroatom
What is the third strategy (c… c…) we use to determine what changes to make to a compound to optimise it?
what model does it use?
conformational constraining:
- freeze drug in a particular conformation (shape in space) to best suit the target)
- uses the lock and key model concept
Conformational constraining is used in molecules with what type of bonds?
rotatable, as these molecules are flexible and can adopt multiple conformations; we need a fixed shape that best interacts with the target
In conformational constraining, what is the ideal conformation called?
how can it be determined?
bioactive conformation
determined: trial and error/ rational
What is one way of identifying the ideal conformation in conformational constraining?
rational design - look at the crystal structures of proteins we’re targeting
2 ways conformational constraining can be acheived?
using substituents and or struc changes
Example of conformational constraining: atenolol, levcromakalim
- atenolol: no bonds restricted which can rotate a lot in space
- levcromakalim: more potent due to the completion of the cyclic ring, constraining a lot of stereochemistry - the OH will always point upwards
now fixed in space
What is the fourth strategy (b… s…) we use to determine what changes to make to a compound to optimise it?
bioisostere substitution:
- replace substituents with bioisosteres - have chemical/physical similarities to that it replaces
- results in production of similar biological properties
bioisostere modifications will depend on role of moieties they replaced, what 4 things can be changed/affected?
structural
receptor interaction
PK
metabolism
What properties of a compound will be affected if a bioisostere replaces a STRUCTURAL substituent? (5)
- geometry
- size
- shape
- polarizability
- hydrogen bonding
What properties of a compound will be affected if a bioisostere replaces a substituent that has a role in RECEPTOR INTERACTION?
all parameters
except lipid/water solubility