Torts Flashcards
Describe the Intent necessary for intentional torts
There must be a voluntary act. The defendant must intend the consequences of his act, and the act cannot be negligent. Intent can transfer between otrts or between persons.
What assumptions can you assume generally in Torts?
Assume comparative negligence, joint and several liability, and survival and wrongful death are allowed.
Can any persons not be liable for intentional torts?
Children and mentally incompetent people can’t be liable.
What damages are necessary/allowed for intentional torts?
Actual damages aren’t necessary and nominal damages are allowed.
What factors can be considered for punitive damages?
The defendant’s wealth, the reprehensibility of the misconduct, and the actual harm caused. The modern trend is to limit punitive damages.
What harm is a defendant liable for for an intentional tort?
Defendant’s are liable for all harm caused by intentional tort, even if the harm wasn’t foreseeable.
What is an assault in torts?
When the Defendant intentionally causes the plaintiff’s reasonable apprehension of imminent harm. No fear is required from the plaintiff.
Words alone aren’t enough unless the plaintiff can’t see defendant (blind or dark room)
A conditional threat is ok as long as it is immediate: “your money or your life vs. I’ll spit on you next week.
The plaintiff must be aware of the act, and the defendant must have the actual or apparent ability to cause harmful/offensive contact.
Extra sensitivity can be considered if the defendant is aware of the plaintiff’s susceptibilities.
Which intentional torts have transferred intent?
Assault Battery Trespass to land trespass to chattel (NOT CONVERSION) False Imprisonment
What damages are allowed/required for assault?
Nominal damages are ok, and actual damages are not required.
What is a battery?
The defendant must intentionally cause harmful or offensive contact with the plaintiff. The contact can be with the plaintiff’s body or something connected to him.
Harmful or offensive contact is by a reasonable person unless the defendant knows about the plaintiff’s particular susceptibility.
Awareness of the contact is not necessary.
What is false imprisonment?
The defendant intends to confine or restrain the plaintiff in a bounded area and does so. The restraint can be done physically or by threat of immediate physical force.
Being excluded from an area (including your house) is not imprisonment.
The time of confinement doesn’t matter other than proving damages.
The plaintiff must be aware of the confinement unless he is incapable of being aware, like an infant or mentally incompetent.
What damages are allowed/required for false imprisonment?
Nominal damages are allowed and actual damages are not needed.
What is IIED?
Defendant intentionally OR RECKLESSLY does extreme or outrageous conduct that causes severe emotional distress in the plaintiff.
Words alone can be enough.
Transferred intent does not apply, but a minority will allow it for onlookers if a family member is a target of the outrageous conduct.
What damages are allowed/required for IIED?
Nominal damages are not allowed, and Sever emotional harm must be shown.
What is a trespass to land?
The defendant voluntarily enters another’s land, including airspace to a reasonable height.
There is no intent to trespass required, only the intent to enter the land. So believing the land is yours doesn’t matter–still trespassing.
What damages are allowed/required for trespass to land?
Nominal damages are allowed, and actual damages are not necessary.
What is conversion?
The intentional destruction or wrongful possession for a significant period of time of another’s personal property.
Trespass to chattel involves less harm or shorter time.
Defendant’s belief that the property is his doesn’t matter–still a trespass/conversion.
What are the damages for conversion?
The fair market value of the chattel or replevin (return).
What damages are allowed/required for conversion?
conversion requires actual damages, and nominal damages are not permitted.
What are the damages for trespass to chattel?
The reduction in the value or the value of the loss of use
What damages are allowed/required for trespass to chattels?
Actual damages are required and nominal damages are not allowed.
What is consent in torts?
A defense to all torts. It cannot be based on duress.
It can be implied, like by participating in an activity or an emergency.
Consent is valid if the defendant reasonably believes it, even if there is none.
The defendant can’t exceed the scope of the consent.
What is capacity to consent?
The plaintiff must have the capacity to understand the consequences of consent. Children and drunk people can’t consent.
Consent and mistakes?
Consent based on a mistake is allowed so long as the defendant doesn’t know about the mistake (i.e. identity).
Consent and misrepresentations?
It cannot be based on a misrepresentation unless it’s a collateral matter–like a wrongful birthday.
Changed levels of outrageousness in IIED?
Who the Defendant is can make conduct more outrageous–common carriers and innkeepers are more likely to be outrageous.
Who the plaintiff is can also make it more outrageous, like pregnancy or children.
The defendant must know of extra sensitivities for them to be considered.
Trespass to land and proper plaintiffs?
The plaintiff can be the owner, a tenant, or anyone else with superior possession rights than the defendant.
When is self-defense allowed?
When the defendant reasonably believes an intentional tort is about to be comitted against him and he uses reasonable force to prevent it.
Duty to retreat and self defense?
There is no duty to retreat generally. There is a modern trent that retreat is necessary outside the home before using death or serious bodily injury
Retaliation and self defense?
Retaliation is not allowed for self defense. Only prevention.
Self-defense and injured bystanders?
So long as the self defense is reasonable and valid, the defendant is not liable.
When is defense of others allowed?
A defendant can protect anyone whom he reasonably believes is entitled to self-defense.
What defense is allowed for defending property?
Reasonable, non-deadly force can be used ot protected land or chattels. Retaliation is not allowed, only prevention.
Recourses if Chattel is taken?
Reasonable non-deadly force is permitted to regain possession if the original taking was illegal, you are in fresh pursuit, and a request for return would be useless or dangerous.
What is public necessity?
A defense to trespass to land, chattels, and conversion when the defendant commits a tort to avoid greater injury to the public. There is NO liability to the defendant then.
What is private necessity?
When a defendant commits a tort to prevent greater injury to a small number of persons, the defendant is only liable for actual damage caused.
Is discipline a tort?
Persons responsible for children are permitted to use reasonable force to control a child.
What is the merchant’s privilege?
A defense to false imprisonment when a shop owner reasonably believes that a person detained has shoplifted.
What is defamation?
Defamation lowers the plaintiff’s reputation in a respectful community by publishing (communicating) to a third person. It must be a statement of fact, not opinion (not just saying “in my opinion”).
It can be slander or libel.
It depends on what a reasonable person would find defamatory.
The defamed person can’t be dead.
What is the difference between slander and libel?
Slander is live speech, while writings, tv statements, oral repetitions of writings or written repetitions of speech are all libel.
Facial defamation?
Facial defamation needs no extrinsic facts to make it defamatory. “Aaron married Jennifer”