Constitutional Law Flashcards
What article of the Constitution covers federal courts?
Article 3
What types of cases are federal courts limited to taking?
actual cases and controversies that are justiciable
What is justiciability?
Wether the case/controversy is capable of judicial resolution, requiring no advisory opinions, ripe and not moot, and standing
What is an advisory opinion?
Federal courts can’t give advisory opinions, ones that lack an actual dispute between parties or lack a legally binding effect on the parties.
What are ripeness and mootness?
Ripe is too early and moot is too late. Ripeness requires a substantial hardship in absens of the review and the issues on record are fit for review. Mootness requies live controversies–ongoing injury.
What are exceptions to mootness?
If injury is capable of repetition yet evades review, the defendant voluntarily stopes but can restart at will, or in class actions, one plaintiff’s injuries continue.
What is standing?
1) . injury
2) . Causation in fact
3) . redressability
What types of injuries are justiciable?
Not ideological or generalized objections, not executive spending, but a taxpayer can challeng his own tax liability
You can also challenge congressional spending violative of the Establishment clause , but not executive spending or tax credits for contributions for private tuition.
For injunctive or declaratory relief, you must show a likelihood of harm, and the injury must be suffered personally by the plaintiff.
What exceptions are there to 3rd party standing bar?
Close relationship when the plaintiff is injured, the 3rd party is unable or unlikely to sue, and the plaintiff can adequately represent the third party
2) . organizations when the members have standing, the members’ injury is related to the prupose of the organization, and member’s participation is not required, like for individualized damages
3) . Free speech over breadth when it is not commercial speech and there is overbreadth
When do legislators have standing?
when the injury is to them or their votes personally and not an injury to an enacted bill as a whole.
What is causation under justiciability?
the plaintiff must show that hte injury is fairly traceable to the defendant
What is redressability?
the plaintiff must show that a favorable court decision can remedy the harm. Ex: not when mother sues to make state prosecute non-payment of child support
What is a political question?
Federal courts can’t do political questions, questions committed by the Constitution to other political branches or incapable or inappropriate for judicial resolution.
What is sovereign immunity?
Eleventh Amendment bar of suits OF STATE GOVERNMENTS in state or federal courts unless
1) . the state waives it,
2) . another state or federal government is suing
3) . it is bankruptcy
4) . Congress has clearly abrogated sovereign immunity under 14th Amendment powers to preserve discrimination
When can courts decline a federal constitutional claim?
When it turns on an unsettled question of state law. They generally can’t enjoin pending state proceedings
When can SCOTUS hear a case?
When there has been a final judgment by the highest state court available and not when there is an adequate and independent state grounds: i.e. the outcome would be the same regardless of the federal question’s outcome.
What article concerns Congress?
Article 1
What is the necessary and proper clause?
NOT a basis of legislative power, but a basis for Congress to use any means to achieve an enumerated power.
When can Congress tax and spend?
anytime, even to promote the general welfare. It can entice state only if the enticement is not so coercive that the state has no real choice and the strings attached are related to the spending
What does the commerce clause cover?
commerce between foreign nations, indian tribes and the states.
What does the interstate commerce clause cover?
1). instrumentalities
2). channels
3).economic activities with a substantial effect on commerce
NOT non-economic activities traditionally regulated by states.
When can Congress delegate powers?
It can delegate to agencies as long as there is some intelligble principle to guide the exercise of power
No line item veto-allowing the prsident to pick parts of the law to enact
No legislative veto–enacting a lw with the power to change/modify it later
When are Congress members immune?
Immune from criminal and civil liability for legislative acts, not speeches and publications outside of Congress.
What article governs the president?
ARt. 2
How does appointments work?
The President appoints ambassadors, federal judges, and officers of the US with majority approval by the Senate
For inferior officers (not executive branch officials), Congress appoints them, but can vest this in the PResident, department heads, or the judiciary
How does removal work?
The prsendent can remove high level executive officers at will
Congress can limit other officials’ removal to good cause.
Congress can remove executive officials through impeachment process
Who can the president pardon?
Anyone convicted of federal crime other than impeachment, and not civil liability
War powers?
Congress declares war and the president is commander in chief. When they crossover, it’s often not resolveable as a political question. They have to negotiate
What is a treaty?
An agreement the president negotiates with other countries. They require 2/3 senate approval. It trumps all state law and existing federal law.
What is an executive agreement?
An action by the president that requires no Senate approval, trumps all state law, but no federal law.
What are grounds for impeachment?
treason, high crimes and misdemeanors, and bribery.
What is the process for impeachment?
A majority of the house passes articles of impeachment and the senate convicts with 2/3.
Presidential Immunity?
The president has absolute immunity from civil damages for any actions arguably within his official responsibility, but no private immunity for conduct prior to taking office.
Executive privilege?
protects all communications related to presidential duties unless outweighed by other IGO’s, like evidence in a criminal trial.
What is the 10th Amendment?
Powers not granted to the federal government is reserved by the states. And the federal government can’t compel state to enact or administer federal programs.
What is preemption?
Express preemption when Congress says
Implied conflict when it is impossible to follow state and federal law
Implied field when extensive federal regulation indicates a Congressional intent to occupy the field.
What is the dormant commerce clause?
It prohibits state laws that discriminate against or unduly burden ISC.
Discrinatory laws are invalid unless necessary to achieve an IGO unrelated to economic protectionism and there is no less discriminatory means.
Exception if the state is acting as a market participant or there is Congressional approval
What is P & I of ARt. IV?
It prohibits state law that discriminate against OUT OF STATE US CITIZENS only for an important commercial act (basically livelihood) or for a fundamental right.
Discriminatory laws are invalid unless necessary to achive an IGO and there are no less discriminatory means. It has no exceptions.
What is P & I of 14th?
It prohibits state laws that interfere with interstate travel and the right to petition the federal government. NOT BOR rights.
People have the right to enter and leave the state and all state citizens are treated the same. No right to leave the country though.
STate taxation of ISC?
discriminatory taxes are generally invalid. non-discriminatory taxes are valid if there is a substantial nexus between the taxpayer and the state and the tax is fairly apportions to the business done or benefits received in the state.
What does the 13th Amendment do?
Ban slavery by everyone, not just state actors, as all other Constitution does
What rights have not been incorporated by hte 14th?
right to not have soldiers quarted in home, right to grand jury, right to jury in civil cases, right agaisnt excessive fines