Torts Flashcards
Negligence Prima Facie Case
In order to prevail on a claim for negligence, a plaintiff must show duty, breach, causation (actual and proximate), and damages
Duty
A person owes a duty to act as a reasonable prudent person would in the same or similar circumstances.
Maj: Cardozo foreseeable in zone of danger
Min: Andrews everyone
Duty - Standard of Care - Statutory
If a statutory standard is applicable, it must be followed to satisfy one’s duty
Actual Cause
Show defendant’s conduct was the but-for cause of injury
Proximate Cause
Show that injury was foreseeable in order to recover
Damages
Plaintiff must show actual damages to recover
Vicarious Liability - Respondeat Superior
An employer is liable for the negligence of their employees for all acts committed in the course and scope of their employment
The employee is under direct supervision and control of his employer
Employers are not responsible for the torts or negligence of independent contractors unless the IC was negligently hired or the duty he performed was nondelegable
Contribution and Indemnity
Vicariously liable employers can sue employees for reimbursement due to employee’s own actual negligence
Libel
Published or written defamation
Truth is a defense
Damages are presumed
Defamation
Defamation involves making untrue statements about a person or entity to the public
Two types: libel (published or written) and slander (spoken)
Damages need not be proven for slander but must be proven for libel
Defamation for Public Figure
Public figures must prove malicious intent on the part of defendant for claim
Private Nuisance
Defendant is continuously, substantially (reasonable), and unreasonably interfering with the plaintiff’s use and enjoyment of her property
Private Nuisance Defense - unusually sensitive
Plaintiff cannot be unreasonably sensitive
Public Nuisance
Defendant’s actions are causing health and safety concerns to citizens
Public Nuisance Defense - Damages Not Unique
Private citizens that bring public nuisance claims have to prove that their damages are unique compared to the rest of the public
Intentional Trespass
Requires a plaintiff to show that the defendant intended to intrude onto someone else’s property and damages. Can be done by defendant himself or extension of his person
Negligent Trespass
Defendant entered onto someone else’s property through recklessness or negligence (duty, breach, causation, damages)
Defenses to Trespass
Private Necessity: emergency situation and are attempting to save own lives in the process (only liable for nominal damages)
Public Necessity: if the public is in an imminent emergency situation (not liable for any damages)
Assault
Intentional act that causes apprehension of fear of an imminent harmful for offensive contact to another
Can be shown by volitional act y the defendant
Battery
An intentional or offensive touching of another or another’s person without consent
Trespass to Land
TPL is the unlawful entry onto the land of another without consent
Vicarious Liability - parent/child
Liability for third parties exists if the parent has known of a child’s behavior and fails to prevent their behavior
Trespass to Chattel
TTC is the trespassory taking or damaging of the personal property of another without consent
Defense of Others
Defendant is permitted to use force reasonably necessary under the circumstances to defend another person from harm
Transferred Intent
TI for tort applies when a person intends to commit a tort against a specific person but commits a tort against another person
Private Nuisance
A substantial and unreasonable interference with the plaintiff’s use and enjoyment of their property. Whether a nuisance is unreasonable is looked at from the prospective of an average member of the community, and particular uses are not considered
Public Nuisance
A public nuisance is an unreasonable interference with the health, safety, and wellness of the community. To sue for a claim of public nuisance, the plaintiff must have suffered a unique harm that is different than the communities harm generally
Coming to the nuisance
When someone comes to the nuisance (moves into the neighborhood) for the purpose of suing, this is a valid defense for nuisance