Topic 3 : Class And Educational Achievement Flashcards
What is cultural deprivation?
The idea that some young people underachieve in education because of cultural deficiencies in their family background. Such as inadequate socialisation, failings in pre school, language and values towards education
Causes of WC underachievement
Parental attitudes towards education
Amount of cultural capital
Restricted code of language
Subcultural attitudes and values
Parents level of education
What did Sugarman argue
WC subculture has 4 factors that cause a barrier for educational achievement
Immediate gratification
Fatalism
Collectivism
Present-time orientation
Feinstein
Main reason why wc underachieve was because of parents lack of interest in their children’s education
WC parents unlikely to give their children educational toys that will stimulate their thinking skills - this affects their intellectual development so that when they begin school they are disadvantaged compared to the MC kids
Goodman and Gregg
Quality of mother - child interactions and amount of time spent with children
Parents reading to young children
Parental involvement in school - helping with HW, parents evenings
Bourdieu’ a cultural capital
Each class has its own framework of ideas and values - habitus
MC habitus gives advantage to MC students
Accent / clothes / music etc. allow MC to fit in - this cultural capital helps students excel in school and makes them comfortable because school values are more in line with their own cultural values
How economic capital has a role in education
Tuition / private education
How cultural capital has a role in education
Parents create an environment at home where they can thrive, help with homework, take them to culturally enriching places and have an active interest
How social capital has a role in education
Know how to get in the best schools and build relationships with teachers
How symbolic capital has a role in education
Could help with admissions or private / selective schools
Sullivan
Students who achieved higher:
Read complex fiction
Watched documentaries and current affairs
Attended ‘high culture’ events
Ball et al. - how do parents use their capital in education
Economic capital - move homes, tuition, choose independent schools
Social capital - more contacts in education, headteachers etc.
Cultural capital - more knowledge of education system, league tables, admission procedures
Reay et al
Students with lower cultural capital less likely to attend Russell group universities
Evaluation of the role of cultural capital in educational achievement
Sullivan - cultural capital was not the biggest determinant of educational success
UCAS admissions - students from lower social classes more likely to attend post 1992 universities
Bernstein
Elaborate v restricted
Schools and teachers use elaborated code - schools are MC institutions
Elaborated:
Grammatically complex
Bored vocabulary
MC
Restricted:
Grammatically simple
Narrow selection of words
WC
How does speech codes impact education
Teachers speak in elaborated code
Education resources written in elaborated code
External examinations written in elaborated code
Evaluation of Bernstein
Students learn the elaborated code throughout their schooling
Restricted code and elaborated code can be interchangeable in social situations
Evaluation of the role of speech codes
Educational performance of Chinese and Indian students
Douglas’s study
Longitudinal study on children and the value parents place on education
WC parents placed less value on education so kids were less ambitious
MC parents showed more interest (visiting schools etc.)
Therefore, parental interest is the key factor in explaining the class differences in educational achievement
Evans’ study
She found that WC parents did encourage a good education bur she found it was differences in primary socialisation
MC mothers use formal style learning in their play early on so this builds up a learning platform
WC mothers do not have formal learning styles through primary socialisation
Therefore MC have a headstart
Evans rejects CDT - she sees it as different not worse