The social construction of individual differences Flashcards
What is authenticity
the quality of being real or true
Common View of the Authentic Person
A person is unique, with a self-contained mind and consciousness
People are the centre of their own experiences, owning their thoughts and feelings
Classical Psychology
Divides the individual along broad lines
- Internal/External: Internal = authentic self.
- Stability/Instability: Events attributed to internal (stable) or external (unstable) factors.
- Stability linked to good mental health.
- Globality/Specificity: Explains both commonalities and uniqueness
Issues with Classical Psychology
Divisions useful for research, but less applicable in real-world contexts
Measurements often force-choice or one-dimensional
Excludes cultural, historical, and social factors
Intersectionality
Explores how interlocking systems impact marginalized groups
Main claim: Social class, sexual orientation, gender, and age are interlocked and cannot be understood in isolation
Vygotsky (1896-1943)
emphasized that society provides psychological tools, a set of social devices that shape thinking and learning
- believed language is a crucial tool in cognitive development, acting as a bridge between social interaction and internal thought
Holtzkamp (1927-1995)
Argued that psychology often studies abstract concepts, assuming isolated stimuli cause responses in subjects
emphasized the importance of understanding people’s lived experiences, interactions, and the historical context in which they occur
Critical Psychology
Knowledge and truth are created by institutions (e.g., universities, research labs) and processes (e.g., peer-reviewed journals)
- Knowledge is internalized by individuals and mediated by language, which makes thoughts and concepts possible
Socio-political critique on critical psychology
Psychology can be seen as a tool for social control, defining and “treating” people considered problematic by society
Personality tests may function as mechanisms of control
According to Burr (1995), our understanding of the world is shaped by cultural and linguistic frameworks that exist before birth and are reproduced through language and social interaction
Postmodernism
Language is seen as more than just a tool; it creates vocabularies that shape how we interpret experiences
- Disease, illness, and deficit models contribute to power dynamics, where the practitioner is the expert and the client is a passive recipient
What is anti-essentialism
Human beings do not have a single, determined nature there are no ‘essences’ inside people that make them what they are
What is anti-realism
We cannot construct a system of knowledge that perfectly maps onto reality
Knowledge is always structured from a particular perspective
Social Constructionism
A critical approach in the social sciences that emerged in the 1970s-80s
Focuses on how people describe, explain, and make sense of the world
Subjectivity in Social Constructionism
Psychological experiences are subjective; perception is filtered through mental schemas
What is solipsism
only one’s mind/reality exists
- Social constructionism is no solipsism
What is the main belief of social constructionism
Social constructionism claims that things can be both real and our creation
- While the world exists independently, it is structureless until we impose meanings on it
What are performative utterances?
Statements that perform an action, not just describe a situation (e.g., “I promise”)
What are illocutionary acts in speech theory?
Actions performed via utterances, such as making requests, promises, or declarations
How did Butler extend the concept of performativity?
Butler applied performativity to gender, arguing that gender is not innate but is performed through repeated actions, behaviors, and language based on societal norms
What is the idea of gender as performance according to Butler?
Gender is a series of repeated performances, not an inherent trait. We “do” gender through actions, behaviors, and language, creating the illusion of a stable gender identity
How does performativity challenge gender norms?
Performativity allows for the subversion of gender norms, showing that gender identities are socially constructed and can be disrupted
What role does performativity play in cultural and social contexts?
performativity examines how social norms and identities are constructed and maintained through repeated actions and performances
How does performativity align with social constructivism?
supports the idea that many aspects of social reality are constructed through human actions and interactions, rather than being purely natural or inherent
How does gender distinction relate to traits?
Traits used to distinguish gender are found in both sexes, and what makes one person different from another often relates to what those traits signify rather than any intrinsic or innate quality
Should psychology focus on what is real/authentic or on how it becomes and is performed?
Psychology can explore both what is real/authentic and how identity, including gender, becomes constructed and performed, focusing on the processes by which traits and distinctions are socially enacted
What is the critical stance in social constructionism?
critically challenges taken-for-granted knowledge, arguing that categories we use to describe things (like “classical” or “pop” music) are not inherent in the nature of things but socially constructed
What does historical and cultural specificity mean in social constructionism?
It means that the categories and concepts we use to understand the world are shaped by a particular culture and historical moment, like concepts of childhood or sexuality