The Secularisation Thesis Flashcards
what is the secularisation thesis?
the idea that religious beliefs are becoming less plausible and less appealing so religion is declining in importance
what is Wilson’s definition of secularisation?
‘the process whereby religious thinking, practice and institutions lose significance.’
what is an exclusivist definition of religion?
sees it as involving belief in the supernatural
what is an inclusivist definition of religion? and what does this definition mean for religion?
sees it as including a wide range of beliefs and activities to which people give sacred qualities. such a definition means religion is unlikely to decline
what does Aldridge say about inclusivist definitions of religion?
such all embracing evidence for the continued existence of religion is not telling us anything it is ‘a mere trick of definition.’
why is it difficult for secularisation supporters to show that society was more religious in the past?
- historical records about the strength of religion are sparse
- data collection wasn’t reliable
- there were no opinion polls
most people 150 years ago couldn’t read or write so records that exist are about a small privileged section of society and tell us little about the religiousness of ordinary people
the first census in …… found that …..% of people in england and wales attended church
1851
40%
who said that in victorian britain church attendance was a socially necessary part of middle class respectability
Martin
what does Davie say about believing without belonging?
that religion can be private and people increasingly believe without belonging meaning religious people aren’t included in statistics
the ….. census asked ‘what is your religion?’ …% answered with a religion.
what is the assumption this question makes?
2011
68%
that people should have a religion
a YouGov study in …… asked ‘are you religious?’ and only …..% said yes
what is this question open to?
2011
29%
the possibility that people may not have one
why are statistics on religion difficult to interpret? 4 reasons
- what counts as practicing may vary for different groups
- information about small groups often unavailable and some may exaggerate to increase image of importance
- lots of practice isn’t recorded e.g. christian housechurch movement
- different denominations use different criteria for membership so apparently similar figures may be recording different things e.g. the church of england record who is baptised, whether they attend etc while Jehovah’s witnesses only record the people who show the high commitment demanded
what could be causes of secularisation? 6 reasons
- declining attraction
- many functions religion used to carry out have been taken over by the welfare state
- traditional religions have faced challenges to teachings and growth of science
- changing leisure patterns
- decline in trust of metanarratives
- religious pluralism means religion can no longer command respect from the whole of society
who argued that the growth of scientific explanations for why things happen has undermined religious belief?
Bruce
the …. census found …. people in england and wales had no religion
2011
1/4
who suggests religious beliefs are now a last resort concerned with areas of life which science cannot control?
give a quote
bruce
‘when we have tried every cure for cancer, some of us pray.’
what does Bruce argue about Davie’s idea of believing without belonging?
that it is a halfway house
churches used to disapprove of divorce, cohabitation etc but are now forced to accept it and water down beliefs what does this show?
a decline in strength of religion in society and influence on people’s actions