The Nature of God Flashcards
Transcendent
Outside time and space
Impersonal
Beyond us, other worldly
Immanent
Within time and space, happening now
Anselm on timelessness
God is ‘that than which nothing greater can be conceived’.
God is timeless, as a consequence of his omnipotence.
God is impassible, simple (no parts) and outside of time to preserve his supremacy.
God is eternal
Time is contingent and God is necessary - he does not need time to exist
Anselm on free will
Is our timely existence pre-determined?
For Anslem, freedom lies in the choice and rectitude.
Free will is the ability to choose the right thing because one wants to choose it.
God by nature cannot choose evil.
God knows what will happen in the future, however it is, in time, changeable by our choices.
Rectitude
Doing the right thing
The eternal present
Anselm
The concept of eternity is not built on our concept of time.
Non-temporal concept.
The eternity is God is in another dimension, in which all periods of time are contained.
Anselm - Language and logic
Terms such as ‘foreknowledge or ‘predestined’ are terms which invoke aspects of time, so when we apply them to God to try to grasp his knowledge and action because we have no other vocabulary- we are working at the very edge of their meaning.
Richard Swinburne
Rejects the concept of God as timeless.
It is unbiblical to argue that God is wholly outside of time. e.g God now does this, now does that, now destroys Jerusalem, now lets the exiles return home, he forgives, brings, punishes and warns.
A timeless God is ‘radically incoherent’, it makes no sense of the life of worship and prayer.
How can a loving God be unable to answer prayers in the present?
God is everlasting
Paul Tillich
A timeless God would be lifeless, yet we speak of a ‘living God’.
Karl Barth
God is not timeless; the incarnation of Christ is an example of God acting intentionally and decisively in human history.
Alvin Plantinga - Free Will
Free will means being radically free.
Choice implies selecting something for a reason.
An action is only moral if it is freely done.
Plantinga - Possible worlds
God can do anything that is logically possible- the logically impossible is meaningless.
A world with moral actions by free creatures is a better world than any alternative.
A world with no evil and free choice is logically absurd.
God is omnibenevolent because he made a world where the greater good is possible.
Isaiah 57:15
“For thus says the high and lofty one, who inhabits eternity, whose name is Holy”
Nicholas Wolterstorff
An eternal God appeals to people because of how it differs from humans’ experience of life in the physical world.
We try and stave off time, and we regret this past, suggesting that things that change are imperfect.
Boethius on eternity
God is eternal - eternity being “the whole, simultaneous and perfect possession of unending life”
Life is not an experience of events following one another, so it does not involve change.
He is limitless and changeless
All of time is present to God
Aquians on eternity
Heavily influenced by boethius
God exists unendingly, he is outside of time, so it doesnt pass him.
It is in his nature to exist.
Atemporality
The state of being outside the time process.
Descartes on God’s omnipotence
God can do anything, including the logically impossible.
The phrase only applies to humans- nothing is logically impossible to him.
He can change the laws of physics at will.
His attributes are therefore not limited by human logic- he can be both timeless and omnibenevolent (be with us and be outside of time)
Criticisms of Descartes view on God’s omnipotence
Too vague?
What about a stone that is unable to be lifted?
Does this make God unpredictable and untrustworthy?
Problem of evil
Making a circle into a square is nonsense- lack of knowledge not power.
Why doesn’t God prevent evil?
Peter Vardy on God’s omnipotence
“God is limited by the universe he chose to create” He can do the logically impossible but chose not too so that free will isnt compromised. —- if God really is omnipotent he shouldnt have to compromise anything.
3 views of God’s omnipotence
- God can do anything, even the logically impossible
- God can do the logically possible
- God can do anything that is logically possible for God to do