The Debate and Differential Diagnosis Flashcards
How long has the definition, etiology, sign and symptoms, treatment, and outcomes of CAPD been debated?
More than 70 years
What are the issues that complicate the diagnosis of CAPD?
There are many who question whether (C)APD is a separate and distinct disorder or a disorder of non-auditory processes
Such as cognition, language, memory, and attention that are not only tightly intertwined, but also closely integrated with auditory perception
Does CAPD remain universally ill-defined and poorly understood?
Yes
What has resulted from the uncertainty of a CAPD diagnosis?
(C)APD is not in DSM-V
(C)APD also is not a disability/disorder allowed under the Individualized Education Plan (IEP)
Children diagnosed only with (C)APD may receive accommodations under the 504 Plan
What is a 504 plan?
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
“No one with a disability can be excluded from participating in federally funded programs or activities, including elementary, secondary, or postsecondary schooling”
Spells out modifications/accommodations needed for students to have an opportunity to perform at the same level as their peers
(wheelchair ramps, blood sugar monitoring, peanut-free lunch, home instruction, keyboard for notetaking)
What is the difference between a 504 plan and an IEP?
A 504 plan, which falls under the civil-rights law, seeks to level the playing field so that those students can safely pursue the same opportunities as everyone else (temporary or permanent)
An Individualized Education Plan (IEP), which falls under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), and is also federally mandated, is associated with providing educational services (more involved; only represent a small subset of all students with disabilities)
What are the 14 disabilities that are eligible for an IEP?
Autism
Deaf-blindness
Deafness
Developmental delay
Emotional disturbance
Intellectual disability
Multiple disabilities
Orthopedic impairment
Traumatic brain injury (TBI)
Visual impairment, including blindness
Hearing impairment
Speech or language impairment
Developmental learning disability (DLD)
Other health impairments that limit strength, vitality, or alertness (asthma, ADHD, diabetes, epilepsy, heart conditions, etc.)
What is lax criterion?
Abnormal performance on a single test (> 2 SD below mean)
What is strict criterion?
Abnormal performance on all tests (> 2 SD below mean)
What is intermediate criterion?
Abnormal performance on at least 2 tests (> 2 SD below mean)
Abnormal performance on at least 1 test (> 3 SD below mean)
*We will always follow this one because it is more sensitive
What is the AAA criteria?
Abnormal performance on at least one ear for 2 tests (> 2 SD below mean)
*Could be for different ears
Is there a gold standard for CAPD?
No
Essential to move the field forward
It is the best available method for establishing the presence or absence of CAPD (also called reference standard tests)
What is an index test?
A test under evaluation
Without a reference standard test, it is not possible to determine the diagnostic accuracy or validity of index tests
Do many diagnostic tests used to diagnose CAPD lack scientific basis or a well-defined utility?
Yes
These tests also are not used uniformly across professionals
Further, behavioral tests do not always differentiate or definitively diagnose (C)APD from other neurodevelopmental conditions
Have an efficiency (combined sensitivity and specificity) ranging from 68% to 90%
Is it difficult to make distinctions between CAPD and language-related issues?
Yes
Because most CAPD tests are based on verbal material/responses
BSA requires difficulty in both speech and non-speech sounds
Are there physiologic markers specific to CAPD?
No
Nothing that can be used to distinguish CAPD from other developmental disorders
What are non-auditory variables that may confound CAPD test interpretations?
Motivation
Attention
Cooperation
Test interpretation (performed the same way it was standardized, age appropriate, skill of the scorer in administering the test)
What are some criticisms of the CAPD test battery?
(C)APD tests tap into multi-modal processes such as attention, working memory, and cognition
Unimodal CAPD tests can not be validated from multimodal deficits in school age children
Some believe that CAPD tests should only assess auditory perceptual dysfunction (made with non-speech sounds so they are less likely to tap into memory and language)
What would happen if multiple modalities are shown to be impaired in those with CAPD?
It would argue for a supramodal problem
This would move it from the audiologic domain to the psychological domain and possibly outside our scope of practice
Do many disorders produce similar behavioral/academic profiles?
Yes
True (C)APD may coexist with these disorders but is not the result of these disorders
Who is in the CAPD team?
Audiologist
SLP
Classroom or special ed teacher
Pediatrician/physician
School counselor/psychiatrist
Social worker
Parents
Why does CAPD need a team?
Because it is heterogeneous
What is the general profile on children with CAPD?
Academic difficulties
Family history
Sporadic results on test batteries
Difficulties exacerbated in adverse listening conditions
Difficulty following multi-step directions, and so on
*This can also be said for other conditions
Is attention critical to higher level processing?
Yes
Is a greater comorbidity between ADHD and CAPD suspected?
Yes
The question is whether (C)APD causes some attention deficits or whether a more global ADHD negatively impacts auditory processing
(C)APD is considered a condition of bottom-up primarily auditory perceptual deficiencies
ADHD is considered a top-down global attention/executive function disorder
What is top-down processing?
Information processing that is guided by higher level cognitive processes that draw on experiences and expectations to construct perceptions
Top-down processing occurs any time a higher-level concept influences interpretation of lower-level sensory data
Cues are based on previous experience or knowledge
Example: light bulb over cartoon means idea, don’t need to be told what that means
What is bottom-up processing?
A form of information processing that is guided by input
Perception is data driven, therefore, most sensory information such as sound is an example of bottom-up processing
Senses allow us to interpret the scene around us
But how a person’s expectations, knowledge, and experience will shape that scene is the influence of top-down processing
Example: 15 people in a room hear the same song but there may be different emotions that song will evoke in each person based on their life experiences
Do many professionals believe that there can be a bidirectional interaction between central auditory processing and attention?
Yes
Both are essential for optimal speech processing
But CAPD and ADHD are distinct