The Criminal Trial Process Flashcards
What is original jurisdiction?
The ability of a court to hear a case on first instance
What is appellate jurisdiction?
The authority of a court to review matters on appeal from another court
What is a coronial inquest?
A court hearing conducted by a coroner to help determine the manner and cause of death
Who are judges?
Judicial officers who preside over intermediate and superior courts
District and Supreme Court btw
Who are Magistrates?
Judcial officers who preside over hearings in the Local Court
What are the 2 types of prosecutors?
Public prosecutors and Police prosecutors
What is the Burden of Proof?
In criminal matters, the responsibility of the prosecution to prove the case against the accused.
What is the standard of proof?
The level of proof required for a party to suceed in court.
How is legal aid granted?
Must go through a means test
Only 8% can actually access this
What does ‘Beyond reasonable doubt mean?’
The standard of proof required in a criminal case for a person to be found guilty
What is a Complete Defence?
A justification for the accused’s actions and if successfully proven will either result in all charges being dropped or acquitted
What are the six types of Complete Defences?
- Mental illness or insanity
- Automatism
- Mistake
- Self defence or neccesity
- Duress
- Consent
What are characertistics of the Coroner’s Court?
Coroner’s Act 2009
- Original jurisdiction for investigating the cause of suspicious deaths
- Investigates unexplained fires or explosions
- More inquisitorial and coroner calls witnesses and can give evidence at the inquest
What does automatism refer to?
The idea that the actions of the accused were involunatry and could not be controlled and thus mens rea cannot be established. e.g. medical episodes
What is duress?
When someone is coerced or forced to do something against their will from someone else
What is self defence?
That the defendant acted in defence of self, another or
property; only accepted in limited circumstances and
only for reasonable force
Why is using Self Defence as a complete defence risky?
Self defence as a complete defence can only be uesed when reasonable force in terms of the propotion to the crime is justified. What ‘reasonable force’ means to a jury can be quite different to the accused.
What are the charecteristics of the Local Court?
The Local Court Act 2007 (NSW)
- No jury, presided by a Magistrate
- Oversees commital processes
- Hears bail hearings and AVO hearings
- No appellate jurisdiction
- Hears most summary offences
- Up to 100,000 in civil cases
What are characteristics of the Children’s Court?
Children’s Court Act 1987 (NSW)
- Specialised Court
- Closed court
- Presided over Magistrate and has no jury
- Children’s Court magistrates have specialised training in dealing with youth matters, and proceedings, formalities and available sentences are different from those applicable in other courts.
What factors affect the court that a criminal matter may be heard in?
- Seriousness and nature of the offence
- Whether it is a first time or repeat offence
- Age of the accused
- Type of hearing (e.g. bail)
- Is crime an offence under state or federal law
What are disadvantages of Charge Negotiation?
- Tells prosecution how you will conduct defence
- In order to get Prosecution to withdraw case, you may have to highlight weaknesses in their case and thus give them an oppurtunity to fix them
- Intimidation or manipulation
What are charecteristics of the District Court?
Distcrict Court Act 1973 (NSW)
- Holds apellate jurisdiction for Children’s Court and Local Court
- Original jurisdiction for civil claims up to $750,000
- Hears most indictable offences except murder and treason
- Case heard by judge and jury
- Matters are more formal and will take longer to be heard
What are characertistics of the Drug Court?
- Only a person who has plead guilty, is over 18, highly likely for fulltime imprisonment and dependent on drugs can apply
- Emerged as a resuslt of growing disenchantment with the ability of traditional criminal justice approaches to provide long term solutions to cycle of drug use and crime
What are charecteristics of the Supreme Court?
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW)
- Apellate jurisdiction for lower and intermediate courts
- Original jurisdiction for civil matters over $750,000
- Hears most serious criminal matters and has original jurisdiction for Commonwealth prosecutionsfor serious breaches of the Corporations Law
- Highest level of State Formaility
What are characteristics of the Court of Criminal Appeal
- State’s highest court for criminal matters
- Can hear appeals from District Court and Supreme Court
- Usually heard by 3 judges sometimes 5
- Appellate jurisdiction from all levels