Test 2 Flashcards

1
Q

How do animals experience pain?

A

Vertebraes- sense harmful send it to spine, remove hand, get rid of stimulus-
Concious recognition of pain- neurons create sensation in pain- associated with fear, stress
Hurt animasl- tend to wound, make noises, avoid future harm
Osyter, worm and jelly fish- experience nocioception and not concious pain
Those that are smarter- may experience the concious pain
Remember physical sensation- recognixe when pain is cominh

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Why Use Animals?

A

can conduct causation experiments

can stimulate/lesion any tissue

can assay, record from, or extract any tissue
can give unapproved drugs
can alter gene expression (temporarily or permanently)
can control pre-exposures- life history
cheaper, faster, less highly regulated- gestational period= 3 weeks and make 8-12 babies
no malingering- faking it, exaggerating , no demand characteristics- don’t change response based on observation

Can do more with animals than humans
Rat used the most for pain research followed by mice

Boomed bc of transgenic mice
C57-black 6 mouse inbred- making genetic clones brain stem and dicephlon- similar to humans
Mouse brain is flat, has no folds

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Why Use Animals?

A

can conduct causation experiments

can stimulate/lesion any tissue

can assay, record from, or extract any tissue
can give unapproved drugs
can alter gene expression (temporarily or permanently)
can control pre-exposures- life history
cheaper, faster, less highly regulated- gestational period= 3 weeks and make 8-12 babies
no malingering- faking it, exaggerating , no demand characteristics- don’t change response based on observation

Can do more with animals than humans
Rat used the most for pain research followed by mice

Boomed bc of transgenic mice
C57-black 6 mouse inbred- making genetic clones brain stem and dicephlon- similar to humans
Mouse brain is flat, has no folds

onsequentialist Ethics
The normative ethical position holding that the consequences
of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness of that conduct.- focus on serving greater good, grey zones

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Pain and Utilitarianism

A

Consequentialism= subcategory of this
Maximize pleasure and minimize painPain and Utilitarianism

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Pain and Utilitarianism

A

Consequentialism= subcategory of this
Maximize pleasure and minimize painPain and Utilitarianism

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What are we trying to model?

A

Central sensitization- hyperactive cns- brain or spinal cord causin. Pain
non nocioceptor neuons= cns neurons
Inflamattion- meant to repair damage, causing sensitization
High threshold- need large stimulus to cause nocioception
Neuropathic and csn- pathological
Csn- fobromyalgia and only in cns, not nocioception

NOCERITA
NEUROPATHIC
CORA SENSITATION

system aystuncton
Neurons
Nociceptor and
non-nacicentor
Nociceptor and non-nociceptor
Non-nociceptor
Site
Peripheral and central
Peripheral and central
nervous system
Central nervous
SYSICE
winico
setting
Acute trauma
arthritis
Nerve lesions diabetic neuropathy,
shingles, carpet tunne
Fibromyalgia and a
volesy or outer pon
FunCLOI
healing/repair,
patholocica
ratholodice
Patholodica
rall
sensitivity
hien or low tiresnold Low tresno

Low tiresnore

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Chronic pain models in rodents

A

Inflammatory pain
Can be modeled in rodents by the injection of chemical inflammatory agents and irritants
Common models include foot, ankle or knee joint injections of carrageenan, complete Freund’s adjuvant (CFA), capsaicin, formalin- preserves tissue, zymosan, cinnamaldehyde, mustard oil- foreign and cause immune response
Different agents induce different resolution time courses.
CFA recruits neutrophils and macrophages to the site of injection.
Cells that cause infklammation- give rise to nocioception
Cytokines and and white blood cells- cause inflammatory response
Injecting different dosed of carrageenan- seaweed extract- changes sensitixation easily

Pay attention to change in time- can tell you what test used

Inflammatory pain- last up to 8 weejs for mice
Differences in pain sensitivity based on what used and dose

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Formalin phases mimic neuronal activity

A

Inflammatory teste
Measures- nicioceptive defensive behaiour, prevent or respond to to pain
Example= lick paw/wounds, cold water

Injected into hind paw- starts to lick paw
Purple= quiescent- calms Dowm
Then picks up again in late phase(central spinal cord activity)
Interested most in late phase
First 10 minutes= activation nocioceptor
C fiber- detetcts nocioception

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Hyperalgesic priming

A

Hyperalgesic priming
Carrageenan or CFA is injected into the paw of a group of animals. This will resolve over a couple of hours or days.
After the resolution of inflammatory sensitivity, a second inflammatory substance is
injected into the same region (i.e., PGE2- cause inflammation)
Sensitivity is significantly longer in duration than what is observed in a group of animals that did not receive the first injection (naïve). Tests neuronal pain memory and plasticity
Hyperalgesic priming- if hyperalgesia affects subsequent experience

Inject pge2, have transient pain response but if before, inject inflammation- will experience more pain for longer- bc of inflammation sensitizing neurons, have memory of pain, want to protect self, change threshold

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Musculoskeletal pain

A

Musculoskeletal pain
Pain originating from muscle, bone or joints (i.e., OA and RA)
Most common symptom reported in pain patients
OA is modeled with injection of monosodium-iodoacetate into the joint or
surgical transection of ligaments
RA modeled with injection of collagen and CFA into the knee joint. Can cause
release of proinflammatory cytokines (IL-1, IL-6, TNFa) Inflammation causes release of inflammatory cytokines
DBAv strain- susceptible to collagen artritis- when inject it makes it more inflammatory

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Neuropathic pain

A

Neuropathic pain
Pain caused by damage or disease of the somatosensory nervous system-MS
Surgically induced in periphery of rodents by stretching, compression, or transection of peripheral nerves (i.e., sciatic nerve)
Non-surgical models include chemotherapy-induced lesions, multiple sclerosis, diabetes and viral infection
Surgical Non-surgical
Chemotherapy Paclitaxal, oxiplatin, cause pain, chemotherapeutic induced
Diabetes  streptozotocin (STZ)- targets b cells, disrupting insulin production, causing hypogylcemia Postherpetic neuralgia  herpes varicella- zoster virus- shingles pain, this is when left with shingles pain
After a stroke- especially in thalamus
Target leg or foot- most accessible and easy to test
Spare nerve injury- cut two nerves, leaving sural nerve and it becomes hyperexcitable, causing more pain
Cci- tie off sciatica- causing slow strangulation, prevents oxygen floe, kills of nerves- chronic constriction injury
Cci and sni- used widely

Surgical- models trauma, cut nerve, car crash

Meausre sensitivity in feet
Neuropathic pain occurs first in legs bc these are longest nerves- more susceptible

Occurs after 2-3 weeks

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Visceral pain models

A

Visceral pain models
Pain in the abdomen, chest and pelvic organs
Commonly induced using chemicals or trauma
Bowel injection of capsaicin, mustard oil or zymosan- cell wall of yeast, activates immune system- getting rid of agent causes pain or bowel distension
Researchers don’t have immediate access to the organs. Instead, will measure changes in behaviour including spontaneous pain, grooming of the region, torso constrictions. Capsaicin- chemical found in spicy things

Mustard oil- burning sensation

Rything response- mouse elongates abdomen and constricts torso – to induce, inject acetic acid
magnesium sulfate
hyper-/hypotonic saline
Bradykinin- released during inflammation, causes sensitization

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Pain testing in rodents

A

How do we assess rodent pain
Evoked behaviour and spontaneous behaviour
Mechanical and thermal stimuli  allodynia and hyperalgesia
Spontaneous behaviour  facial expressions and quality of life

Mechanical evoked behaviour tests
Series of monofilaments applied to hindpaw (von Frey test)
Positive response  withdrawal response following application of filament
VF calculates force required to evoke withdrawal in 50% of animals
R-S calculates mechanical pressure threshold of deep tissue.
Other tests include pinprick test and brush test.
Typically use von frey test- von frey filaments applied to bottom of foot and see its response, can determine threshold and pain response- keep inc strength until it responds- then go down
Apply different force of filament until it responds then go down one level – hone in on threshold

Apply pain threshold dec
Randall-Selitto test- apply pressure- done for rats, put paw in clamp and once animal makes response- threshold
Vs and rs are mechanical tests

Changes pain responses

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Thermal evoked behaviour tests

A

Thermal evoked behaviour tests
Hot or cold temperature
More noxious the stimulus, the faster the animal’s tail will flick, paw removed,
paw licking or animal escapes
Common tests include tail flick, hot plate, cold plate, acetone evaporation test Why do we need all these- get at different pain pathways and responses

Flick tail when neuronl activation of spinal nerve
Even when disturb brain function- still occurs- spinal function
Latncy to firt response- how long for one of these responses to occur

C- expose heat once at a time, if have injured side can use non injured as control
Acetone test- dries the skin, its cold, if have injurt esp neuropathic, this turns into cold pain- flicking of paw

Apply dry ice under glass floor- cold floor

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Spontaneous behaviour tests

A

Spontaneous behaviour tests
Can involve measuring licking in response to formalin, capsaicin, mustard oil, acetic acid – nocifensive behaviour, causes rything
Animal’s gait, weight bearing behaviour, conditioned place preference, facial
grimacing in response to an injury C- total weight sitribution- cat walk test
nocifensive be- nocioception and defensive behavoiour- escaping, licking- meant to protect anaimal

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

A Measure of Spontaneous Pain in Mice: The Mouse
Grimace Scale

A

Bulges nose, puffs cheeks, tighten ears, get pulled back

The Mouse Grimace Scale
Works For Pain of Moderate Duration
Only changes in response to specific stimuli
30 min- a day- chsnge in pain face
Secobsa- minutes probaby unable to capture the face chabge

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Conditioning Methods to Study Pain

A

Operant Conditioning
learned escape from pain- learn to go to nonpainful area
from electric shock
from noxious heat/cold
learned analgesic self-administration
motivational conflict
between pain vs. food/water- has inury, has to obercome pain to get food or water

Classical (Pavlovian) Conditioning
conditioned place avoidance
to formalin-paired chamber
to chamber where allodynia is experienced
conditioned place preference
to analgesic-paired chamber
Relief from pain= reward, activate system when redfuce pain

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Motivational Conflict Between Pain and Drinking

A

Injected into mouth
Have to put head in slot to acheieve reward
At slot have thermode- hot
Did in rats when have injection vs not at normal temp and high temp
Normal rats- didn’t affect them, pained rats- when inc temp, do it much less
Grey bar- apply analgesiac

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Conditioned Place Preference to Analgesia

A

Prefer rewarding environment- drugs
Want to provide analegisiac without activating rewards system
Gabapentin- calms down neuronal firing
Sham= surgey but don’t touch nerve

Post sni- prefer pain relief chamber

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Mice in Chronic Pain Have Anxiety/depressive-like behaviour?

A

Acetic acid-induced muscle pain
Pain thresholds and negative emotions measured
Negative emotions (anxiety/depression) reversed by pregabalin (gabapentin) Anxiety- elevated plus maze- spend more time in open space- less anxious
Induce pain- more anxioud
Forced swim- learn no way out and stop trying, pain= more immobilized

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Burrowing as a Quality-of-Life Measure?

A

Either measures amount displaxed or time till remove it all
Naïve vs cfa- causes inflammation, models chronic inflammation- deal bacteria tht causes immune response

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Voluntary Wheel Running (1 h/day) in Mice with Inflammatory Pain

A

only inflammatory pain
-only bilateral CFA- have to be in both feet Restricted running wheel time to one day, give cfa- will run less than control

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Animal pain Researchers are Studying the “Wrong” Symptom!

A

Most crhonic pain- have spontaneous pain
In rodents- study thermal hyperalgesia tge most
Spontaneous pain- hard to measure

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Individual differences in pain sensitivity

A

Those with lower rating had less brain activity in pain area
With higer- acc and somatic sensory cortex
Causalgia- neuropathic

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Biopsychosocial Model
Biological • Age, Gender, Genetics • Physiologic Reactions • Tissue Health Psychological •Menal Meat • Emotional Health Expectations Sociological • Interpersona Relationships • Social Support Onatic • Socioeconomics
26
The Heritability of Pain: Twin Studies
Lots of variability in what makes pain differences- variability= heritability Higly influenced by environment
27
Effects of genetic variability on pain
Inbred mice are brother-sister repeated matings (>20 generations).= genetic clones Test inbred mouse strains on different pain assays. Variability in pain sensitivity between strains is genetic. Variability within strain is environment and susceptibility to develop chronic conditions highly linked to variation in alleles
28
Sex Differences in Chronic Pain Prevalence
Women- more susceptible to pain and more sensitive Gout and back pain condition – males get it more Men less likely to get help Female have greater pain sensitivity
29
Effect of experimenter rated subject sex
Did cold pressor and had opposite or same sex experimente- female rate higher in both cases Men- opposite sex- decrease pain rating
30
Sex differences in rodents
Hormone levels are an obvious contributor Many ligands, receptors and cell types involved Women report less chronic pain during pregnancy Upregulation of opioid receptors, decrease in Th1:Th2 ratio Females respond quicker- inc sensitivity Ovarextomy- remove ovaries- dec pain sensitivity Female sex hormones- inc sensitivity When pregnant- change in immune system Decreases tH1 cell ratio- decreases the immune response and decreases inflammation Inc th2 Microglia- in the cns- tag the invaders and try to get rid of them have neurons and glial cells- f Astroglial- support Pain activates microglial- in male- chronic pain reversed by inhibiting hese cells In female- don’t matter Block hyperexcitability- reverse pain in both sexes In late pregnancy- no allodynia Reverse microglial- reverse in male and female(in pregnancy)
31
H
H
32
Descartes’ View of Pain
If for example fire comes near the foot, minute particles of this fire, which you know move at great velocity, have the power to set in motion the spot of skin on the foot which they touch, and by this means pulling on the delicate thread which is attached to the spot of the skin, they open up at the same instant the pore against which the delicate thread ends, just as by pulling on one end of a rope makes to strike at the same instant a bell which hangs at the end.” Descartes Signal sent to brain
33
Skin Anatomy
Different receptors in skin for different sensations Meissner corpuscle- touch flutter Pacinian corpuscle vibration Ruffinis corpuscle stretch Merkels disks touch, pressure Pain nerve endings - nociception)- responds to noxious stimulus
34
Nociceptors
Nociceptors are special receptors that respond only to noxious stimuli and generate nerve impulses which the brain interprets as “pain” Free nerve endings Tissue damage Tissue damage results in cells breaing, releasing toxins into the system Prostoglandin- ege2 Causes swelling/ inflammation White blood celss and mast cells go here and release chemicals- start to activate specific recpetors on free nerve ending- Causes an action potential- sometimes go to cell body,- neuron terminates in spinal cord- releasing substance p or glutamate but goes all ober the place- can reach other free nerve endings to release more chemicals– axon reflux- releases substance p- causes inflammation, is excitatory, causes vasodilation- spreds wuicker and releases more blood cells- sesntive nociocpetord
35
Nociceptors are Unipolar Neurons
Dendrites found on skin, in bone, muscle- dendrites= free nerve endings and have long axon- periphial Cell body- outside if spinal cord- in dorsal root ganglia Multipolar- CNS Unipolar neurons have one process from the cell body, an axon. It branches to connect to receptors and the spinal cord or brain. Unipolar neurons are most of the body's sensory neurons. The dendrites are found at the receptor and the axon leads to the spinal cord or brain.
36
Afferent Fiber Classes
Aa- proprioception, skeletal muscle, gives body space awarness feedback Ab- connected to mechanorepetors- touch – attaches to corpuscles and transmit sensory info Ad- convey pain and temp info- nocioceptors C- pain ,temp, itch, sweating – unmyelinated Larger fobre and more myelin- faster
37
Nerve Bundles
Packaged into sheet- have many axons- blood supply Axon collection- endonerium Nocioceptors packaged together to transmit info
38
Fast and slow pain
Bump knee- first notice sharp pain- very quick- Ad fibres Have lasting throbbing- C
39
DRG basics
DRG – dorsal root ganglion – cells bodies of sensory neurons Sensory neurons – axons sent to periphery and to dorsal horn of spinal cord All sensory info when reaches close to spinal nerve- eneters through dorsal root of spinal nerve Have spinal roots- send projection into dorsal spinal cord Also have ventral part- motor info goes out this way to leave spinal cord But sensory and motor info- packaged in same spinal nerve
40
Cell content
Neuropeptides Paracrine- released and work on other cells to activate them and autocrine actions- works on cell released from Peptidergic- contains neuropeptide CGRP, substance p vs. non-peptidergic- use glutuamte Substance P Released from sensory nerve terminals (C fibers) upon injury or infection – causes inflammatory response Mediates actions through the neurokinin 1 (NK1) receptor NK1 expressed by endothelial cells, keratinocytes, spinal neurons and glial cells Can be released antidromically- opposite direction then normal – from dendrites where it contributes to plasma extravasation, mast cell degranulation and neurogenic inflammation Activation of NK1 by substance P causes receptor to become internalized and upregulated. Causes nk1- to make nucleus make more transporters, inc sensitivity for substance p Mast cells release content- paracrine Found in DRG cells, can be releases into dorsal spinal cord to transmit and continue pain signal Cells release chemicals into spinal cord- when cut yourself etc- mostly neuropeptides(transmit nerve signal)- Substance P
41
Calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP)
Expressed by neurons in the peripheral and central nervous system Most abundantly expressed by subset of nociceptors in the dorsal root ganglion (DRG) and trigeminal ganglion- facial pain. Not found in spinal neuron cell bodies.- released from DRG Importantly involved in vasodilation, resulting in swelling, increased blood flow and recruitment of inflammatory cells to area of injury. CGRP receptor not found in cells that express CGRP- doesn’t act in autocrine fashion CGRP is released in the spinal cord of rats with chronic injury- injure nerve then measure levels= higher
42
Spinal Cord Anatomy: Directions and Dermatomes
What is “afferent”- toward vs. “efferent”?- away What is “medial” towards middle versus “lateral”?- to side What is “ipsilateral”- same side vs. contralateral”? Opposite sides Rostral- towards head] Caudal- towards tail Dorsal towards back -above Ventral towards tummy – below Shingles lays dormant in DRG- reactivate the virus, expresses in the body where innervated by DRG Upper thigh- l2, l3 Have as many drg as vertebrae- at every level of vertebrae Shingles reactivated- upper shoulder- innervated by c3 and 4- where drg virus is reactivated Dermatome map
43
Spinal cord gross anatomy
Meninges- membrane surrounding brain and spinal cord Grey- cell bodies and neurons v s. white matter- tract system Vertebral segments S pinal cord encased in bone Affererent comes in through drg activates neuron and sends ap along white matter
44
Sex differences in rodents
Hormone levels are an obvious contributor Many ligands, receptors and cell types involved Women report less chronic pain during pregnancy Upregulation of opioid receptors, decrease in Th1:Th2 ratio Females respond quicker- inc sensitivity Ovarextomy- remove ovaries- dec pain sensitivity Female sex hormones- inc sensitivity When pregnant- change in immune system Decreases tH1 cell ratio- decreases the immune response and decreases inflammation Inc th2 Microglia- in the cns- tag the invaders and try to get rid of them have neurons and glial cells- f Astroglial- support Pain activates microglial- in male- chronic pain reversed by inhibiting hese cells In female- don’t matter Block hyperexcitability- reverse pain in both sexes In late pregnancy- no allodynia Reverse microglial- reverse in male and female(in pregnancy)
45
Pain and Aging
Biological variable- contributes to pain development and sensitivity First graph- X axis- age groups Open box= population, filled= pain centre Don’t see young ppl getting chronic pain treatment During middle age- have more getting treatment although population is less Shows you population prevelance vs those getting treated at pain centre As age decline in both categories Pain gets worse up until your middle years then goes back down As age may get more sensitive but have more pain experience, same pain experience may not lead you to get treatmenet Xould have a biological relationship between age and pain reduction but could be psychological- expecting to hurt more so don’t go to clinic Rat pain- trying to avoid pain from heated surface- rat can escape and go into other area 8- 16 months- have quickest escape response- more sensitive to pain As age escpae duration becomes longer As we age may be greatwe insensitivity to pain Older rats may just be slower
46
Environmental Enrichment and Pain
Environemt modulates recovery from environemnt Rats went under surgery- CCI- nerve injury- SNI and CCI- tie suture around nerve to constrict it- sensitivity develops Can measure recovery Had regukar vs enriched environment In enriched- recovery is faster Could be related to exercise as well Environment matters
47
Pain and Spousal Support
Social environment is important for persistence and recovery of pain and chance to get chronic pain Looked at married couples- one with chronic pain Wanted to understand social development and how it affects development of chronic pain Used wimpy- measures spousal responses and social dynamics- in pain patient Had spouse write diary- solicitiousness- led to chronic pain Someone whos very supporting and kind- in both diary and spouse- led to inc pain More caring spouse= more pain Spouse is reinforcing pain behaviour To improve pain- spouse can engage in distraction techniques- distract from pain
48
Empathy for Pain
Empathu studied with pain as output measure Feel empathy, pain sensitivity changes Activates same pain responses when watching someone you love experience pain Enhancing pain sensitivity Meausured thermal responses- when it hurts and how much Did this while watching video Positive group- watch empathetic inducing video Negative group- inducing lack of empathy/ disgust In positive group- more perceived intensity- sensitivity and unpleasentness- perception of pain Positive group felt more empathy
49
Empathy for Pain in Mice
Can have mice watch other mice going through pain Inject acetic acid into mice- does writhe response extend and cotorse torso If take both mice and inject both- writhing goes up- pccurs more This only occurs if the mice are familiar Stress blocks empathy- when meet stranger a little stressed
50
The Placebo Effect: Discovery
Henry Beecher discovered the placebo effect as a medic in World War II. After running out of pain-killing morphine, he replaced it with a simple saline solution but continued telling the wounded soldiers it was morphine to calm them. To his surprise, almost half of the soldiers reported that the inert saline solution actually reduced or erased their pain. Beecher- world war 2 medic- civilian vs war pain narcotic request- stress induced analgesia Ran out of morphine- had saline and told them it was morphine Caused improvements in perceived pain
51
Placebo Effect: Is It Real?
meta-analysis Binary- have it or don’t Continuous- on a spectrum Confidence interval cant pass 0 Placebo effect may be more pronounced for pain- but has more participants and trials Binary- harder to have placebo effect- yes or no, harder to show an improvement
52
What is the placebo effect?
Inert substance or treatment that activates endogenous body systems and brain networks- counteracts condition you have Expectation influences bodily response to treatment and anticipates outcomes- what you anticipate influences it, don’t believe in treatment- less likely to work Covert-Overt Paradigm Protocol where the patients are either informed about the drug effect or given it in a hidden way- tell patient youre giving them an effective drug- high pain reduction, don’t tell= no pain reduced Can be done in open context- informed patient and still work if participant believes in actual drug Patient expectation- causes more pain reduction= placebo effect What is the Placebo Effect? conditioning? Expectation- expectation to what will work? desire?- desire to get better natural history? (regression to the mean)- when it feels worse than before or different Conditioning- stick to same drug- know it works- history with medication- type,colour, size’ When have pain reduction- not all because of drug, part of it is due to placebo effect
53
Hidden vs. Open Drug Administration
Active treatment- drug- has an effect that causes outcome If have knowledge abt treatment- causes a non specific effect that influenceds the outcome Treating with placebo- want to remove active treatemnet- tell them itll do something- give them the knowledge Or give active treatment but don’t tell them abt the drug In this study- told remifentanil- improves pain and gets worse when stop administering Used VAS scale No expentancy- reduces pain a bit Have positive expectations- reduces pain even more Negative expectation- stopped it even if you didn’t- pain intensity goes close to baseline With expentancy- combined drug and placebo effect
54
Factors Affecting the Placebo Effect
subjectivity vs. objectivity of measure (pain or depression- more placebo effect vs. wound healing or Parkinson’s) the nature of the verbal suggestions (compare “It can be either a placebo or a painkiller” to “It is a powerful painkiller”) previous experience belief/expectation/desire of patient and clinician patient-clinician interaction (the “therapeutic context”) -“bedside manner” (enthusiasm, reassurance, empathy, communication) -white coats- positive effect -deep voices- greater placebo effect physical properties of placebo itself -sham surgery > i.v. placebo > big pill > small pill -expensive pill > cheap pill personality variables (esp. “ego-resiliency” and “agreeableness”) More invasive surgery= greater placebo effect
55
Placebo Neurochemistry
Placebo effect mediated by opiods- endogenous opioid system Follow pain intensity of open injection of saline- decreases pain sensitivity Administer drug in hidden fashion- over tume pain sesnitivty reverses to baseline- because of nonspecific opiod blocker
56
Placebo Anatomy
Placebo effect mediated by endogenous opiod system PAG, amgydala, Vpfc Activated in response to placebo and release endogenous opiods and dopamine to reduce pain but also generate experience of pain
57
Nocebo Effect
Nocebo- negative expectations – makes things worse Driven by the fear, anxiety of pain
58
Repeated pain sensitizes male but not female mice
Mice tested for thermal thresholds using Hargreaves test. Mice injected with acetic acid and then placed in context for 30 min 24 hrs later mice returned to same context or different context Thermal thresholds measured using Hargreaves test. When mice returned to pain environment- have negative association that enhances pain sensitivity
59
Vulnerability factors for chronic pain
Fear avoidance model Persistent pain  fear, avoidance and physical deconditioning Fear-avoidance model  pain may be chronically maintained through cognitive appraisals Avoidance of activity may act as negative reinforcement for the fear-avoidance cycle. Trauma PTSD is higher in chronic pain populations Higher pain at time of injury is associated with PTSD Chronic pain and PTSD  hypervigilance to threats Depression Chronic pain populations have a higher prevalence of depression ”Chicken and egg” problem; what’s the causal direction – both may be true Learned helplessness as a model to conceptualize depression in the context of chronic pain Catashprophizing- leads to more fear, more pain, more depression enhancing pain experience
60
Resilience factors for chronic pain
Pain self-efficacy One’s belief in controlling events of situations Associated with lower perceived pain, reduced depression, improved physical function Considered a contrasting factor to catastrophizing High social component (positive expectations from your Dr.) Acceptance- better outcome Individual’s willingness to engage in valued goal-directed behaviour despite the pain Mental struggle is not evident in these people Focus on the positive (life events, social, hobbies). Psychology in treatment of chronic pain Interdisciplinary care is best approach Cognitive behavioral therapy educates patient on the biopsychosocial nature of pain to reinforce different thinking about pain conditions Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) and mindfulness improve protective factors and promote resilience Reduces the negative thoughts and feelings getting people to think differently about their pain Drugs alone wont work