Test 1 Flashcards
What science is not:
Not defined by a discipline, isn’t defined by apparatus or equipment or gear you wear.
The APA organizes psychology in to sub disciplines.
Science is not defined by any sub disciplines it is a method.
What is science:
Science is a way of thinking that includes use of systematic empiricism, Production of public knowledge and the examination of solvable problems.
Science in this country has been used to deal with current problems. WW1 saw use of it to figure out people’s roles in the military. A similar role was found in WW2 both for personnel and making easy to use weapons and material.
Systematic:
It is structured
Empiricism:
observations
Systematic Empiricism:
Structured observations that reveal something about the underlying nature of the world.
Knowledge:
Knowledge gained through the scientific endeavors doesn’t exist until it is shared publicly.
Two key aspects of publicly verifiable knowledge:
Replication: findings are presented in a way that can be attempted by others to obtain the same findings.
Peer review: procedure in which scientists, knowledgeable about the content of the research, critique the study.
Empirically solvable problems are testable theories.
Problem: The answer is possible even if we don’t have one yet
vs Mystery: Can’t conceive what an answer might look.
Theories must have a chance to fail!
Why is having the chance to fail important?
Theory (modification), begin with a problem -> Prediction, (develop a hypothesis about what will happen)-> Test (Put the Hypothesis to the test) -> Theory (Based on the results of the test, refine the theory) and the cycle goes on.
What is pseudoscience:
Pseudo: fake
Pseudoscience: A system of theories, assumptions, and methods erroneously regarded as scientific.
Examples: Polygraph, MBTI
It lacks a fundamental respect for research and evidence
e.g: falsifiability
It poses as science to garner respect for itself.
Characteristics of Pseudoscience:
1 outward appearance of science:
Science defines its terms.
Pseudoscience uses jargon, scientific language without defining terms.
Gives the appearance of credibility.
2 Absence of skeptical peer review:
Healthy skepticism is key to good science.
Pseudoscience lacks anything more than token skepticism.
3 Reliance on a personal experience (testimonials, anecdotal evidence):
In science, anecdotes may suggest hypotheses but are not evidence in themselves
In pseudoscience, great faith is placed on anecdotes.
4 Evasion of risky tests
Science proposes risky tests that false hypotheses will not pass
In science, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Pseudoscience uses weak tests because disconfirming evidence hurts it.
5 pseudoscience retreats to the supernatural
Science is grounded in the natural world, even if an underlying mechanism is unknown at the time.
Pseudoscience cites the supernatural if claims are found to be false.
6 Claims that “unexplained” equals “inexplicable”
Science recognizes that something that isn’t explained can be eventually.
Pseudoscience uses what is unexplained a evidence of a true mystery.
7 Tolerance of inconsistencies
Science is designed to eliminate contradictions.
Pseudoscience tolerates them.
8 Appeals to authority
Because science is publicly verifiable, anyone can consume the research.
Pseudoscience has only weak data so relies on “authorities” to convey a claim.
9 Promising the impossible.
Science, being bounded by reality, recognizes natural limitations.
Pseudoscience often makes claims that disregard these limitations.
10 Stagnation
Science is constantly changing, updating.
Pseudoscience stays rigidly unchanging.
That is often touted as a virtue.
11 Placing the burden of proof on the critic.
In science, the proponent of the claim must provide the proof.
In pseudoscience, the proponent turns the burden of proof over to the critic.
Skepticism is
Skepticism is a set of tools, honed by time and field tested by science, into the best instruments we have for discovering the truth.
At its core, it is an attitude of doubt or questioning applied to any topic
Someone who is skeptical=not easily convinced.
Also involves suspended judgment, critical scrutiny, caution, open-mindedness, and continual testing.
Skepticism is rooted in
Skepticism is rooted in a hunger for knowledge, fed by rational inquiry, constructive doubt, and the questioning nature of an open, inquisitive mind.
It allows us to find joy and magic in the majesty of reality and yet still allows our hopeful hearts to be open to the possibility of something more.
Skepticism is not about
Skepticism is not about disbelief.
Often skepticism is used to mean disbelief and a skeptic is someone who doesn’t believe in something.
Disbelievers are not skeptics.
Remember, skepticism isn’t a position, it’s a process for finding the truth. These examples are incorrect uses of the term.
Skepticism is NOT opposing claims just to oppose them.
Inquiry and NOT opposition is what drives skepticism.
Skeptics Do oppose some things but not because of a default automatic mechanism. Opposition is due to carefully evaluating evidence and finding it lacking.
Skepticisms default is to
Skepticisms default is to reserve judgement until evidence can be examined, not outright opposition.
Skepticism is NOT about debunking.
Debunking does occur, it is not the purpose of it.
Skepticism separates those things that are untrue from those things that are true.
Finding the things that are untrue is a necessary outcome of the process.
Skepticism is not about believing nothing.
Good, well applied skepticism can lead to either belief or disbelief in a given claim.
But like debunking disbelief is not the goal/purpose of skepticism.
Skepticism teaches you HOW to think not WHAT to think
Other misconceptions about skepticism.
It doesn’t make you more intelligent than non-skeptics
There is a correlation between education and skepticism
Doesn’t mean that one requires the other.
Smart people are better able to argue for their beliefs true or not.
It doesn’t make you immune to error.
Skeptics are just as susceptible to being fooled as anyone else.
Indeed, failure to be humble can lead to being fooled.
Why is skepticism important?
It allows you to wonder about the natural phenomena of the universe while demanding evidence for their existence.
Psychology is merely common sense.
“the duh files”-Psychological findings just confirm common sense.
Examples:
Expressing pent up anger reduces anger (66%)
Strange behaviors are especially likely during fool moons(65%)
People with skizophrenia have multiple personalities(77%)
Human memory acts like a tape recorder (27%)
The polygraph is a highly accurate detector of lies(45%)
Hypnotized people blindly follow the suggestions of tests(44%)
On a MC test one should stick with the original answer even if it doesn’t seem correct(75%)