Term 1 Flashcards
Revisionist perspective on GD
Europe = Asia before 1800
No divergence until industrial revolution
Traditionalist perspective on GD
Europe > Asia before 1800
Process of improvement beginning in early modern period
Pomeranz grain wages: what % of European wages were China’s in Yangzi delta region?
87% 16C to 17C
38% 18C to 19C
Why do Broadberry & Gupta say grain wages are unreliable?
W/P for china high due to low prices as a result of excess supply + low nominal wages. Higher prices in Europe deflates nominal wages to similar level. Misleading impression of comparable living standards
Why are silver wages better?
Silver traded internationally = subject to law of one price
Equal prices so differences in real wages reflect different nominal wages = reflect living standards
Two main causes of great divergence
Demographics
Institutions
How was Europe’s democracy different to China’s?
Demographic revolution 250 years before IR: high FAFM & low fertility
Preventative checks in Europe vs. Positive checks China.
How did European demography –> GD?
Preventative checks = confidence & predictability = Investment
Lower BR & DR = higher wage equilibrium = incentive to invest in labour-saving technologies = K technology change
Positive checks China = low wages = no K L substitution effect
How did institutions –> GD?
Olson’s theory of stationary bandits
Stationary bandits > roving bandits (full taxation)
But stationary < democracy (lower tax - see Laffer Curve)
GR 1688 = secure property rights
What were the 3 phases of the European miracle?
Phase 1 = Italy & Portugal
Phase 2 = Holland & England
Phase 3 = English MEG
How was Italy an individualist society w.r.t. Mediterranean trade?
Italian traders captured gains by hiring agents outside organisation + had enforceable contracts = step towards institutions
Collectivist = sent members abroad, fear of punishment = no need for institutions
How does Kuznet define modern economic growth? (6)
- Sustained rates of pop & GDP p.c. Growth
- Structural change
- Urbanisation & secularisation
- Rapid transport & communications
- Wide gaps between rich and poor countries
- High & sustained TFP growth
Causes of European miracle
Good institutions
Agricultural revolution
Empire
(Same as GD but focus in European success)
Why was the IR a revolution? (6)
Agriculture to industry Small to large scale production Rapid TFP growth Investment Capital substituting labour Integration of markets
Causes of IR
- Factor prices
- scientific institutions
- GR 1688
- Agricultural Rev & proto-industry
- Industrious Rev
How did British factor prices lead to IR? (Allen)
High wages, low cost of capital = investment in labour saving technologies
Isocost/isoquant diagram
How did scientific institutions lead to IR? (Mokyr)
Enlightenment 1800
Royal society 1662
Market for innovations saw an increase in supply
What were the 3 phases of the agricultural revolution and dates?
- Yeoman’s (Peasant’s) Rev = 16C/17C
- Landlord’s Rev = 18C (Enclosure)
- 19C Rev = machinery from IR to agriculture
What was enclosure?
Consolidation of small landholdings into larger farms & private ownership of previously common pastures
When were the Enclosure acts?
1750
4 arguments for Enclosure
Overton: economies of scale, draining & proper irrigation
Marx: landless peasants –> cities for IR
Hardin: Tragedy of the commons (public good) = need property rights
3 arguments against Enclosure
Inequality
Huge cost for peasants
Policing of common pasture = no tragedy of commons
What are the 2 opposing arguments regarding the timing of the agricultural revolution?
Neo-Revisionists: growth slowed after 1740
Yeoman’s Rev > landlord’s
Counter/revisionist: growth rapid after 1700
Landlord’s > peasants
Enclosure very important
Demand side argument for AR causing IR
Higher incomes for landlords = higher consumption
Increased efficiency = lower food prices. Due to inelastic demand, excess income spent on industrial goods
Supply side argument for AR causing IR
Broke Malthusian checks with increased food production = population growth = increased labour supply. Landless peasants to industry.
What is pronto industrial rev?
Shift from agriculture to industry occurred before the IR
IR marked rise of modern industry, but not industry as such
How was proto industry different to IR?
Remained decentralised: in homes not factories
Not much capital machinery used in production
3 theories about how proto industry led to IR
- Demographic acceleration model
- Transition to capitalism model
- Dualistic labour supply model
Explain demographic acceleration model w.r.t. how proto industry led to IR
Agriculture seasonal = underemployment
Proto industry = able to earn more income = could marry & support a family sooner = lower FAFM & higher fertility
Population boom = cheap labour to cities for IR
Explain the transition to capitalism model w.r.t. how proto industry led to IR
Created an entrepreneurial class with skills & business training Workers better training to operate machines Proto industrial exports established trade = first mover advantage
Explain the dualistic labour supply model w.r.t. how proto industry led to IR
Lewis: surplus labour from traditional to modern sector
Here traditional = proto industry
Modern = modern industry
Surplus Labour to modern industry for IR without demanding higher wages = profitable = investment in K
Criticism of dualistic labour supply model on how proto industry led to IR
Allen shows high wages in Britain led to IR by incentivising capital investment, so wages not low.
What other revolutions is argued to have caused the industrious revolution?
Consumer revolution –> industrious revolution
What was the consumer Rev?
Households demand for status goods and luxury imports rose
Earning opportunities for women & children increased purchasing power
Great discoveries e..g America –> increased variety of goods
What was the industrious Rev?
Wages flat/declining but wanted to consume work = worked longer hours, more work less leisure.
Holidays abolished e.g. Saint Monday & 49 holy days in 16C
Why do critics argue there was no consumer Rev?
Hours worked only increased to maintain SoL due to declining real wages = not due to consumerism
Why do critics argue that there was no industrious Rev?
Hours worked already high in Middle Ages
Women active in LF in 14C as response to Black Death & remained due to sticky preferences.
Women & children made up small share of income in 19C