Task 5 Flashcards
screening
screening – designed to quickly identify risky patterns of substance use
assessment – establishes where on the continuum of substance use the patient falls: use, misuse, excessive use, or substance use disorder
assessment
assessment – establishes where on the continuum of substance use the patient falls: use, misuse, excessive use, or substance use disorde
Basic components of a substance use assessment include
Basic components of a substance use assessment include:
1. describing current and past patterns of substance use with an emphasis on characterizing use that may be excessive, harmful, or hazardous
2. diagnosing any substance-related disorder that may be present currently
3. documenting the effect of substance use on an individual’s mental and physical state
Preparation for Substance use assessment
— Each interviewing setting has unique qualities and features that must be considered beforehand
— Clinicians should keep in mind that patients who are presenting for care in a non–addiction treatment setting may not be expecting complex and vigorous questions about substance use
— therefore, clinicians should describe to the patient, in clear terms, the purpose and intent of asking questions about substance use
— highest level of security and confidentiality in the interview room is fundamental to completing an accurate substance use assessment
— Electronic medical records and their use during the substance use assessment must be taken into consideration beforehand
— practice of typing and inputting information while inter-viewing (and thus making less eye contact) has drawn mixed reviews from clinicians and patients
— recognize the current physical and psychiatric state of the patient
— Patients who use substances will present in a wide variety of states, ranging from intoxication to withdrawal
— interview with an intoxicated patient should be limited to an assessment of the patient’s physical and psychiatric safety
Preparation for Substance use assessment
(in general)
Review the Medical Record Beforehand
Check Prescription Drug Monitoring Program Database
Administer and Review Substance Use Screening Forms in Advance
Interview Techniques
— patients may be experiencing shame, embarrassment, or guilt or simply be in denial or lack awareness or understanding of the severity of their illness
— interviewers should pay especially close attention to:
— verbal and nonverbal clues, such as not listening to questions
— minimizing use or consequences of use
— changing the subject
— discouraging inquiry by displaying irritation, anxiety, or other behaviors
— outright lying
— overcome barriers by:
— include asking open-ended questions
— control the pace of the interview, especially in regard to reviewing all substances
— summarize the patient’s history at end of session
Structure of the Assessment
Substance Use History: Focus on Documenting Current Use
Ask About Non-Substance-Related Disorders (Behavioral Addictions)
Distinguish Substance Use from Substance Use Disorder
Substance use disorder treatment history
Psychiatric History
Medical History
Familial History
Social History
Substance use disorder
Substance use disorder – defined globally as a maladaptive pattern of substance use leading to clinically significant impairment or distress, as manifested by persistent or recurrent social or interpersonal problems caused by substance use
Physical and Mental State examination
— Crucial because of the high frequency of overlapping conditions between medical and psychiatric disorders found in this population
Laboratory Testing
— useful laboratory data include urine toxicology, blood alcohol levels, and measures of substance metabolites or the biological effects of substance use
— e.g., biological markers of alcohol use
Importance of Collateral Information
Importance of Collateral Information
additional, objective information from sources other than the patient
— collateral information include family members, roommates, friends, employers, and other health care providers
— supply objective data and improve assessment, or they may advocate for a particular outcome and add to bias
Strategies to Improve Clinical Skills in Conducting a Substance Use Assessment
Ú practical tips to increase their clinical knowledge and skills related to conducting a more efficient and thorough sub-stance use assessment
- Attend the annual meeting of an addiction organization
- Regularly review and refer to online addiction resources, which offer no-cost guides to screening, assessment, and enhancing clinical assessment skills
- Access the Provider’s Clinical Support System, which is a online mentoring program that offers a national network of trained clinicians with expertise in addiction medicine and pain management
- Visit local substance use disorder treatment programs to learn about available treatment options, effective treatment practices, and current trends in substance use
Screening and brief intervention (SBI)
Screening and brief intervention (SBI) – a well-established clinical practice supported by evidence from controlled clinical trials
Purpose of Screening
— target of screening is any unhealthy substance use
Represents
1. a preventive intervention aimed at recurring behavioral risks
2. an initial step in the management of moderate to severe substance use disorders
“SBIRT” (SBI plus referral to treatment
Unhealthy substance use
Unhealthy substance use – any use of alcohol or other drugs that increases the risk for or has been related to health consequences
— includes use of any illicit drugs or misuse of prescription or nonprescription drugs known to cause risk or harm, and amounts of alcohol known to increase the risk for health consequences
— also includes use with consequences that do not yet meet criteria for a disorder, as well as use leading to a substance use disorder
— aimed at detecting the entire spectrum of unhealthy use, from risky use to use with problems to a diagnosable disorder
— important because the majority of health consequences on a population level do not accrue to those with severe substance use disorders, but instead occur in people who are simply drinking too much, with no severe disorder
tools for screening
CAGE questions
the Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test
— not sufficiently accurate for identifying the spectrum of unhealthy use
Laboratory testing
— not recommended for screening
combination of screening and testing (e.g., CAGE, laboratory testing) might be useful for assessment or monitoring
Single-item screening questions (SSQs)
— administered quickly and easily
— validated in primary medical care settings
— Longer screening tools have
— Two disadvantages:
1. they cannot be memorized and used as easily in medical interviews in busy settings
2. they are more difficult to score
— BUT can provide more information about the severity of the risk identified
Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test—Consumption (AUDIT-C)
Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test—Consumption (AUDIT-C)
— short screening version of the AUDIT with three alcohol consumption items
— is validated
— with optimal sensitivity and still reasonable specificity for unhealthy use
Alcohol, Smoking, and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST)
Alcohol, Smoking, and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST)
— Long screening
— does not identify risky alcohol use amounts directly
— however, provides risk-level information that is useful for brief intervention
Two specific populations:
1. adolescents
2. pregnant women or women aiming to conceive
Ú for whom use of tailored screening tools is helpful, because for these patients, any use is unhealthy
Assessment
Ú When a patient screens positive
Following three areas should be assessed:
1. drinking amounts, drug used, and frequency
2. substance use consequences, including substance use disorders
3. patient’s perception of his or her use and readiness to change
Ú Assessments, as an extension of screening, can also be considered part of the intervention when done in the context of a therapeutic relationship
Assessment of Use
Assessment of Use
– quantity and frequency of alcohol use
– three questions:
1. On average, how many days per week do you drink alcohol?
2. On a typical day when you drink, how many drinks do you have?
3. What is the maximum number of drinks you had on any given occasion during the last month?
– drug use, the first item for each drug from the ASSIST
– or simply be asked what drugs he or she uses, how many days in the past month the patient used those drugs or any drugs, and how many times per day
CAGE-AID
CAGE-AID – “or drug use” and “or used drugs”
– Questions:
– Have you ever felt that you ought to Cut down on your drinking or drug use?
– Have people Annoyed you by criticizing your drinking or drug use?
– Have you ever felt bad or Guilty about your drinking or drug use?
– Have you ever had a drink or used drugs first thing in the morning (Eye-opener) to steady your nerves, e.g., get rid of a hangover, or get the day started?
CRAFFT – brief assessment to indicate to possible presence of a SUD
- Have you ever ridden in a CAR driven by someone (including yourself) who was “high” or had been using alcohol or drugs?
- Do you ever use alcohol or drugs to RELAX, feel better about yourself, or fit in?
- Do you ever use alcohol or drugs while you are by yourself, or ALONE?
- Do you ever FORGET thins you did while using alcohol or drugs?
- Do your family and FRIENDS ever tell you that you should cut down on your drinking or drug use?
- Have you ever gotten into TROUBLE while you were using alcohol or drugs?
2 or more “yes” answers indicate a higher likelihood of a disorder
Assessment of the patient’s perception and readiness to change
Assessment of the patient’s perception and readiness to change
— Readiness to change lies on a continuum and can be assessed by using simple visual analogue scale-type questions
— E.g., “On a scale of 0 to 10, how ready are you to change your drinking?”
Performing a brief intervention
— Brief intervention involves counseling to help the patient to abstain from or reduce substance use
— Brief interventions consist of feedback, advice, and goal setting
— Based on principles of motivational interviewing
— Goal of intervention depends on the level of severity of substance use and participant’s perception of the problem and readiness to change
— Best goal abstinence
— Brief clinical interventions include:
— Clinical feedback about the patient’s risks and consequences of substance use
— Specific advice
— Goal setting
— The clinician has 2 initial concerns:
— Establish a trusting and preferably ongoing relationship that includes follow-up
— Determining how the brief intervention should be provided
Abstinence Initiation
Abstinence Initiation – clients still use substances, focus on abstinence initiation as the first target
— Relapse prevention – requires abstinence for treatment entry, so that all their treatment is geared toward keeping the clients abstinent
Relapse prevention
Relapse prevention – requires abstinence for treatment entry, so that all their treatment is geared toward keeping the clients abstinent
coping skills training (CST)
— Common conceptualization Client lacks important coping skills, including skills for handling:
— Internal states (mood, cravings, stress, etc.)
— Interpersonal situations (e.g., family conflicts)
— Employment situations
— Some of these states/ situations have developed learned associated with substance use higher relapse risk for those situations
Social learning theory
Social learning theory – identifying situations which trigger substance use (via operant/ respondent conditioning principles), cognitions that are elicited by these situations, and probable consequences
Functional Analysis
Functional Analysis – using those aspects of social learning theory to analyze situations that pose a high risk for relapse
Social learning principles
Social learning principles (also called Skills training)
guiding the intervention methods include:
— People learn through direct instruction
– Modeling of alternatives
– Learning to counter automatic thoughts/ beliefs with adaptive alternative thoughts
– Changing the environment to reduce triggering situations
– Increased contact with positive reinforcement for not using substances
– Changing social and/ or employment or living environment
Aversive Conditioning Approaches
— Nausea based approaches – induction of nausea, then the client is exposed to or ingests the addictive substance
— Most common but modestly positive success
— For tobacco dependence rapid smoking or rapid puffing procedures – nausea occurs from toxic levels of nicotine BUT only under medical supervision
— Electrical aversion – pairing electrical shocks with tasting the substance
— Less encouraging success
— Covert sensitization – imagining aversive scenes while drinking small amounts of alcohol
— Less encouraging success
Cognitive Therapy
Cognitive Therapy
— Approach to modify both the core and drug-related beliefs and the automatic thoughts elicited by high-risk situations
CBT appraoch
— To help the client learn new behaviors to replace the maladaptive ones
1. Start with analyzing the client’s personal situational
– antecedents of substance use
– thoughts and emotions that are triggered by these situations
– the core dysfunctional beliefs they have about themselves, other people, and the substance use
– and the patterns of behavior that the client uses in response to these beliefs
- Through Socratic questioning and modelling, the therapist helps the client learn to develop alternative more adaptive thoughts to replace the maladaptive ones with
— Used to deal with situations that trigger drug use
— Also used to help person learn more effective ways to handle anger, depression, anxiety, and other emotions without using drugs
— Used as an aspect of CBT not on its own
Cognitive-Behavioral Skills Training
— Interpersonal skills for building better relationships
— Cognitive and behavioral emotion-coping skills for regulation moods more effectively
— Skills for coping sudden stressful events without using substances
— Coping with substance use cues without using
— Helps to increase clients’ sense of self-efficacy about handling situations without using substances
— Conducted in individual or group sessions depends on client
— CST session topics are structured as skill-focused or situation-focused
Cognitive-Behavioral Skills Training & alkohol dependnace
— Communication Skills Training – developing social skills designed to promote a lifestyle that encourages sobriety
— Cognitive-behavioral mood management training – designed to slow down the process of reacting to risky events
— Behavioral self-control training – teach moderation in alcohol consumption for problem drinkers who had not sought abstinence-oriented treatment
— CST has excellent support for use with alcohol and cocaine dependence
— Good support for marijuana dependence
— Persistent long after treatment has ended
Contingency Management
Contingency Management
— Based on operant conditioning principles
— Patients who abstain from drugs are provided with financial incentives immediate reinforcement
— Timing of reinforcement (immediately)
— Choosing an incentive that is personally valued by the target individual and is large enough to promote the targeted change
— Larger events generally produce more abstinence
abstinence during first 2 weeks of treatment predicts longer term abstinence most effective treatment approach for cocaine dependence, with efficacy also shown for opiate and marijuana dependence, particularly when combined with CST or community reinforcement that includes CST
reducing value of voucher over time/ using fewer valuable incentives (e.g., lottery tickets) maintain abstinence while lowering the costs of the program
long term results of Contingency Management
— Long-term efficacy mixed results
— Concerns:
— High financial costs
— Differing results on whether people stay abstinent after finishing the program
— CM might undermine intrinsic motivation to change
— The success of CM could be affected by the findings of a recent fMRI study
— Sensitivity to monetary rewards was compromised in light of cocaine addiction
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
— Attempts to reduce, eliminate, or decrease the likelihood of negative thoughts and emotions (“Experiential avoidance”) may worsen potential outcome in the long term
— Focus on helping clients realize the breadth of their psychological difficulties and to overcome the cognitive and emotional barriers to stopping destructive drug use patterns
— 5 main treatment phases:
1. Creative Hopelessness – Making contact with the scope of the problem and the effort expended to solve it
2. Values Assessment – Exploration of the client’s personal values to direct and dignify the treatment
3. Control as the Problem – Identifying ineffective control strategies
4. Defusing Language – Making room for acceptance
5. Applied Willingness – Putting values into action.
Cue-exposure with Response Prevention
— Designed to reduce respondent condition to stimuli that have been repeatedly associated with the drug in the past
— Repeated presentation of sight, sounds, and/or smells associated with drug use (“cues”) while the person is in a safe environment with no access to the drug unreinforcement of drug
Cue-exposure with Response Prevention mechanism
— 3 mechanisms by which cues are believed to pose a risk for relapse:
— by classical conditioned responses that elicit urge to use substance
— these reactions then interfere with a client’s ability to use coping skills effectively
— cues and internal responses to cues lead to operant behavior (substance use) that reinforce the behavior by reducing the aversive aspects of the response
CET is believed to work through one or both of 2 mechanisms:
CET is believed to work through one or both of 2 mechanisms:
— Breaking the conditioned association between cues and substance use behavior cues no longer elicit conditioned reactions
— Providing the opportunity to practice coping with urges to use so that urges will be less likely to disrupt the client’s ability to apply coping skills when in the presence of cues after treatment
CET Implication s
— Exposure should occur long enough for responses to habituate within-session
— Wide variety of different cues should be used in exposure sessions
— Urge coping practices should occur early in exposure when elicited reactions are at a peak
CET results
— CET has not been successful for opiate- or cocaine-dependent clients
— No effect after treatment ends for smokers
— Beneficial effect for people with alcohol use disorders
Coping skills with best support
Coping skills with best support
— Telling themselves that they can wait out the urge and it will go down
— Thinking about the negative and positive consequences
— Imagining eating or drinking something else
— Imagining engaging in an alternative activity