T2) Biological Theories✅ Flashcards
What does biological theories consist of?
Genetics & physiology
(Genetics 🧬 )
What are the three studies of genetics?
- Jacobs XYY⟵
- Twin studies
- Adoption studies ⟵
🧬-jacobs XYY
What does jacobs xyy believe?
Believe crime is down to chromosome activity
🧬- jacobs XYY
What does it mean if you have an extra why chromosome?
Your known as ‘hyper masculine’ and agressive and therefore more likely to be criminal
🧬 - jacobs XYY
how many newborns are born with an extra ‘y’?
And
How many times more likely are XYY males likely to commit crime compared to normal XY males?
- 1/1000
2. 10x
🧬 - jacobs XYY evaluation:
✅State a strength of jacobs xyy
✅ statistics back the fact that men with an extra ‘y’ chromosome have higher levels of aggression
🧬 - jacobs XYY evaluation:
❌State 3 criticisms of jacobs XYY?
❌Theilgard found that aggression was not associated with xyy
❌stereotypical- xyy men commit non violent crimes therefore doesn’t account for aggression intensity
❌Genetic abnormalities are wide spread
🧬 - adoption studies
What was the aim of adoption studies?
To separate the impact of environment (nurture) versus inheritance (nature)
🧬 - adoption studies
What did the study in Iowa show about imprisoned females?
That adopted individuals born to an imprisoned female offender had a higher rate of crime convictions in the future
🧬 - adoption studies
What did hutchings and mednick find out when studying 14000 adopted children?
Found that a high proportion of adopted boys with criminal biological parents were more likely to be criminal themselves
🧬 - adoption studies evaluation:
✅identify 2 strengths of adoption studies
✅ compares how children behave in comparison to their adoptive parents
✅ evidence to support the fact that criminality and antisocial behaviour is linked to inheritance in genes
🧬 - adoption studies evaluation:
❌state 3 criticisms
❌ doesn’t consider age of adoption which can make a huge difference
❌children are places into similar adoptive families to them
❌info about biological parents isn’t always accessible
(Physiological🧍🏽♂️)
What are the 2 studies?
- Lombrosso
2. Sheldon
👨🏽 - lombrosso
What did he believe made some one a criminal?
Give examples
He believed ‘atavistic’ features made some one criminal
e.g: long ears, limbs, large jaws, chins, monobrows, extra fingers
👨🏽 - lombrosso
What did he call these abnormalities?
Stigmata
👨🏽 - lombrosso
What were the stats he found regarding the amount of characteristic men and women need
how did he find this out?
Men= 5+ atavistic features to be criminal Women= 3+ ft. To be criminal
studied Italian prisoners vs Italian soldiers
👨🏽 - lombrosso evaluation:
❌list limitations
❌no control group - too simplistic
❌DeLisi claims its scientifically racist saying. Those of an African decent are most likely to be criminal
❌highly stereotypical and most of the time inaccurate , can’t generalise
❌ignores other factors eg social, environemntal
❌too deterministic
👨🏽 - lombrosso evaluation:
❌list limitations
❌no control group - too simplistic
❌DeLisi claims its scientifically racist saying. Those of an African decent are most likely to be criminal
❌highly stereotypical and most of the time inaccurate , can’t generalise
❌ignores other factors eg social, environemntal
👨🏽 - lombrosso
What did lombrosso say about ppl with tattoos?
He said it’s a marking of criminality bc it shows immorality & insensitivity to physical pain
🧍🏻- sheldon
What did sheldon believe criminality was down too?
What were the three types?
- Body type
- 3 types=
- ectomorphic= thin (private)
- endomorphic=fat (sociable)
- mesomorphic= masculine (aggressive)
🧍🏻 - sheldon
Who did he find out to be most and least likely to commit crime?
He found convicts are most likely to be mesomorphs and ectomorphs are less common
🧍🏻 - sheldon evaluation:
✅state some strengths of this study
✅ 3 clear and precise categories
✅male’s reflect high testosterone
🧍🏻 - sheldon
Who did he say committed the most violent crimes?
What’s did he link aggression too?
- Mesomorphic men
2. Mesomorphic build reflects high levels of testosterone
🧍🏻- sheldon evaluation:
❌state some limitations
❌ body shapes can change - stereotypical
❌other body types can be criminal too
❌meso’s may be at target of deviancey by gangs
❌some one can’t control there body but can control their actions