Supreme Court Cases Flashcards
Civil liberties
Protection- liberties automatically given at birth. Civil society.
Civil rights
Given by government by laws. Convicted felons can’t vote
Judicial powers
Pres actions are subject to review. Can be reversed by Supreme Court.
Marbury v Madison
Est basis for exercise of judicial review. 1 time Supreme Court ruled unconstitutional.
Exec powers
Manage national affairs. Rules to follow.
Ex parte Milligan
Milligan and 4 others accused of stealing union weapons. Sentence to hanging by military court. Court ruled cannot be tried by military tribunals when civil courts are open. ( even during war)
Us v Reynolds
( Korean War 1953 -Eisenhower )- challenged exec privilege in civil suit against Air Force contractor. Lower court ruled against pres. Supreme Court over ruled the lower court
Us v Nixon
(1974)- Nixon claimed exec privilege for not turning over certain tapes and doc during watergate investigation. Court rejected nixon’s claim. Gerald Ford pardoned Nixon.
Clinton v jones
Immunity from prosecution for acts done before taking office, while in office. Court ruled a sitting pres has no immunity from civil law litigation against him unrelated to his present office. Allowed him to be tried.
Boumediene v bush
Writ of habeas corpus submission for release from Guantanamo bay detention to civil court trial. Court ruled prisoner had right to habeas corpus and his military confinement was unconstitutional.
Gibbons v Ogden
Challenge to congress’ right to regulated interstate commerce, who granted gibbons a monopoly to his steamboat services. Court favored Ogden concluding congressional power over commerce.
Us v Lopez
Challenged congress’ commerce clause when in possession of a concealed revolver on school grounds. Court sided with Lopez on the grounds that congress’ powers were limited.
Gonzalez v raich
Congress’ right to regulate commerce in the form of banning home-grown cannabis when state approved for medicinal purposes. Angel Reich claimed she used marijuana to keep herself alive. Court conceded that congress had the power to control or ban marijuana for non-medical use, but banning medicinal marijuanna was permissible as a way of preventing or limiting access to marijuana for non-medicinal uses.
Arizona v US
Az law to regulate immigration. Struck down 3provisions of the state law:
1 requiring legal immigrants to carry registration docs at all times.
2 allowing state police to arrest any individual for suspicion of being alien.
3 making it a crime for illegal aliens to search for jobs.
They upheld the provision to investigate the immigration status of individual stopped detained or arrested.
Fl v us dept of HHS (2012)
Challenged all citizens to buy health insurance and the expansion of Medicaid which were part of the affordable care act of 2010. 5-4 decision court upheld individual mandate requiring Americans to buy health insurance or pay a penalty. Provision on interstate commerce clause was not upheld but was under congress’ right to tax.
Reynolds v us(1978)
First case testing the free exercise clause. Practicing polygamist in Utah. Read clause as protecting beliefs and not practices that run counter to neutrally enforced criminal laws.
Sherbert v vernier (1963)
7th day Adventist challenged a sc state law requiring him to work on a Saturday. Court found unconstitutional because it significantly burdened religious exercise.
Empl div v smith
Reinterpreted decades of case law relative to exercise clause. Ended obligation of states to demonstrate a state interest and narrowly defined the burden to religious practice.
Church of lukumi babalu v city of Hialeah (1993)
Passed a law prohibiting animal sacrifice practiced by a large clandestine religion of mostly ex Cubans. Stuck down as being unconstitutional because it singled out religious groups
Everson v boe (1947)
Challenged a mo law that financially reimbursed parents of children attending parochial schools. Court upheld the law on the basis that it served a secular interest.
Engel v vitale(1962)
Challenged ny state practice of school prayer at beginning of day. Court ruled it violated the establishment cause.
Prior restraint
Preventing or censoring material before its spoken or published.
Sedition
Speech or writing the advocates or incites discontent or rebellion against the government
Sedition law of 1789
First sedition law used to stifle criticism of the ruling Federalist Party. Repealed after a few years.
Espionage act of 1918
Law was used to convict any war dissenters for writing or speaking against the war effort
Alien registration act of 1941(smith act)
Designed to convict any individual who advocated the violent overthrow of the government organizing any such group or conspiring to commit any of these crimes.
Dennis v us
Challenged the smith act as applied to the conviction of leaders of the American communist party. Supreme Court ruled that the provisions under the act were constitutional.