SUBJECT 1: PART 1 Flashcards
What is substantive law?
Legal rules that determine the rights and duties of individuals and the state
What is substantive criminal law?
The prerequisites for criminal liability and elements of specific crimes
What is adjectival law?
Puts substantive criminal law into action. Criminal procedure rules are part of adjectival law
How do criminal procedure rules operate?
Operate together with common law and constitution
What does criminal procedure regulate?
Duties and powers of criminal courts and prosecutorial authority
What balance does criminal procedure aim to strike?
-Interest of society in effective criminal law enforcement +Interest of society in protection of rights of indiv suspect/charged/convicted/ sentenced for crime
What is the crime control model?
Repressing criminal conduct is most important function of criminal process
What is the due process model?
Primary function of criminal justice system is to ensure process of leading to a conviction is based on rules which ackn rights of an indiv at every stage (from pre-arrest >post-trial proceedings)
What are the 6 internal tensions in criminal procedure process?
- Rules cannot be created to only apply to criminals. System allow for innocent people in the system
2.Freedom of indiv must’nt be sacrificed to increase crime control efficiency
3.If state has absolute powers>crime is reduced at risk of tyranny. If Indiv rights are absolute >state can’t enforce crim law
4.CP Rules are positive & negative> rules authorising police action and rules limiting police authority
5.Balance accused rights and victim rights
6.Permitting unconstitutionally obtained evidence gives way to state abuse of power in evidence-gathering process
What is main criticism of due process model?
Rights of victims of crime are neglected and failure to bring factually guilty to justice
What is the purpose of the due process model?
-Ensure rights of victim are vindicated and not lead to further injustice
-Limit state power to ensure justice for all parties involved in the process
What is the punitive model?
-Similar to crime control model> rights of victim of crime are worthy of respect
What is the non-punitive model?
Emphasises prevention of crime and restorative justice.
What is restorative model?
Process that aims to avoid criminal sanctions. Offender, victim and community are involved in process to restore position that existed prior to unlawful conduct
What is the role of the victim in the criminal process?
An ordinary witness called to testify on question of guilt/innocence