sovereignty Flashcards
sovereignty
supreme, independent authority over a geographic area; monopoly over legitimate use of violence in the enforcement of its border
legitimacy
lack of legitimacy among population does not always mean problem; lack of legitimacy among coercive power holders (national police, army) = big problem; citizens willing to subject themselves because they desire protection
anarchy
where sovereigns interact, system that lacks overarching authority and enforcement; no similar sorts of enforcement system to be able to regulate affairs - up to sovereign state members themselves to how they interact; no world government; no world sovereign, no world body with a monopoly of legitimate use of violence
anarchy’s implications - realist
constant threats, constant worry about war, need to prepare for war; sovereign entities free to do what they want, say, change their mind = can’t know their intentions
realism view on WWI and anarchy
root cause = not Germany or any other powers, real culprit = european anarchy, powerful incentives for countries to seek european domination and domination
importance of sovereignty - Ukraine
president Yanukovych decided not to sign free trade and political association agreement with EU, chose closer ties with Russia - Euromaiden protests in 2013, death of protestors, regime crumbled - Yanukovych fled - Russia’s annexation of Crimea (Ukrainian peninsula) in 2014, continued civil war in eastern region for several years until people dying at constant scale - peninsula removed from Ukraine’s sovereign orbit; Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022
Iraq and sovereignty
undermine sovereignty of existing states, territory controlled expanded into Syria, Iraq, Libya, and West African countries; greatly lost territorial control remains still a threat from sovereign standpoint
anarchy’s implications - liberals
less paranoid than realists; can estimate intentions of others - regime type, whether its willing to trade; don’t see anarchy as constant war = see it as commitment problems, no higher authority to enforce rules = fewer incentive to cooperate and solve problems; loss of mutual beneficial outcomes (free trade, environmental coalitions) viewed more as market failures
anarchy’s implications - constructivists
more fluid; anarchy is what state’s make of it, state’s play a role in creating the environments in which they place themselves
constructivists vs. liberals + realists
realists - threatening environment when it comes to anarchy; liberals - opportunistic environment; constructivists - environment is mutually constitute, though interactions - states can change through dynamics that structure/nature of anarchical environment; not inherently cooperative/conflictual, identities/interests are fluid early on, but once set difficult to change
Westphalian peace conference 1643-1648
ended 30 yrs war; system where sovereign states had right to regulate within its territory
Westphalian principles
mutual recognition - see each other as a state, non-intervention in other state’s domestic affairs (religion within other state’s territory main issue at the time); equality - under international system, each viewed as states (peers) despite differing economies; similar rights, similar responsibilities; territorial integrity - clear sense of what borders are, wars became more regulated
Westphalian principles applied today
inconsistently followed; hypocrisy within European club; set of principles mutual recognition, equality, territorial integrity used among like members in a civilizational way; scramble for Africa - conference of Berlin
Westphalian principles and imperialism
steamships, railroads - improvements in technology = states that could be exploited could be increased dramatically; conference of Berlin was way to regulate competition between European powers; no sovereignty for any African peoples - Britain controls South Africa, european powers (france, Germany) will respect Britain’s sovereignty over South Africa - recognize each other’s sovereignty rights over non-white people
status quo
to be recognized as a state, other states need to recognize you as a state; “the capacity to enter into relations with other states”; can have diplomats and ambassadors - ambassador has to be accepted