Socialized & Systemized: Personality in Context Flashcards
Sex, Gender and Culture
what are some of Malala’s traits?
- tends to be extraverted, good when performing speeches
- very low neuroticism
- high in conscientiousness, agreeableness, communion, authenticity, self-actualization
- very high honesty and humility
- levels of traits are associated with psychological wellbeing
what is culture?
- customs, values, beliefs, knowledge, art, and language of a society or community
- passed from generation to generation
- are the basis for everyday behaviours and practices
what is gender?
- social and cultural meanings of different sex categories
- includes commonly associated attributes (feminine vs. masculine)
what is gender identity vs gender expression?
- gender identity - a person’s deeply-felt, inherent sense of being a man, or woman, or an alternative gender
- gender expression - a person’s expressed behaviour that communicate aspects of their gender or gender role (masculine/feminine, androgynous)
what is an example of gender being a social construct?
- used to be common practice to dress boys in gowns and dresses till age 8
- also used to be common to dress boys in pink and girls in blue
what determines a persons sexual orientation?
- is 50% heritable but also depends on environmental factors
- multiple genes play a role in same-sex orientation
- sexual orientation is on a continuous scale
what determines a persons gender identity?
- both environment and biological factors (60% heritable)
- multiple genes play a role in nonconforming identities
- olsen et al found that trans children showed patterns of gender cognition more consistent with their expressed gender than their assigned gender at birth
do all cultures think of gender as binary?
no
- many precolonial indigenous tribes recognized and respected third-gender or gender-variant people
- traditional Navajo culture recognised 4 genders, including the Nadleehi (feminine male) and the Dilbaa (masculine female)
what is low identity clarity and what does it lead to?
- not being confident in who we are, our identity (associated with suicidal ideation)
- in gay and straight women, ambiguity about sexual identity has been associated with alcohol misuse and suicidal ideation
- low cultural identity clarity in indigenous youth has been associated with low subjective well-being and low self-esteem, suicidal ideation, and physical and relational aggression
what is most likely to compromise identity clarity?
- invalidating a person’s identity
- attacking and restricting a person’s identity (hate and discrimination)
what is intersectionality?
the study of intersecting, overlapping social identities and labels; and related systems of discrimination and oppression
- ex. women are more likely than men to go missing, but indigenous women are more likely to go missing than any other women
- ex. trans women are more likely to be murdered than other trans people, but trans people of colour are the most at risk
how does intersectionality come into play in Malala’s life?
- intersectionality between her culture and gender
- she became an activist because of the sociocultural environment she grew up in, but also because of her being a woman
- also intersectionality between her culture and age
what are the problems in the research on sex differences?
- reliance on sex-gender binaries and cisgender people
- possible exaggeration of differences, stereotype reinforcement
- insufficient attention to intersectionality
how do we measure sex differences?
- look into meta-analyses to observe size of differences (cohen’s d)
- effect size is averaged across studies to give objective assessment of difference
what is a small, medium, and large effect size, and what does it mean in the study of sex differences?
0.20 - small effect
0.50 - medium effect
0.80 - large effect
- positive d means men are higher
- negative d means women are higher
what is the maximalist view on sex differences?
- more attention paid to sex differences because they think that they matter
- think that even small differences could have larger cumulative effects (ex. helping behaviour)
what is the minimalist view on sex differences?
- believe that the differences between sexes are very small
- there are more differences within groups than between groups
- there is a lot of overlap between average levels of traits in men and women
what is the gender similarity hypothesis?
- in line with the minimalist view
- suggests that men and women are similar in most, but not all, psychological variables
- meta analyses found 78% of sex differences were small or close to 0
- but, men are more aggressive and have more sexual activity
- it is still important to study sex difference because it affects other personality aspects
- ex. men were more likely to not follow safety precautions during covid because of ideas of masculinity
what are the biggest sex differences in the Big Five traits?
- women are more neurotic (moderate difference)
- could be because of socialization of emotional expression
- women are slightly more extraverted (very small difference)
- women are more agreeable (moderate difference)
- men score higher in agentic traits and women score higher on communion traits
what are the biggest sex differences in temperament in children?
- girls are more able to control inappropriate behaviours (inhibitory control)
- girls are more able to detect subtle stimuli from the environment (perceptual sensitivity)
- boys have more approach behaviour and impulsivity (surgency)
- girls are more fearful and boys have more anger expression
what are the main sex differences in agreeableness, how do they translate to nurturance?
- females across cultures consistently score higher on all aspects of agreeableness
- including trust and tender-mindedness
- females also score higher on warmth (extraversion) and empathy
- these traits are associated with higher tendency towards nurturance
what are the main sex differences in aggressiveness?
- by age 4 or 5, males show higher aggression (low agreeableness)
- across cultures, males are more aggressive, as assessed on personality tests, in fantasies, and in behaviours
- males are higher in the dark triad and tetrad
- including psychopathy and antisocial personality disorder
- we think large difference is driven by a small subset of men who are extremely high in aggression
what is the difference between overt vs. relational aggression? how do they relate to sex differences in aggression?
- overt aggression - physical and verbal aggression
- relational aggression - excluding people, starting rumours, etc
- maybe there is no difference in internal causal property, but different ways of displaying aggression in men and women
- could be because of socialization - boys encouraged to be aggressive but girls are forced to hide it
- some argue men are more diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder because the DSM is based on the way that men express these traits
- argue women display antisocial personality disorder differently
how do men and women differ in the frequency and intensity of their emotions?
- women experience positive and negative emotions more frequently and more intensely than men
- biggest sex differences: affection, joy, fear, sadness
- minimal sex differences in pride and guilt
what are the main sex differences in self-esteem?
- men have more self-esteem across the lifespan
- difference in levels of self-esteem is largest in childhood and becomes smaller in adulthood
- suggests that it’s tied to environmental and situational factors
what are some possible reasons for sex differences in self-esteem?
- during adolescence, many girls accept stereotypical notions for how they should be
- repress true feelings to adopt a woman-like self-presentation
- idealize standards of beauty
- greater bodily changes, more discrepancy between real and ideal body types
what is the cross-cultural perspective on sex differences in self-esteem?
- consistent with previous research, found age-related increases in self-esteem from late adolescence to middle adulthood
- also found significant gender gaps, with males consistently higher reports of self-esteem
what are the findings regarding self-esteem in collectivist cultures?
- more of an increase of self-esteem in males and females overall
- difference between self-esteem in males and females is less
why might the self-esteem gap be larger in individualistic cultures?
- sex differences overall, are larger in individualistic cultures that have more gender equality
- could be because individualistic cultures are more aware of inequalities
- also, differences in height of sexes are larger in individualistic cultures
how do men and women differ in sexuality and emotional investment?
- men have permissive attitudes toward casual sex, desire more sex partners, have more frequent sexual fantasies, and are more willing to accept sex from strangers
- men who have “hostile masculinity” and who lack empathy use sexual aggression more often
- women have more emotional investment
- could be due to evolution of sex difference in attachment to children and partners
what is the people-things dimension?
- things dimension - prefer careers that deal with impersonal objects
- ex. carpenters, mechanics, building contractors, tool makers, farmers
- people dimension - prefer social occupations that involve thinking of others, caring for others, or directing others
- ex. teachers, social workers, nurses, and counsellors
- men are more likely to be closer to the things dimension and women closer to people dimension
- similar to empathizing-systemizing distinction
why were masculinity, femininity, and androgyny important in research?
- first believed sex differences were due to differences in masculinity-femininity
- then bem argued there might be another dimension that is independent, androgyny
- androgyny - the possession of high levels of both masculine and feminine attributes (most adaptable)