Social influence Flashcards
Who is Kelman(1958)
suggested 3 types of conformity
What are the 3 types of conformity?
-compliance
-identification
-internalisation
What is compliance?
-publicly changing views but privately disagreeing
What is identification?
-publicly and privately changing beliefs and behaviour but is is temporary
What is internalisation?
-an individual publicly and privately changes their beliefs and behaviour because they have genuinely accepted the views of the group
What did Deutsch and Gerard (1955) propose?
-The 2 process theory-2 reasons why people conform
What is informative social influence(ISI)
-people conform due to the desire to be right
-it is a cognitive process
-it is a form of internalisation
What is normative social influence(NSI)
-people conform due to the desire to be liked
-it is an emotional process
-it is a form of compliance
What are some features of Asch’s baseline study?
-lab experiment
-123 male American participants
-volunteer sampling was used
What was the procedure of Asch’s experiment?
-pps saw 2 large cards, one with a standard line and 1 with a comparison line. Each person in the room had to state which comparison line was the same length as the standard line
-each naive participant was tested with a group of 6-8 confederates
What were the results to Aschs study
-pps gave the wrong answer 36.8% of the time
-25% never conformed
-74% conformed at least once
-in the control group, with no pressure to conform to confederates, less than 1% of participants gave the wrong answer
-this shows there were high levels of conformity when the situation was unambiguous
What was the conclusion to Aschs study
-participants conformed due to fear of rejection(NSI)
What were Asch’s variations?
-Group size, unanimity, task difficulty
How did variating the group size affect the results?
-when there were2 confederates, conformity to the wrong answer was 13.6%
-3 confederates caused conformity rising to 31.8%
-further increases to the majority made little difference to conformity
How did unanimity affect the results?
-Asch introduced a dissenting confederate-someone who gave the wrong answer sometimes and the right answer sometimes but always disagreed with majority
-conformity reduced by 1/4
How did task difficulty affect the results?
-Asch made the line-judging task harder by making the stimulus line and comparisons lines more similar in length
-conformity increases
What are some limitations of Asch’s study
-lacks temporal validity(1950’s was a conformist time in America)
-situation and task was artificial so demand characteristics could have occured
-it was biased-Men and American
-ethical issues
What is a strength of Asch’s study?
-it is easy to replicate
-standardised procedures
How can Lucas et al.(2006) support Asch’s study?
-carried out the math experiment and found people were more likely to conform when they were not confident in their own math abilities
What is conformity?
-a change in a person’s behaviour or beliefs as a result of a real or imagined pressure from a person or a group of people
What is a social role?
-A set of behaviour that are expected of someone who holds a particular status
What did Zimbardo(1971) argue?
-argued that it is the situation that makes people act the way they do rather than their disposition(personality)
What was the method for the Stanford prison experiment?
-controlled observation: mock prison was created in the basement of Stanford University
-Zimbardo played the role of lead researcher and prison superintendent so it was also a participant observation
-participants responded to a newspaper ad so it was a volunteer sample
What was the sample for Zimbardo’s experiment?
-24 ‘emotionally stable men who were also white and middle class students
What was the procedure for Zimbardo’s experiment?
-prisoners were arrested in their homes and delivered to the prison
-some of their basic civil rights were gone
-prisoner’s names were not used just their numbers
-the guards had their own uniform consisting of a wooden club, handcuffs, keys. They worked in teams of 3 for 8-hour shifts and were allowed off site after their shift