SOC FINAL: Week 9-12 Flashcards
Conflict theory
-Perspective that sees crime as the outcomes of class struggle though economic inequality
-Established by people in power
-Crime caused by intergroup rivalry
True crimes
-Racism, sexism, Imperialism
-Housing, childcare, working conditions,
-Pollution, wars
Marxism
-Industrial revolution
-Productive forces: Tech sources, material sources, energy sources
-Relation of production: People involved in the production
What would a social conflict theorist see as the most important feature of class?
Class groupings tell us about who has power to exploit others
Early conflict theorists
-Willem Bonger
-Ralf Dahrendorf
-George Vold
Willem Bonger
-Divided into “have” and “have not” groups (based on lineage)
-Law serves the ruling class
-Resources are monopolized by the wealthy (ruling class) leading to law breaking
Ralf Dahrendorf
-Imperatively coordinated associations: Authority/domination relationship
-Society has multiple competing interest groups
-Proposed a unified conflict theory
-Capitalism
George Vold
-Laws are created by politically oriented groups
-Different groups gain power
-Government is used to protect interests and defend rights
-Law creation creates conflict, every stage of the process has conflict
Modern conflict theory
-Self report studies show a more even distribution of crime across class groups than official statistics
-Discrimination through CJS
-New research focus
-1960’s- 1970’s: Social and political upheaval supported the development of conflict theory
New research focus
1) Identifying “real” crimes in society (Crenshaw)
2) Evaluating how the law is a mechanism of social control
3) Refocus on social inequality
Main objectives of conflict criminology
-Describe how the control of political/economic systems affects the CJS
-Show how definitions of crime favor those who control the CJS
-Show how justice is skewed/uneven (white collar crimes)
Power relations
-Unequal distribution between power/wealth creates conflict
-only 13% police are women
-only 3% of public police forces are visible minorities
-Structure of the CJS and discretionary decision making further victimizes minorities
Social reality of crime
-Theory proposed by Richard Quinney on interrelationships between power, society and criminality
1) Changing social conditions
2) Emerging interests
3) Increased demands to protect political, economic and religious interests
4) Changing conceptions of public interest
-Concepts of crime are controlled by the powerful and CJS works to secure their needs
Norm resistence
-Social conflict is inevitable
-Authorities are in conflict with groups with low/no control over the law and who are controlled by the law
-Both groups have cultural and social norms
-Interactions between authorities and subjects produce norm resistance (open conflict)
Research methods
-Historical (focus on social and economic issues rather than just crime rates)
-May consider the relationship between the CJS and class conflict
-“Dangerous classes”
-Bail hearings and pre-trial detention
-Police may use public funds to defund their reputation
-Victim demographics influence policing
-R. V Gladue
‘Dangerous classes”
-Personal characteristics (young, single, urban, male, racialized) may result in harsher sentencing/treatment in the CJS
Development of radical criminology
-Conference formed to critique positivist criminology
-Taylor, Walton, and Young: The New Criminology and Critical Criminology
-Correctionalist: Social science seeks to correct criminal behaviors rather than explain it
Fundamentals of Marxist criminology
-Values political/ideological foundations over empiricism
-Capitalism has always produced high level of violence and crime
-Each society will produce it’s own types/amounts of crime
-Each society will have it’s own distinctive ways of dealing with criminal behavior
-Each society gets the amount and type of crime it deserves
-Criminals are not outsiders who can be controlled by law enforcement
-Crime is a product of how the society is structured
Instrumental Marxism
-The law is designed to specifically advance the interests of particular groups and organizations
-Law allows those in power to advance themselves
Structural marxism
-The law maintains the capitalist system, and those who threatened stability will be punished
-Law controls people OF ANY CLASS if they go AGAINST capitalism
left realism
-Invested in due process > crime control
-How does street crime effect communities
-Marxism is utopian and idealistic but not based in reality
-Pushed for the focus on the victim
-Law enforcement would be a life saving tool if there was less force and more sensitivity
-Pre-emptive deterrence: Efforts to reduce crime before it is necessary for police involvement
Marxist feminism
-Gender inequality stems from the unequal power of men and women in capitalism
-Seen through use of private property, male domination and exploitation of women
-Capitalism and patriarchy
-Women have less opportunity for white collar crimes and are denied access to male dominated street crimes
-Masculinity scholarship
Masculinity scholarship
-Marxist feminist
-Men emulate behavior that are culturally coded as ideal masculine behaviors
Radical feminism
-view that crime by women is caused by the patriarchy and by the subordination and control of women through men
-Many women who commit crimes are also victims
-Critiqued as white feminism