Sjorgen's Syndrome and Therapies Flashcards
What is Sjorgen’s syndrome?
Second-most common autoimmune rheumatic disease
- Chronic inflammation of exocrine glands – particularly salivary and lacrimal glands
- Prevalence 0.1-0.6%
- 9 Female: 1 male
- Standardised mortality ratio 1.38 (95% CI 0.94, 2.01)
- However, confidence intervals cross 1 so can’t be certain that mortality is greater than background population
- Some groups have increased mortality
- For most patients, mortality isn’t greatly increased, but does impact quality of life
what are the key glandular symptoms of Sjorgen’s syndrome (SS)?
Severe dryness of eyes and mouth
- Oral dryness – low saliva production – difficulty swallowing, speaking, affects sense of taste and smell
- Staining of ocular surface -> pink = disrupted epithelial surface of eye – eye feels gritty, can’t look at screens for long, discomfort on eye surface
- Swelling of salivary glands e.g. parotid gland
- 1/3 patients have systemic manifestation: vasculitis (inflammation of small blood vessels in skin)
what are the extraglandular symptoms of SS?
- Fatigue – common in most patients due to chronic inflammation
- Hypergammaglobulinaemia – high IgG
- Arthralgia – joint pain
- Cutaneous vasculitis - inflammation of skin blood vessels
- Raynaud’s phenomenon – inflammation of lungs
- Interstitial lung disease
- Peripheral neuropathy – sensory nerve fibres affected – pins and needles or loss of feeling in toes and hands
- Renal tubular acidosis in small no. patients – affects ability of kidneys to excrete acid
- Lymphoma – 5% go on to develop B cell lymphoma - worse mortality
- severe systemic manifestation like lung disease can also affect long-term mortality
what lymphocytic infiltrates are present in the salivary glands of SS patients?
Salivary gland tissue:
- Periductal infiltration of lymphocytes
- In mild lesion: predominant T cell infiltrate
- Severe lesion: predominant B cell
In larger lesions:
- ¼ patients have segregated B and T cell areas – GC-like formation to support autoantibody production in glandular tissue
- Ectopic lymphoid structures/TLS
how is SS classified/defined?
Diagnosis is for clinical studies and practice
Classification criteria is mainly designed for research: don’t need to remember these
- 4 or more points = SS (Sjorgens syndrome)
- Schirmer test – filter paper under eyelid – less then 5mm wetting in 5 mins = positive test for dryness
- whole unstimulated salivary flow rate - less than 0.1ml saliva per minute
- To be sure that patient has SS, need positive autoantibody or positive biopsy e.g. anti-Ro antibody
- anti-Ro can be present in other diseases, but tends to segregate with SS in context of dryness
how can the cornea be stained?
2 stains combined for ocular staining score
Fluorescein staining for cornea
- high stain = lots of epithelial erosion on front of cornea
- May affect vision, defo causes ocular fatigue and discomfort on eye surface
Lissamine green stain:
- Stains conjunctivae of eye
- Staining on outside is abnormal
- Top left = fairly normal
- Bottom right = extensive confluent staining – disrupted epithelial surface - uncomfortable
is SS associated with other autoimmune diseases?
SS can occur alone in absence of other AI disease = Primary SS
Secondary SS tend to be associated with another rheumatic autoimmune disease
- SS occurring in context of SLE, RA or systemic sclerosis
SS can occur in context of thyroid autoimmunity or primary biliary cirrhosis
- This isn’t secondary SS in these contexts
is SS closer to SLE pathogenesis than RA?
SS occurs in RA or lupus, but pathogenesis is more aligned with lupus
- HLA-DR4 strongly associated in RA, as well as TNF production and macrophages
- In SS, mostly associated with HLA-DR3, presence anti-Rho and anti-nuclear antibodies (ANAs) – similar to SLE patients
how do SS and SLE differ?
Despite similarities SS and SLE do differ
- Lung involvement in SLE is pleurisy, whereas in SS it represents infiltration of lymphocytes into lung parenchyma (interstitial pneumonitis)
- For kidney involvement, in SLE its glomerulonephritis, in SS its infiltration of lymphocytes into intertisium (nephritis) – can lead to renal tubular acidosis
why can SS be described as autoimmune epithelitis?
SS may represent autoimmune reaction to epithelium – autoimmune epithelitis
what mice can be used to model SS?
NOD mice – used as model of diabetes – infiltration of pancreas with inflammatory cells
- NOD mice can model SS – they get autoimmune inflammation of salivary glands (sialadenitis)
NOD-SCID mice
- SCID mice lack adaptive immunity, don’t have lymphocytes
- When SCID are crossed with NOD, they lack functioning immune system that can cause sialadenitis, but they have changes in their salivary glands, that are non-immune induced changes
- Over time, reduction in amylase enzyme produced by glands, and upregulation of proteins associated with salivary gland damage, and reduction in size of submandibular glands
how have NOD-SCID mice led to the hypothesis that SS is autoimmune epithelitis?
Changes occurring in the mice in absence of functioning immune system led to hypothesis that changes in epithelium occur first, and that immune changes are secondary in response to that
what is the model of SS pathogenesis?
- Resting epithelium is disturbed e.g. by genetic change, by reduction in oestrogen, by EBV infection of salivary glands
- This dysregulated epithelium produces chemokines – leads to lymphocyte recruitment
- Lymphocytes interacs with epithelium – further dysregulates epithelium
- This attracts plasmacytoid DCs – primary type 1 IFN producers
- This can lead to production of B cell activating factor (BAFF) in salivary glands – this leads to activation and survival of B cells
- Leads to activation of T cells induced by dysregulated epithelium
- Leads to lymphocyte-activated environment and SS pathology
how have changes in oestrogen been implicated in SS?
peak onset is in 40-60 years in women – could be that menopause and drop in oestrogen disturbs epithelium
what evidence is there for polyclonal B cell activation in SS?
While T cells are important, strong evidence is for B cell component
- High levels of BAFF correlate with disease activity
Animal model: BAFF transgenic mice
- These develop similar condition to SLE and SS
- Small proportion of these mice develop B cell lymphoma
presence of autoantibodies and high immunoglobulin levels - polyclonal B cell activation
TLS in salivary glands
B cell lymphoma can develop in 5% of SS patients
what autoantibodies are present in SS?
- anti-Ro
- anti-la
- RF
how are type 1 IFNs implicated in SS?
Increased IFN1 in pSS
Polymorphisms in IFN1 pathway associated with pSS - IRF5, STAT4
Hard to measure protein level of IFN1 in peripheral blood
- But can look at transcriptomic levels of IFN1 transcripts
- Look at transcripts upregulated in response to IFN1 – these inducible transcripts are upregulated in pSS and they correlate with anti-Ro and anti-La levels
- pDCs are upregulated in salivary glands and reduced in peripheral blood in pSS – increased trafficking to sites of inflammation for IFN1 release
what is the model of IFN1 in SS?
- IFN1 activate epithelial cells, CD8 T cells
- Anti-Ro antibodies may drive IFN1
- Anti-Ro bind proteins that are RNA binding proteins
- Forms immune complexes containing antibody protein bound to small H1-RNAs
- pDCs internalise immune complexes
- These immune complexes stimulate FcRs and TLRs
- TLRs bind the RNA
- Both receptors provide strong stimulus to pDCs to produce IFN1s – vicious cycle
- this may explain why SS patients with anti-Ro tend to have high levels of IFN1
what are the current symptomatic treatments of SS?
- Artificial tears for patients with dry eyes– can control symptoms nicely, but some still have dry eyes even though they use the drops often – not always satisfactory and still discomfort and impaired vision
- Punctal plugs – put plug into duct that drains tears away to conserve tears – retain tears but can be harmful as MMPs and enzymes are retained
- Saliva substitutes (sprays or gels) – can be short-lived
- Pilocarpine (muscarinic agonist) – mimics neurological signal to stimulate saliva flow, but non-specific so can cause sweating, increasing urine passing, bowel discomfort, multiple times a day needed to be effective
how is inflammation controlled/treated in SS?
Hydroxychloroquine – inhibits TLRs, reducing IFN1 signalling
Immunosuppression for some extraglandular manifestations e.g. inflammatory arthritis, inflammation of lung
does HCQ improve symptoms?
Looked at symptoms of dryness, fatigue and pain of >100 patients
- HCQ has no clear difference to placebo in improving symptoms
- HCQ is good for rash, joint inflammation, but not very effective
- Biologically, HCQ reduces total immunoglobulins (IgM, IgG, ESR) and IFN1 signature – but not large effects
how is there an unmet clinical need in SS?
No licensed therapy for SS
Why?
- Less understanding of pathogenesis
what are the barriers to successful therapy in SS?
Identifying needs
- Costs - costs of drugs can be high and funders need to agree to pay based on the cost of the disease to society
- Quality of life
Identifying therapeutic targets to understand pathogenesis
What does a good treatment look like?
- Outcome measures
- How can a trial be designed to show that drug works – need valid outcome measure
how may SS be a cost to society?
- People with SS are less likely to work – cost to society – indirect impact
- Cost of SS is 81% of RA in direct healthcare costs, and similar with indirect (69-83% of the costs of RA)
- SS costs a lot for healthcare system and society - need to demonstrate this to show need for drugs