Significance of educational policies Flashcards
What is educational policy
Plans and strategies for education introduced by gov
Left wing view on education
-Should reduce Social inequalities + focus on underachieving groups
-All should have equal op to do well
-Should tackle inequalities
Right wing view on education
-Should provide choices
-Should look to private sector as good example
-Students own responsibility if don’t do well
-Marketisation = important part of education
5 main issues
-Selection policies
-Marketisation and privatisation
-Policies achieving greater equality of opportunity
-impact of policies on achievement of social groups
-Impact of globalisation on educational policy
What is selective education
-Entry criteria students need to meet in order to go to particular school (IQ tests)
-Prefer to select brightest + well behaved
-Prefer students w/ m.c parents who encourage Childs education
3 types of selection policies
1-Selection by ability
2-Selection by aptitude
3-Selection by faith
Selection by ability
-Selecting based on academic ability
-1944 Butler Act : introduced triparte system (3 types of secondary school)
-Everyone sat iq test called 11+
-If passed : Grammar
-If failed :Technical or secondary modern.
Selection by ability
-Selecting based on academic ability
-1944 Butler Act : introduced triparte system (3 types of secondary school)
-Everyone sat iq test called 11+
-If passed : Grammar
-If failed :Technical or secondary modern.
Criticisms of Triparte system
-M.c bias –> q’s based upon mc knowledge (classical music , Shakespeare , poetry)
-Reproduced social class inequalities (grammar filled w/ mc students while others had mostly w.c)
-Gender inequality –> few grammar school places for girls so had to achieve higher place than boots
Is selection by ability still a thing ?
-Now banned in all state funded schools .
-Most private schools have selection by ability (entrance exams)
Is selection by ability still a thing ?
-Now banned in all state funded schools .
-Most private schools have selection by ability (entrance exams)
Selection by aptitude
-Students selected based on aptitude or potential to be good at certain subjects
-Specialist schools allowed to select up to 10% of students on basis of aptitude in specialist subjects .
Selection by faith
-Faith schools may select proportion of students on basis of religious beliefs and commitment of their parents
-Example : St Marys college in Hull
Evaluation of selection policies
-Seleciton by ability banned in all state schools but cream skimming still exists
0Students selected that are seen as most able and hardworking (often m.c students female or from Chinese backgrounds)
Marketisation and Privatiation
-Root in neo-liberalism
>Economic approach suggesting resources more efficiently managed by private businesses
>Public services (education and healthcare) –> private sectore
-Claim best way to deliver and improve quality of public services is through making them operate like private businesses.
-Neo liberalism = feature of N.R approach to education underpinning conservative education policies
What is marketisation
-Market forces of supply and demand based on consumer choice should be introduced to education system
-To improv education schools should be run like businesses
-Parents should be consumers shopping around for right state school
-This will inc comp so inc standards as schools will want to attract new parents n students
1988 Education Reform Act
+ 3 policies it introduced
-New right policy (conservative gov)
-Introduced education market
-Schools ran like businesses responding to needs and demands of consumer
-Competiotion would inc standard forcing schools to deliver best education
Introduced 3 policies
-Parental choice, league tables and formula funding
Parental choice (parentocracy
-Until education reform act parents tended to send school to local schools
-Act let parents decide which school they feel is best suited
-Shopping around looking at Open days , ofsted reports, prospectuses
-Parents became inc powerful in shaping the education system,
2 Criticisms of parental choice
A-C economy due to competitive climate. Gilbourn Youdel : teachers allocate more resources on C/D borderline while students in ‘hopeless case’ category given no extra support
Cream Skimming - good schools can be more selective often choosing mc students .
League tables
-Exam results published in league tables
-Encourage parentocracy as parents can make informed choice by comparing ‘success rates’ of diff schools
-Encourage comp between schools for best exam results and highest positions
-conserv gov believed l.tables would make it easy to identify best schools and shame worst into improving standards
Criticisms of league tables
-Comp climate –> a-c economy + educational triage
GGilborn + Youdell : c/d borderline helped but hopeless cases given no support
-Disavantages less able students and reproduces Social class inequalities
-Encouragees cream skimming - selectivity of choosing students etc
Formula funding
-Money schools receive for each student enrolled
-Rewards pop schools
-Schools that succeed in ed market make most money so can improve most
-Schools that dont attract enough at risk of closing down
-Raising standards by encouraging pop schools to maintaining high standards and giving less successful schools incentive to improve .