Selection & Presentation Flashcards
How can the selection and presentation of news be biased?
- Reflects the values and assumptions of media producers
- Can favor dominant class views
- Uses biased language (e.g., “trouble-makers”)
- Gives more airtime to certain groups (e.g., police or management)
What did the Glasgow University Media Group (GUMG) find about news reporting on strikes?
- News favored dominant class
- Voice-overs supported employers
- More access was given to management than strikers
- Police violence was downplayed
- Strikers were portrayed negatively
Why is the appearance of objectivity in news dangerous?
- Makes bias seem neutral
- Increases believability of dominant narratives
- Encourages acceptance of mainstream ideology
What does it mean that news is socially constructed?
- Reflects journalists’ values and societal norms
- Not objective — shaped by human choices
- Influenced by dominant ideology
- Constructed through selection and framing
According to Marxists, why is news biased?
- Journalists are part of ruling class ideology
- Economic and ideological influences shape content
- Promotes the interests of capitalism
How has new media changed the selection and presentation of news?
- People skim content quickly
- Sensational and scandalous headlines gain clicks
- Citizens contribute via social media
- Stories change in real-time
- Errors and misinformation can spread more easily
What is citizen journalism?
- Ordinary people reporting news
- Often via social media (e.g., live tweets, photos, videos)
- Public participation in shaping stories
What are the key impacts of new media?
- Real-time news updates
- Diverse sources
- Greater public involvement
- Risk of misinformation
- Blurred line between journalist and public
What assumptions do media professionals make about their audience?
- What stories will attract attention
- What fits ‘public interest’
- Use of audience values to filter content
- Focus on stories that serve political/business agendas
How can advertisers and the government influence news content?
- Profit-seeking media may avoid offending advertisers
- Governments may suppress critical content
- Influence what gets reported or ignored
- Example: Suppression of Iraq War images
Why do some argue that news content should be regulated?
- To prevent harm (e.g., defamation, legal breaches)
- Protect public interest
- Maintain ethical standards
- Example: Leveson Inquiry after phone hacking scandal
What are the practical constraints on news production?
- Time — quick turnaround, repeat sources
- Space — limited room, stories shortened
- Money — budget limits, cheaper content prioritized
- Technology — easier access to some areas than others
- Competition — popular, sensational stories prioritized
What is the role of press releases in news selection?
- Save time and money
- Delivered straight to newsrooms
- Increases chance of being published
- Often from celebrities, politicians, corporations
What are bureaucratic news values (Galtung & Ruge, 1965)?
- News should be current
- News should be simple
- News should be brief
- Big news is better than small news
What are cultural news values?
- News should be unexpected
- Focus on important people
- Be relevant to the audience
- Bad news is preferred over good news
What is agenda-setting in journalism?
- Journalists/editors decide what is newsworthy
- Shapes audience perception
- Influences what people think about
- Based on what catches public attention
What is gate-keeping in journalism?
- Editors control what is published
- Decide how much space is given
- Acts like a filter — some stories enter, others blocked
- Influences public knowledge
Why do some stories get underreported?
- Hard to access areas (e.g., war zones)
- Lack of technical resources
- Unpopular or complex topics
- Political pressure
- Budget constraints
What did Yvonne Jewkes (2004) argue about news content?
- Influenced by how journalists construct stories
- Uses ‘news values’ to decide what to include
- Public interest often shaped by government and media interests
What did Herman and Chomsky (1988) argue about media content?
- Media is profit-seeking
- Influenced by advertisers and big corporations
- Avoids content that could offend sponsors
What did Edwards and Cromwell (2006) find about Iraq War images?
- Images were suppressed in media
- Critical coverage was minimized
- Shows government and advertiser influence
What is the role of the Press Complaints Commission (PCC)?
- Industry self-regulation body
- Deals with audience complaints
- Aims to uphold journalistic standards
- Was criticized for lack of power
What triggered the Leveson Inquiry (2011-12)?
- News of the World phone hacking scandal
- Journalists accessed mobile phones illegally
- Led to major criticism of press ethics
What were the recommendations of the Leveson Inquiry?
- Stronger press regulation
- Independent oversight
- Government-backed but free from direct state control