secured transactions Flashcards
lease v. security interest
courts look at economic reality to determine if a lease is actually a security interest
lease will be security interest if
1. commitment to make payments for a term exists AND
2. either: OG term is equal to or greater than the remaining economic life of goods,
lessee must renew the lease for the remaining economic life of the goods or is forced to take ownership,
lessee has an option to renew the lease for the remaining economic life of the goods for no additional consideration or
lessee has the option to become the owner of the goods for no additional consideration
collateral: farm products
crops or livestock or supplies used or produced in farming operations or products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states if they are in possession of someone engaged in farming operations
types of collateral: account
a right to payment of monetary obligation whether or not earned by performance
includes property that has been or is to be sold, leased, disposed of services rendered policy of insurance secondary obligation incurred energy provided use or hire of vessel under charter or contract credit card debt lottery winnings
types of collateral: deposit account
a demand, time, savings, or similar account maintained with bank (can only be perfected by control)
does not include investment property or accounts evidenced by instrument
types of collateral: inventory
goods that are leased, held for sale or lease or to be given under k of service, given under k of service, or consisting of raw materials, working process, or materials used/consumed in business
does not include farm products or goods held only for repair
types of collateral: equipment
goods other than inventory, farm products, or consumer goods
this is catchall category for “goods”
goods = all things moveable when the security interest attaches
certificate of title statute: some states require that security interest in car be noted on the title in order to be perfected
types of collateral: instrument
pieces of paper representing the right to be paid money, like promissory note, drafts, and certificates for deposit
types of collateral: consumer goods
goods purchased primarily for personal, family, or household purposes
types of collateral: proceeds
the following types of property:
acquired upon sale, lease, or other disposition of collateral
collected/distributed on account of collateral
rights arising out of collateral
claims arising out of loss, nonconformity, defect, or interference with the use of collateral or
insurance payable by loss of collateral
check in exchange for collateral is cash proceeds
types of collateral: chattel paper
a record that evidences a monetary obligations and a security interest in specific goods
collateral types: accounts
right to payment for goods sold or services rendered
note: contract obligations arising from loan is not an account it is a general intangible
collateral types: deposit account
an account maintained at a bank
only applies to nonconsumer deposit account
collateral type: investment property
includes items such as stock, bonds, mutual funds, and brokerage funds
types of collateral: general intangibles
any personal property not coming within other definitions - trademark, copyrights, etc.
also includes monetary obligations
this is the catchall for intangible things
attachment and perfection
enforcing a security interest depends on two factors:
- attachment = secures the creditor’s rights in the collateral, making it enforceable (security interest has been created) attachment gives creditor rights against debtor
- perfection = gives notice of the creditors rights in collateral (determines priority of interests) gives creditor rights against the world/other creditors
security interest cannot be perfected unless it is first attached
requirements of attachment
creditor extend value to debtor
debtor have rights in the collateral AND
security agreement (must be authenticated, or can be oral if collateral is in possession of creditor -i.e., pledge)
requirements for security agreement in writing
- evidenced by a record: agreement must be evidenced by record and must show an intent to create a security interest
- agreement must be authenticated by debtor - aka signed by debtor
- description of collateral - reasonably identifiable
requirements of perfection
obtained by filing a financing statement with the secretary of state or taking possession or control of the collateral
after acquired property clause
grant of security interest in property acquired in the future
this is permissible - just a provision in the security agreement that we enforce
if there is no after acquired clause in security agreement, the secured party’s interest only reaches collateral that debtor had rights in at time of signing
future advance clause
grant of security agreement to secure future loans where they are contemplating such future loans
– must be in conjunction with after acquired property clause, or it only extends to present collateral owned
exceptions: security interest will auto attach without future advance clause to collateral of a type that is
rapidly depleted and replenished or
identifiable proceeds of collateral (commingled cash proceeds, lowest intermediate balance rule applies)
proceeds
very broad
includes WHATEVER is received upon sale, exchange, etc., of collateral as long as it is identifiable - i.e., secured creditor can prove the proceeds can be traced back to original collateral
lowest intermediate balance rule
look at bank account starting at time proceeds are deposited and ending at the time you are applying the rule - the lowest balance during that time is secured parties proceeds
cannot be more than the amount dumped into the account tho
after acquired property clause does not apply to..
after acquired property clause
- does not apply to consumer goods unless debtor acquires rights in the goods within 10 days after the creditor gives value
- does not apply to commercial tort claims
financing statement
UCC-1
document used to convey notice of security interest – best way to perfect security interest
requires
- debtor name
- - use of trade name is not sufficient
- - individual debtor = the name you use is whatever is on unexpired drivers license - if no DL, then you file under the name you are known in the community
- - error in debtor name: search correct name using standard search logic, if it would turn up the correct statement, then it is not seriously misleading. if it does not, then it is seriously misleading.
- - name change: good under old name for 4 months - must amend in 4 months to correct name - describe collateral: reasonably identify the collateral
- - does not have to mention after-acquired property to perfect interest in property if the description is broad enough to include it
- - super generic statements are OK here, unlike in security interest (i.e., can use all debtors inventory) - secured party’s name
- debtor must authorize filing of financing statement
does not require signature to authorize - only has to authorize the creditor to file the statement
debtor does so by any signed writing **
**debtor automatically authorizes if debtor signs the security agreement covering the same collateral - lack of addresses does not make it ineffective
**if involving real property – must contain description of the related property, name of record owner (if not debtor) and indication that it is to be filed in real property records
errors are OK as long as not seriously misleading
which state law governs perfection?
gen rule: law of state where debtor is located
exceptions:
possessory security interests/fixtures/timber to be cut = where collateral located
goods covered by title = state issuing most recent certificate of title
deposit accounts = state in which bank has CEO office
investment property = state where certificate security is located or if un secured security, state where issuers organized governs
methods of perfection
- automatic: automatically perfected upon attachment – this is PSMI in consumer goods
- possession (pledge): actual possession of the collateral – will be perfected from the moment of possession and continues as long as possession is retained (cannot apply to things you cant take physical possession of i.e., intangibles, accounts, etc.) only way to perfect security interest in money is possession
- control: security interest, chattel paper, and nonconsumer deposit accounts **nonconsumer deposit accounts can ONLY be perfected by control
Nonconsumer deposit account control: (3 methods)
a. automatic control by bank maintaining account
b. putting account in secured party’s name
c. control agreement - k b/t debtor, creditor, and bank where account is, giving permission to seize account if they default
- filing: filing either electronically or in writing, a financial statement –> does not apply to deposit accounts or money
**this focuses on the relationship b/t creditor and OTHER creditors NOT b/t the creditor and debtor
unperfected does NOT mean they are unsecured – security attaches at attachment - they can be an unperfected secured creditor
PSMI
- secured party sells goods to debtor on credit and retains a security interest in goods sold or
- creditor loans the funds to the debtor to enable the debtor to buy specific collateral, those funds are used by debtor to acquire specific collateral, and the creditor takes security interest in that collateral
perfection for motor vehicles
notation on the certificate of title issued by state
exception: dealers (req filing financial statement to perfect)
perfection of proceeds
attachment = proceeds identifiable
perfection automatic for 20 days
perfection continues if proceeds are cash OR
same office rule applies: OG collateral is perfected by financing statement, security interest in proceeds type that would be perfected by filing in same place, and proceeds not purchased with cash proceeds from collateral
priority between perfected secured parties
priority goes to whichever party was the first to either file or perfect – whichever is earlier – provided there is no period thereafter when there is neither filing nor perfection
priority b/t unperfected secured parties
first to attach has priority
priority b/t unperfected and perfected secured parties
perfected security interest prevails over an unperfected security interest
PMSI priority
PMSI enjoy superpriority
they are superior to prior perfected security interests in the same collateral if conditions are met:
- PMSI in goods other than inventory and livestock - has priority over conflicting security in same goods or their proceeds if the interest is perfected before or within 20 days after the debtor receives possession of the goods
* *if this doesn’t apply, then you apply general priority rules - PMSI in inventory or livestock - priority over conflicting security interest in same inventory or their proceeds that are chattel paper, instruments, or cash if it is perfected at time debtor gets possession and secured party with interest has authenticated notification of PMSI before debtor gets possession
priority of conflicting security interests in investment property
security interest perfected by control takes priority over security interest perfected by other methods
in other cases, first to file or perfect controls
deposit account priority
best: bank account in creditor name
second: bank has control b/c of maintaining account
third: control agreement
secured party v. buyer priority
- buyer takes subj to security interest unless:
1. secured creditor authorized sale free of security interest, express or implied (only implied in ordinary consumer sales where agreement is silent)
2. buyer in ordinary course takes free of security interest created by his/her seller only take free of security interest created by SELLER
- buyer takes subj to security interest unless:
- the seller must be in business of selling the goods you are buying
- buyer in ordinary course is in good faith, without knowledge that sale violates another rights, and seller in business of selling goods purchased
3. buyers or lessees not in the ordinary course, take subject to perfected security interests and take free from unperfected security interests unless they knew of security interest when gave value
- buyer in ordinary course is in good faith, without knowledge that sale violates another rights, and seller in business of selling goods purchased
consumer to consumer priority sales
"garage sale rule" buyer takes free of security interest if: no knowledge of interest gives value goods are for personal use and no financing statement
secured party v. judicial lien creditor priority
- judgment lienholder wins if lienholder arose before security interest was perfected
- PMSI special rule: secured party files within 20 days after debtor takes possession, the secured party will have priority over judicial creditor
secured creditor v statutory/possessory lien holder
statutory/possessory lien takes priority over all secured interest if the goods or services were provided in ordinary course of business and collateral remains in lienholder possession
repossession
upon default creditor may reposses via
- writ of court/judicial process/replevin
- self-help – can be done by creditor without breach of the peace (conduct that can lead to violence, generally physical presence by debtor and objection)
strict foreclosure
if the creditor wants to keep the collateral and not sale it, then they have to notify all other creditors with liens on the property and debtor and if neither objects, you can keep it. if either party objects, you must sale the property
selling collateral upon default
sale discharges all other junior liens, but senior liens stay on the property
requires reasonable notice to all creditors and debtors within reasonable time (10 days or more before sale)
every aspect of the sale must be commercially reasonable – there are penalties such as losing right to deficiency, statute penalties if it is not commercially reasonable
proceeds goes to: paying cost of sale, cost of debt, and then junior liens – superior lienholders get nothing b/c they still have their lien
right to redeem
debtor can get their property back if they pay entire amount owed before foreclosure sale
perfection of fixture
must file a fixture filing, which is a financing statement with description of real property and filed in county where fixture is located
priority of fixtures
security interest in fixtures has priority over any real estate interest that is recorded after the perfection of fixture
a prior real estate interest that is properly recorded has priority over security interest that subsequently arises – PSMI exception: PSMI takes priority over an earlier in time realty interest if perfected by fixture filing before goods become fixtures or within 20 days after
accessions
goods physically united with other goods in such a manner that the original goods are still distinguishable (like tires on car)
if an accession becomes part of a whole that is subject to a perfected security interest in compliance with requirements of certificate of title statute, the perfected security interest takes priority over the other interest (even when PMSI) in the accession
perfecting interest on accession
perfected when collateral becomes accesssion and remains perfected in collateral