Second Issue: Formation of a K Flashcards
def of K (2 part)
1) an agreement
2) that is legally enforceable
- first look to agreement, then to see if enforceable
when looking at an agreement watch what type of info n question about
1) the initial communication (offer) and
2) what happens after the initial communication (termination of offer)
3) and who responds and how she responds (acceptance
generally what is an offer?
a MANIFESTATION of commitment
- maniffestation of willingness to K.
what to look for to determine if an offer was made
look for WORDS and CONDUCT showing COMMITMENT by that person.
what is the basic test if there was an offer
w/e a REASONABLE PERSON in the position of the oferee would believe that his or her assent creates a K.
if you see the words “believed or intended” is there an offer?
NO. dont care subjectively, look objectively if reasonable person would think offer
what is the effect of a MISSING price term in SALES K for sale of RE (CL)
PRICE and LAND description REQUIRED in order for a communication to be an offer to sell land
what 2 things need to be in offer to sell land (cl)
1) price and
2) land description
does a sale of RE require price to be included (CL)
YES
for a sale of goods (UCC) does a communication to offer to buy or sell goods need a price term
NO
what is the rule for price term for sale of goods (UCC)
a communication can be an offer to buy or sell goods W/O a price term IF PARTIES SO INTENDED
is a vague or ambiguous MATERIAL term an offer under CL
NO. vague or ambigous MATERIAL terms are not an offer
are vague and ambigious MATERIAL terms an offer under UCC
NO. vague or ambiguous MATERIAL terms not an offer under either UCC or CL
words to look for vague and ambigious terms for material
1) appropriate
2) fair
3) reasonable
- these words cannot create an offer
is a requirements or output contract vague or ambiguous
NO and are valid
what is a requirement K`
BUYERS requirement to buy from seller
what is an output K
SELLER sells to buyer
is a contact for the SALE OF GOODS ok if it states the quantity of goods to be delviered under the K in terms of the buyers requirement or sellers output
YES
words to look for when dealing with requirement/ output K
1) all
2) only
3) exclusively
4) solely
what is the rule for INCREASE requirement K
buyer can increase requirements SO LONG as increase is in the line with prior demands.
- NO UNREASONABLY DISPROPORTIONATE limitation on increase
general rule are advertisement or price quotation offers
NO. Gr advertisement or price quotation is NOT an offer
3 x/c that advertisements or price quotations are NOT offers
1) an ad can be UNILATERAL offer if it is in the nature of REWARD
2) an ad can be an offer if it SPECIFICS QUALITY and EXPRESSLY indicates who can accept (Ex: first come first serve
3) price quote can b an offer if it is sent to an inquiry
4 methods of TERMINATING an offer
1) LAPSE of time: time stated or reasonable time
2) DEATH of a party PRIOR to acceptance
3) WORDS or CONDUCT of offeror: revocation of offer
4) WORDS or CONDUCT of offeree: rejection
what if an offer does not have a time period, how long will it last
for a reasonable time
GR does death or incapacity of either party AFTER offer BUT BEFORE ACCEPTANCE terminate an offer
YES
what is the X/C that death or incapacity of either party after an offer but before acceptance terminates a K
irrevocable offers
how is an offer revoked by statements by offeror
later UNAMBIGUOUS statement by offeror to OFFEREE of unwillingness or inability to K
how is an offer revoked by conduct by offeror
later UNAMBIGUOUS conduct by offeror indicating an unwillingness or inability to K that offeree is AWARE OF
does offeree need to be aware of (have notice) that oferor revoked offer?
YES. oferee needs notice
who is the only part that can REVOKE an offer
offeror
is making multiple offers to different offerees a revocation?
NO, merely making multiple offers does not make a revocation
difference b/w revocable offers and irrevocable
revocable= possibility irrevocable= no possibility revoked= actuality
what is the GR about irrevocable offers
GR is that offers can be freely revoked by the offeror
what are the 4 x/c that offer cannot be revoked (is irrevocable)
1) option k:
2) UCC “Firm Offer Rule:
3) Reliance
4) unilateral K
what is an option K
an offer cannot be revoked if the offeror has not only made the offer but also
1) PROMISED to not revoke (or promise to keep open)
AND
2) this promise is supported by payment or OTHER CONSIDERATION
what are the 2 elements needed for an option K
1) PROMISED to not revoke (or promise to keep open)
AND
2) this promise is supported by payment or OTHER CONSIDERATION
does an option K need consideration
YES
when does Firm Offer Rule apply
UCC
what is the UCC Firm Offer Rule
an offer cannot be revoked for up to 3 months if
1) offer to buy or sell goods
2) signed, WRITTEN PROMISE to keep the offer open and
3) party is a merchant
how long can a UCC FIRM OFFER be open
up to 3 months
what are the elements for UCC Firm offer
1) offer to buy or sell goods
2) signed, WRITTEN PROMISE to keep the offer open and
3) party is a merchant
who is a merchant
GENERALLY a person in business
does the UCC Firm offer rule require consideration or payment
NO
does the UCC firm offer rule NEED to state the time period for which it will stay open
NO. Courts will supply a reasonable time frame up to 3 months
does the UCC firm offer rule apply to real estate
NO only fucking goods yo
when can an offer not be revoked due to reliance
1) where reliance that is
2) REASONABLY FORESEEABLE (must be reasonable reliance)
and
3) detrimental
when can an offer for a unilateral K not be revoked
the 1) start of PERFORMANCE pursuant to an offer to enter into a
2) unilateral K makes that offer irrevocable for a reasonable time to complete performance
is mere preparation enough to make a unilateral offer irrevocable
NO. need more than mere preparation
what is the general rule when unilateral K is irrevocable
when START OF PERFORMANCE
what is the default rule to go to determine either start of performance or preparation unilateral K
assume mere preparation
who is the only one who can REJECT an offer
oferee
what are the 3 ways a rejection happens by offeree
1) counter offer
2) conditional acceptance
3) additional terms
does the additional terms of rejection apply to UCC
NO only CL for services
what does a counter offer do
terminates offer AND creates a new offer
- Offeree becomes the offeror
does bargaining terminate an offer
NO. mere bargaining does not terminate an offer
do counter offers terminate option K
NO
can a person later accept a rejected offer
NO its dead
what is the x/c that counter offers do not terminate
option K
1) if promise to keep open
and 2) consideration
when will you know that someone is a bargain and not a counter offerq
if it is QUESTION than just bargain, does not reject offer
conditional acceptance as a rejection
terminates offer
words to look for in conditional acceptance
1) if
2) only if
3) provided
4) so long as
5) but
6) on the condition that
under CL what is a conditional acceptance
REJECTION and counter offer that can be accepted by conduct
under UCC what is a conditional acceptance
rejection BUT not a counteroffer that can be accepted by conduct
under UCC can a conditional acceptance be accepted by conduct as a counter offer
NO
what does the mirror image rule apply to
only CL
what is the mirror image rule
a response to an offer that ADDS new terms is treated like a counter offer rather than acceptance
- acceptance must mirror the offer
under mirror image rule what if the new terms or changed are immaterial
if change is clearly minor dont do mirror image rule
what is it under UCC where additional or different terms not rejection
seasonable expression of acceptance
where there is
1) offer to buy or sell goods and
2) response with ADDITIONAL TERMS raises 2 questions
what are the 2 questions for seasonable acceptance for UCC
1) is there a K
- under UCC a response to an offer that ADD new terms or conditions, but does not make terms a condition, are treated as acceptance
2) is there ADDITIONAL term of a part of K
when will the additional term of K for UCC not become part of K
additional term is not part of K unless
1) BOTH parties are merchants
2) even if both are merchants the additional term is not part of K is the additional term is MATERIAL or if the additional term is objected by the original offeror
what are the 2 elements for when additional term not part of K
1) unless both parties are merchants
2) if additional term is material
what is the general rule that start of performance is acceptance
start of performance constitutes acceptance
- starting to perform is treated as an implied promise to perform
what if the offeree has started performance but the offeror has no reason to notice of the performance
generally do not have to get notice BUT if offeror has no reason to know of notice must give them notice or not acceptance
what is the x/c that start of performance is not acceptance
start of performance is NOT acceptance of UNILATERAL K
what does a unilateral K need for performance for starting
COMPLETION OF PERFORMANCE IS REQUIRED
if an offeree starts performance of a unilateral k but does not finish is that a breach
NO b/c for unilateral K needs to be a completion for acceptance, just starting is not acceptance so no offer and no breach if not finish.
what are the rules for deals at 1) distance 2) delay and 3) different
the offeror and oferee are at different places and there are delays in communication
1) communications OTHER THAN ACCEPTANCE are effective only WHEN RECEIVED
2) acceptance is GENERALLY EFFECTIVE when MAILED
3) if a rejection is mailed before acceptance is mailed, then neither is effective until recieved
4) you CANNOT use the mailbox rule for option K deadline
can you use the mail box rule for option K deadline
NO
what is the general rule for communication OTHER THAN acceptance
communication OTHER THAN ACCEPTANCE are effective only when RECEIVED
what is the mail box rule
acceptance is generally effective when MAILED
what if a person sends a rejection and acceptance both in mail?
neither are effective until received. Which ever received first rules
what if a seller of goods sends the WRONG GOODS what does that mean
general rule: acceptance AND breach
what is the x/c where seller of goods sends WRONG goods
ACCOMMODATION (explanation): counteroffer and no breach
- accommodation must be sent BEFORE the buyer received goods
generally an offer can be accepted only by (2)
1) a person a KNOWS about the offer at the time she accepts
2) to whom the person it was made to, offers cannot be assigned
does a person have to KNOW about the offer at the time to accept it
YES
can offers be assigned
generally NO
x/c that offers cannot be assigned
OPTIONS can be assigned UNLESS the option otherwise provides
can a person accept a reward if they did not know of the offer
NO
what is the effect of acceptance
when an offer has been accepted, it is no longer possible for offeror to revoke or for offeree to reject.
- the caterpillar has become a butterfly LOL
when are contracts not legally enforceable (11)
1) LACK OF CONSIDERATION or consideration substitute
2) LACK OF CAPACITY
3) SOF
4) existing laws that prohibit the performance of agreement
5) public policy
6) MISREPRESENTATIONS
7) nondisclosure
8) DURESS
9) UNCONSCIONABLY
10) ambiguity in words of agreement and
11) mistakes at the time of the agreement as to the MATERIAL facts affecting the agreement