Search and Seizure LD 16 Flashcards
Search
occurs when an expectation of privacy that society is prepared to consider reasonable is infringed upon by the government
Seizure of Property
occurs when there is some meaningful interference with an individual’s possessory interest in that property by the government
Seizure of a Person
occurs when:
- a peace officer physically applies force
- a person voluntarily submits to a peace officer’s authority
4th Amend. to U.S. Const.
the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects
against unreasonable searches and seizures
and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause
supported by oath or affirmation
particularly
Who does the 4th Amend. to U.S. Const. Limit?
Only the power of the Gov.’t, not private citizens, which could be sued in civil court for violations of privacy.
Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
can exist almost anytime and anyplace as long as:
- individuals have indicated that they personally (subjectively) expect privacy in the object or area
- their expectation is one which society is prepared to recognize as legitimate
Subjective Expectation of Privacy
a person’s state of mind demonstrated by affirmative action designed to protect their privacy (e.g., building a fence, closing window shades, locking a compartment, etc.).
Objective Reasonableness
refers to whether society is prepared to recognize the individual’s expectation as reasonable
Curtilage
the relatively small and usually well-defined area immediately around a residence to which the occupant has a reasonable expectation of privacy.
Open Fields
- outdoor real property, outside the curtilage of the residence.
- areas which are so open to public view that the owner or possessor is deemed to have implicitly invited the general public to view the area.
- Because of the lack of a reasonable expectation of privacy in open fields, the protections of the Fourth Amendment do not apply.
- do not have to be either open or real fields to qualify.
Overflight
- the flight of a plane or helicopter over a given area.
- Because of the lack of a reasonable expectation of privacy in an area that can be viewed from an overflight, the protections of the Fourth Amendment do not apply, as long as the aircraft is:
- at an altitude permitted by FAA regulations
- being operated in a “physically nonintrusive manner”
Standing
- exists only if a subject has a reasonable expectation of privacy in the place or thing that is searched or seized.
- To challenge a particular search or seizure, a person must have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the place or thing that was searched or seized. - Only a person with standing can challenge the search or seizure of property, based on Fourth Amendment protections.
Standing generally is established by:
ownership
lawful possession
authority
control of the area searched or the property seized
Probable Cause to Search
- having enough facts or information to provide a fair probability, or a substantial chance, that the item sought is located in the place to be searched.
- requires something less than an absolute or even a near certainty, but something more than a mere hunch or suspicion.
- must be able to articulate how and why they have a fair probability to believe:
a crime has occurred or is about to occur
evidence pertaining to the crime exists
the evidence is at the location they wish to search
The Exclusionary Rule
- The Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
- inadmissible and excluded evidence at trial
- from all items seized during a search and seizure
- which is ruled unreasonable and a violation of a person’s Fourth Amendment rights by the government
Search Warrant
an order in writing, in the name of the people
signed by a magistrate
directed to a peace officer
commanding the officer to search for an individual or individuals, a thing or things, or personal property
in the case of a thing or things or personal property, to bring the same before the magistrate
Benefits of Obtaining a Search Warrant
- the courts have found searches and seizures to be reasonable and therefore lawful when authorized by a valid warrant.
- The burden is on the defendant to prove the illegality of any search executed with a search warrant.
PC 1524(a)(1)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing was stolen or embezzled
PC 1524(a)(2)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing was was used as the means of committing a felony
PC 1524(a)(3)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing is in the possession of any person with the intent to use it as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom the item may have been delivered for the purpose of concealing it or preventing its being discovered.
PC 1524(a)(4)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing constitutes evidence that tends to show a felony has been committed, or tends to show that a particular person has committed a felony.
- to seize evidence such as rent receipts to show possession or control of the premises or computers
PC 1524(a)(5)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing consists of evidence that tends to show that sexual exploitation of a child (Penal Code 311.1), or the possession of matter depicting sexual conduct of a person under the age of 18 years (Penal Code 311.11), has occurred or is occurring.
PC 1524(a)(6)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing when there is a warrant to arrest a person.
PC 1524(a)(13)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing is a sample of blood that constitutes evidence that tends to show a violation of Section 23140, 23152, or 23153 of the Vehicle Code
- and the person from whom the sample is being sought has refused an officer’s request to submit to, or has failed to complete, a blood test as required by Section 23612 of the Vehicle Code, and the sample will be drawn from the person in a reasonable, medically approved manner.
PC 1524(a)(15)
grounds for search warrant when property or thing are controlled substances or a device, contrivance, instrument, or paraphernalia used for unlawfully using or administering a controlled substance pursuant to the authority described in Section 11472 of the Health and Safety Code.
PC 311.2
presents additional authority to obtain a search warrant to seize child pornography.
Content of Search Warrant
The names of all those who have sworn that the facts presented as probable cause are true
The statutory grounds for issuing the warrant
Descriptions of the places and/or persons to be searched
Descriptions of the things or property to be seized
The magistrate’s signature
The date issued
An indication by magistrate if nighttime service is authorized
- PC 1529 & 1533
Reasonable Inference
the act of drawing a conclusion from a fact; it is similar to making a presumption (e.g., seeing smoke and inferring there is a fire).
Direct Evidence
evidence that proves a fact directly, without an inference or presumption (e.g., the sale of a controlled substance to an undercover officer).
Circumstantial Evidence
evidence that proves a fact indirectly, that is, personal knowledge or observations from which deductions must be drawn by the jury or court (e.g., partial six-pack of beer found on the car seat supports inference that someone in the car has been drinking).
Securing Area Pending Search Warrant
probable cause to search and exigencies
- belief, based on the surrounding circumstances or information at hand, that the evidence will likely be destroyed or removed before a search warrant can be obtained.
An area may be if the suspect has been arrested inside the location.
An area may be secured if companions of the suspect may destroy items sought upon learning of the arrest.
- Refusal of consent to enter, by itself, does not provide justification to secure the premises pending issuance of a search warrant.
Detaining Suspects Pending Search Warrant
If the place being secured is occupied when peace officers enter,
- need probable cause to arrest if they take the suspect away or keep the suspect there for an unreasonable period while the warrant is obtained.
- Without probable cause to arrest an individual, peace officers are only entitled to detain the suspect temporarily - while they determine the person’s involvement.
PC 1534
search warrant shall be executed and returned within 10 days from issuance
- beginning with the day after the warrant is issued and running until midnight of the 10th day, - no exceptions for weekends or holidays.
- felony for officer to willfully disclose search warrant before execution to prevent search or seizure
Failure to Execute Timely Search Warrant
If the 10-day period has expired, peace officers must either:
obtain a new warrant
resubmit the expired warrant so it may be reissued and revalidated
PC 1537
The return of the warrant means returning the warrant and a written inventory of the property taken to the magistrate
- The rule for return of the warrant is slightly different than for execution. If the 10th day falls on a weekend or holiday, then peace officers are entitled to postpone returning the warrant until the next business day.
- A late return will not normally invalidate the warrant or result in suppression, particularly if it happens unintentionally, unless the defendant can show prejudice.
Search Warrant Time of Service
Normally, a search warrant may be served only between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m.
Search Warrant Nighttime Service
If peace officers can show good cause, the magistrate may, at the magistrate’s discretion, insert a direction in a search warrant that it may be served at any time of day or night.
The main point of the good cause requirement is to ensure that the request for nighttime service is specifically brought to the attention of the magistrate so that the magistrate will have to make a conscious decision whether such a particularly abrasive intrusion is appropriate. Examples of good cause include situations where:
nighttime service will decrease danger to the peace officers
a drug sale occurred at the search location at night
prompt execution might preclude murders
the property sought will likely be gone, sold, or removed by dawn
the stolen items are primarily perishable or easily disposable goods
As long as the search begins before 10:00 p.m., no nighttime authorization is necessary, even though the search may continue on well beyond that hour.
PC 1531
Knock and Notice
- before entering a dwelling to serve a search warrant, officers must give notice to persons inside through certain actions.
knock or otherwise announce their presence
identify themselves as peace officers
state their purpose
demand entry
wait a reasonable amount of time
if necessary, forcibly enter the premises
- no legal need for knock and notice at inner doors, but may be tactically wise
Wait/Refusal Requirement Search Warrant
specific requirement that before forcing entry, peace officers must be refused admittance.
Refusal may be based on:
a verbal statement
individual conduct
the passage of a reasonable amount of time
- amount of time that is considered reasonable will depend on all the circumstances.
- Approx. one minute would be a safe period in most cases, but it can be less, especially if peace officers know that someone is inside and awake.
Knock and Notice Exceptions
allows peace officers to enter private property unannounced if they can demonstrate that compliance with the knock and notice requirements would be futile, or that compliance could result in:
harm to the officers or other individuals (e.g., hostages
the destruction of evidence
- judge cannot bar a knock and notice exception beforehand
- after knock and notice exception judge will review legality of exception
Ruse Entry
officers may use a false identity, a ruse or trick to obtain consent to enter as long as they already have a judicially-authorized right to enter, i.e.,
a search warrant.
PC 1535
- If the occupant is present, peace officers should show the occupant the original warrant and give the occupant a copy.
- If no one is home, a copy of the warrant may be left in a conspicuous place. Likewise, officers must leave behind a detailed list of the property taken, whether anyone is home or not. (Penal Code Section 1535)
- In CA there is no requirement to present a copy of the warrant to the occupant. Therefore, failure to do so will not result in the suppression of any evidence seized.
Scope and Specificity of Search Warrant
Search warrants must include specific:
statutory grounds for issuance
identification of the area(s) or person(s) that may be searched
identification of the item(s) to be seized
Search Warrant Detentions/Searches
- may detain and frisk/pat search persons who are present and have demonstrated a connection with the premises.
is already inside the premises
has a key to enter the premises freely
enters the premises without knocking - mere arrival, by itself, at premises where a search is being conducted does not provide enough connection to justify a detention, let alone a cursory/frisk/pat search.
- If searching a commercial establishment, peace officers may not detain everyone who is present, only those persons who appear connected to the suspected criminal activity.
Search Warrant Containers
When a warrant authorizes the search of a residence, vehicle, or person, it automatically authorizes the search of any thing, place, or container inside that residence or vehicle, or on that person, where the object of the search might be located.
- If, however, the warrant was not for a general area, but instead was for a particular container, that container would also have to be described as completely as possible in the warrant.
Nexus Rule
officers may seize items not listed in the warrant when:
the items are discovered while the officers are conducting a lawful search for the listed evidence, and
they have probable cause to believe the item is contraband, evidence of criminal behavior, or would otherwise aid in the apprehension or conviction of the criminal
- Nexus means a reasonable connection or link between two or more items.
Plain View Seizures
Peace officers must have:
probable cause of contraband or evidence of a crime
a lawful right to be in the location
lawful access to the item
- Officers may use all of their senses, not just sight, to obtain probable cause. The plain view doctrine, therefore, can also include items they can smell, hear, or touch from a lawful position.
Public Access Area
Any area the general public or some members of the public have been given either express or implied permission to be in is considered a public access area. Peace officers have the legal right to make observations from any public access area at any time.
Surveillance
It is not a search for peace officers to conduct surveillance of private premises or to follow people who leave the premises, as long as the observations are made from a place where the officer has a right to be. Videotaping a suspect’s activities is a form of surveillance.
Sensory Aids
Flashlights
Night vision
binoculars
dogs
Abandoned Property
If an item has been abandoned by the owner, they relinquished any expectation of privacy over the item.
- 4th Amend. does not protect articles or an area that has been abandoned by its owner.
- Trash placed in a position for pick-up outside the curtilage of the residence is considered abandoned.
Lawful Access
Lawful access to private property is most commonly obtained when:
the officer’s entry is based on consent
the officer’s entry is based on exigent circumstances, for example, a reasonable belief that the evidence will be destroyed if entry is delayed in order to obtain a warrant
the officer has lawfully entered the area for some other purpose (e.g., to conduct a parole or probation search, or an administrative or regulatory search, etc.)
Warrantless Searches and Seizures
In addition to plain view seizures, these exceptions to the usual warrant requirement include:
cursory/frisk/pat down
consent searches
searches pursuant to exigent circumstances
searches incident to custodial arrest
probation/parole searches
- courts will evaluate this on totality of circumstances