Scope of Income Flashcards
Test for income
- ascession to wealth
- realization event
- complete dominion (control)
- test from Glenshaw Glass
Taxable income equation
Gross income
Less: Business deductions
= Adjusted Gross income
Less: standard or itemized deductions
Less: Personal exemptions (currently out of the code)
= Taxable income
Tax Rates (for class)
Ordinary income: 30%
Capital gain: 20%
Collectible: 28%
Statute of Limitations
3 years statute of limitations from the date filed, April 15th if filed early
6 years if issue w/ gross income
No filing or fraudulent filing = no limit
Are illegal gains taxed?
Yes. shown by SCOTUS decision and reg 1.61-14
Old Colony Trust Co - paying another’s taxes is discharge of indebtedness
D served as president of the American Woolen Company. Company had a policy to pay the income taxes of the company’s officers.
Rule: An employer paying an employee’s income taxes constitutes income (S 61(a)(11): Income from the discharge of indebtedness)
Genshaw Glass - Punitive damages are taxable
Punitive damages are taxable as gross income
“Here, we have undeniable (1) accessions to wealth, (2) clearly realized, over which the taxpayers have (3) complete dominion.”
Charley v. Commissioner - frequent flyer miles
Here, the issue is NOT a tax on frequent flyer miles, the IRS has explicitly stated the administrative costs of tracking flyer miles outweighs the benefits of taxation
Rule: An employee’s conversion of frequent flyer miles into cash in a travel account created by an employer constitutes gross income.
Rule works under two theories:
(1) additional compensation, or
(2) converting miles to cash was disposition of property
Helvering v. Independent Life Insurance Co.
Imputed wealth is not income (Filing your own tax return or Cutting your own hair)
A tax based on the rental value of someone’s property is unconstitutional, however
Congress is allowed to make taxpayers include an untaxable item, in this case the rental value of the portion of the building occupied by the insurance company, as gross income in calculations as a condition of utilizing a deduction relating to that property
Rev Rul 79-24 (barter income)
The FMV of the property or services must be included in gross income
The stipulated price is presumed to the be the FMV subject to contrary evidence
Dean v. Commissioner (rent free occupancy is income)
An employee’s rent free occupancy of an employer’s property is income equal to the fair rental value
Test for Gifts (gifts are excluded from income)
A “Detached and disinterested generosity” (look to the transferor’s intent)
Prof Note: “Generally, the larger the amount given, the higher the burden to prove it is a gift”
See Duberstein and Stanton
Is a tip considered a gift?
No. Although associated with generosity, under 1.61-2(a) - tips are explicitly taxable as income (therefore, not gifts)
1.102-1(2) Exception to the rule on employee transfers
If the transfer can be related to a familial relationship it is excluded from income
132(h) “Employee” includes
- Spouses and dependents
- Surviving spouses
Duberstein - A Cadillac given in exchange for business leads is compensation
A transfer is NOT a gift if the giver was motivated by
(1) a moral or legal duty;
(2) receiving an economic benefit; or
(3) receiving services, even ones with no economic benefit
The evidence supports a finding that Berman was not acting with disinterested generosity and that he transferred the Cadillac to Duberstein in exchange for customer leads Duberstein already produced or might later produce
Stanton - Whether or not a transfer is a gift is a “fact specific” inquiry into the transferor’s intent.
Stanton resigned after working for a church for over 10 years.
The church gave Stanton $20,000, calling it a “gratuity” in appreciation for Stanton’s prior services. Although the church did not owe Stanton any retirement benefits, the church also said that the payment released it from any retirement-benefit obligations.
Stanton argued gift and IRS disagreed, court remanded for more fact finding (but now, 102(c) does not allow employee gifts)
Disputes over whether a transfer is an employee gift come up in three common scenarios
- to an employee during an ongoing employment relationship;
- to an employee upon or after retirement; and
- to survivors upon the death of an employee
102(c)(1) prevents exclusions of “benefits” to employees
Summary: No employee gifts
An employee “shall not exclude from gross income any amount transferred by or for an employer to, or for the benefit of, an employee.”
two things that likely qualify for the exception to the “no employee gifts” rule 102(c)
Section 132(e ): certain traditional retirement gifts are treated as de minimis fringe benefits; and
Section 74(c ): certain employee achievement awards are freed from tax.
If there is a settlement over a contested will, are the proceeds of the settlement taxable?
Lyeth v. Hoey - property received from a settlement resolving a will is not taxable income
(if the judgment or settlement grants the distribution to the heir because of his or her heir status)
inheritances excluded from income
Are bequests taxable?
Wolder - where a bequest is made in return for services rendered, that bequest constitutes taxable gain.
exception to 102(c) “the no exclusion of employee gifts rule”
“extraordinary transfers to the natural objects of an employer’s bounty if the employee can show that the transfer was not made in recognition of employment.”
heavy burden to establish that there was not a compensatory purpose to the transfer
Does 102(c), no exclusion for employee gifts, apply to bequests?
Most likely, yes.
There may be an argument that 102(c) does not apply to bequests.
Still, there is an issue of whether the circumstances indicate that the bequest was made as compensation for services rendered.
While fringe benefits to employees are included in gross income, there are 6 common exceptions
132(a)(1) No additional cost services
132(a)(2) Qualified employee discounts
132(a)(3) Working condition fringes
132(a)(4) De minimis fringes
132(a)(5) Qualified transportation fringes
132(j)(4) Athletic Facilities
Test for 132(a)(1) No additional cost services
Excludable if
(1) Same line of business, and
(2) does not displace non-employee customers
Subject to:
- nondiscrimination rule
- Reciprocal agreements must be in the same industry
Test for 132(a)(2) Qualified employee discounts
Excludable if
(1) same line of business (employer AND employee),
(2) the discount is for
(a) personal property not held for investment, or
(b) services (including insurance, but not loans for employees of banks)
and
(3) the discount does not exceed
(a) gross profit percentage for property, or
(b) 20% for services
amounts in excess of the limits are includable
Test for 132(a)(3) Working condition fringes
“The cost of doing business” CLE’s or a company car for business purposes
Rule: if the employee paid for it and could deduct the expense (162 or 167), it is excludable from income
132(j)(3) Special exclusion for Auto salesmen use of demonstration cars
(1) be used primarily for facilitating company duties, and
(2) have substantial restrictions on personal use
Test for 132(a)(4) De minimis fringes
Examples
- coffee machine in the break room
- “traditional” retirement gifts given “upon retirement” after a “lengthy service”
Also includes:
“Bargains” at employer operated eating facilities IF
(1) located on or near the premises, and
(2) the revenue generated normally equals or exceeds their operating costs.
nondiscrimination rule for meals
Test for 132(a)(5) Qualified transportation fringes
(A) Transportation in a commuter highway vehicle between the residence and place of employment.
(B) Any transit pass.
(C) Qualified parking.
(D) Any qualified bicycle commuting reimbursement.
Exclusion does NOT apply if employee receives cash up front, but will apply for reimbursement. Having the option is okay.
Transit pass reimbursement only excludable if passes are not readily distributable
Test for 132(j)(4) Athletic Facilities
Applies to a gym, pool, golf course, tennis courts or other athletic facility
(1) located on the employer’s premises,
(2) operated by the employer, and
(3) where substantially all use is by employees, spouses, and dependent children
What is the nondiscrimination rule?
Certain benefits must be available to all employees to be excludable
To what exclusions does the nondiscrimination rule apply?
(1) No-additional cost services,
(2) Qualified employee discounts, and
(3) Meals provided at an employer-operated eating facility
What are the limitations on 132(a)(5) Qualified transportation fringes?
- Aggregate value of commuter highway travel and a transit pass $175 per month
- Qualified parking $175 per month
- Bike reimbursement limited to $20 per month that cycling was the primary travel to work and employee did not receive the other benefits
Test for excluding value of meals and lodging (S 119)
Provided
(1) on the business premises (adjacent property okay, but not across the street)
(2) for the convenience of the employer
Lodging adds:
(3) as a condition of employment
meal exclusion not available if employee has option of receiving compensation in lieu of meals
When does an employee accept loding as a “condition of employment”?
Hatt (funeral home case): An employee accepts the housing as a condition of employment if his continuous presence is necessary in order to adequately perform his duties.
What are the two exceptions to the “typical” rules on lodging
S 119(d) employee of an educational institution may exclude lodging if located on or in the proximity of campus
S 107 Housing benefits for “minister of the gospel,”
- MUST be furnished as compensation
- must be specifically earmarked
- exclude value of home or rental benefits provided to the extent that are used for principal residence
Business trip or an awarded vacation?
The expenses for a trip paid for by an employer is not included as gross income if the trip is
(1) NOT provided in light of the employee’s past work performance and
(2) is taken primarily for business purposes.
The presence of a business purpose or the obligatory nature of a trip are significant, but not conclusive, indications of a business trip
The general rule for S 117 scholarships and fellowships
Scholarships for tuition (and related expenses) are NOT taxable, however, amounts for lodging and services are taxable
S 117(a) excludes “qualified” scholarships
Qualified means: used on qualified tuition and related expenses
- tuition and enrollment fees,
- other fees,
- books,
- supplies, and
- equipment required for courses of instruction
No exclusion for personal living expenses, travel, or research
S 117(c) limits the 117(a) scholarship exclusion
Must include any portion of scholarship that represents payment (even if for services required of all students)
The exception is athletic scholarships with a “gratuitous flavor.”