REVISED Capital Market Expectations Flashcards
What is the basic framework/steps for determining asset class expectations?
- Specify the set of expectations needed including time horizon - generate a list of asset classes
- Research the historical record - understand the factors that matter
- Specify the methods and models to use
- Determine the best sources of information
- interpretation of current investment environment
- Provide the set of expectations
- Monitor actual vs expectations
What are the characteristics of a quality forecast?
consistent, unbiased, objective, well supported
What are the limitations of the quality of our forecasts?
- Limitations on data - there may be time lag
- Data measurement errors and biases. This includes transcription errors, survivorship bias, appraisal indices
- Limitations of historical estimates
Things change - technology, regime changes, regulatory changes
Data will not all have the same number of observations - Ex post risk is a biased measure of ex ante risk - fears that never came to fruition will not show in economic data but could have reflected in volatility in the past
- Biases in methods - data mining and time period biases (time specific results)
- Failure to account for conditioning information
- Misinterpretation of correlation - absence of correlation does not mean no relationship
- Psychological traps
- Model uncertainty
What are psychological traps when forecasting returns?
- Anchoring
- Status quo
- Confirming evidence - confirmation bias
- Overconfidence
- Prudence trap - don’t want extreme forecasts
- Availability bias
What is the difference between cycles and trends?
Trends show long term activity while cycles happen in the short to mid term. Trend is driven by slowly changing factors or exogenous shocks.
What are examples of types of exogenous shocks?
- Policy changes -
- New products and technology
- Geo-politics
- Natural disasters
- Natural resources and critical inputs
- Financial crises, although this is also endogenous in theory
How do we form long term expectations of the average growth rate?
- Growth from labour inputs
2. Growth from labour productivity
what causes growth from labour inputs?
- Potential potential labour size
2. Growth in participation
What causes growth from labour productivity?
- Growth from capital inputs
2. Growth from total factor productivity
How do we estimate the total value of market equity?
MV = GDP * Share of GDP in profit * PE (stable in long run)
What are the three main approaches to economic forecasting?
- Econometric - system of equations
- Economic indicators - lagging, coincident, leading indicators, although revision in indicators will cause hindsight issues
- Checklist approach
What are the pros and cons of econometric forecasting models?
Pros:
1. Robust and examine the effect of many variables
2. Quick output using new data
3. Delivers estimates of impact due to changes
4. Imposes consistency
5. Simulate the effect of exogenous variables
Cons:
1. Complex and time consuming
2. Misspecified models and nonstationarity
3. False sense of precision
4. Doesn’t forecast turning points
5. Requires forecasts for exogenous variables which increases error
What are the pros and cons of economic indisctors for forecasting models?
Pros: 1. Intuitative and easy to construct 2. Limited number of variables 3. Focuses on identifying turning points 4. Easy to track Cons: 1. Overfitting in sample data 2. False signals 3. Binary direction but no magnitude 4. Look ahead bias due to indicator revisions over time
What are the pros and cons of checklists for forecasting models?
Pros: 1. Flexible 2. Can incorporate structural changes easily 3. Breadth Cons: 1. Subjective, arbitrary, judgemental 2. Time consuming 3. No level of consistency
What are the phases of the typical business cycle?
- Initial recovery
- Early Upswing
- Late Upswing
- Slowdown
- REcession
Describe the initial recovery phase of the business cycle?
- Picks up from recession
- Business confidence rises
- Fiscal and monetary stimulus still exists
- Typically investories are growing
- Yields start to bottom
- Stocks rally, specifically HY bonds and cyclical stocks
Describe the early upswing phase of the business cycle?
- Confidence grows
- no inflation yet
- Unemployment falls
- Business investment grows
- Short rates move up, long rates stable
- Stocks go up
Describe the late upswing phase of the business cycle?
- Output gap closed
- Wages growing
- Wages grow
- increased equity vol
- Hawkish monetary policy
- unemployment is low
- Short rates rising
- Inflation hedges perform, cyclicals do not
Describe the slowdown phase of the business cycle?
- Slowing economy
- Confidence dropping
- Inflation is strong
- Less inventory
- Short rates top out
- Long rates go lower (invert)
- Stocks become soft
Describe the recession phase of the business cycle?
- Rates drop
- Large inventory pullback
- Durable good sales drop
- Stocks drop, but bottom out before the end
How is inflation related to the business cycle?
It is procyclical, where the term structure is upward sloping during recoveries and downward sloping during peaks
How does inflation effect bonds?
Rising inflation means a higher discount rate = lower prices
Inflation expectations also increase the discount rate.
How does inflation effect stocks?
If inflation is at expectation, there is little effect. Higher than expected inflation may slow down the economy, but lower rates could result in a decline in asset.
What effects should monetary and fiscal policy have on capital market expectations?
Monetary policy will effect cycles, but fiscal policy will effect trend growth
What is the Taylor rule?
Nominal Rate target = Neutral Target Rate + Inflation expectations + 0.5(Expected GDP - Trend GDP) + 0.5(Expected Inflation - Target inflation)
What would you expect from rates when fiscal and monetary policy are both loose?
You’d expect higher real rates and higher expected inflation, resulting in higher nominal rates
What would you expect from rates when fiscal policy is loose and monetary policy is tight?
You’d expect high real rates and low expected inflation, resulting in mid nominal rates
What would you expect from rates when fiscal policy is tight and monetary policy is tight?
You’d expect low real rates and low expected inflation, resulting in low nominal rates
What would you expect from rates when fiscal policy is tight and monetary policy is loose?
You’d expect low real rates and high expected inflation, resulting in mid nominal rates
How does the shape of the yield curve change over the business cycle?
- Initial recovery - steep curve
- Early expansion - front steepening but back half is flattening as mid rates increase
- late expansion - flattening from long inwards
- Slowdown - flat to inverted
- Recession - steepening