Retirement Savings/Income Planning Flashcards
Qualified Plans: Defined Benefit - Types of Defined Benefit Plans
Traditional Defined Benefit Plan
Cash Balance Pension Plan
Traditional Defined Benefit Plan
Guarantees the final monthly pension amount
A “fully insured” traditional defined benefit plan is funded EXCLUSIVELY by cash value life insurance or annuity contracts (IRC Section 412(c)(3))
Characteristics of ALL Defined Benefit Plans
- pension plans
- guarantee final benefit
- maximum annual pension benefit $245,000 (2022)
- maximum compensation considered in benefit formula $305,000 (2022)
- Only qualified plans insured by PBGC
- must vest at least as generously as 5-year-cliff or 3-7-year graded vesting (Cash Balance plan may use only 3-year cliff vesting)
- must have joint and survivor payout unless waived
- 100% employer funded; mandatory annual employer contributions
- Funding limit is whatever it takes to provide guaranteed benefits; no predetermined annual limits
- No participant-directed accounts; sponsor bears investment risk
- No predetermined maximum deductible employer contribution
- Annual actuarial work required to determine needed funding each year
- DB Plans are the most administratively expensive
- can favor older participants in plan
- must also satisfy 50/40 rule
50/40 rule
The basic rule set out in the Internal Revenue Code is that each qualified plan must “on each day of the plan year” benefit the lesser of: (i) 50 employees of the employer, or (ii) 40% or more of all employees of the employer. This is a new annual requirement that must become a part of the yearly administration.
In a Defined Benefit Plan, generally, at least 40% of qualifying employees (but not more than 50) need to receive a meaningful benefit every year. If there are only one or two qualifying employees, typically all of them must receive a meaningful benefit each year.
When is a DB plan suitable?
- benefit guarantees are desired
- PBGC insurance coverage is needed
- stated goal is to skew older participants
DB Pension formula calculation example
Stan is a long-time executive with XYZ Corporation, and he is retiring this year. XYZ Corporation sponsors a traditional defined benefit pension plan and Stan has participated in the plan for 35 years. The pension formula is 2% of Stan’s final salary per year of service. Stan’s salary is $500,000 per year. What is Stan’s annual pension under the plan?
35 x 0.02 x $305,000
Additional characteristics of a Traditional DB Plan
- guarantees monthly pension
- older, high-earning participants can have substantial funding on their behalf
- common pension formula is a percentage of pay times the number of years of service
- no individual accounts
- accruing a benefit of any amount is active participation for IRA deduction purposes
- if participant is married the pension must be joint and survivor unless spouse waives (notarized!)
A traditional DB Plan provides the highest level of guarantees for the participant but is the most expensive plan to administer; may be correct answer if the sponsor has numerous older management/owner participants, and the company has good financial standing and stable cash flows.
Section 403(b) Plan (TSA) - features
used by 501(c)(3) tax exempt organizations (hospitals) and public schools
Tax benefits:
pre-tax contributions
tax deferred growth and income
Salary reductions: up to $20,500
Age 50 Catch up: $6,500
Special Catch up:
minimum of 15 years of service with the sponsoring school or 501(c)(3) employer
Additional deferral allowance of $3,000/yr
May be used in the same year as 50+ catch up
Age 50+ with 15 years of service may defer up to $30,000: ($20,500 + $6,500 + $3,000)
RMD @ 72
10% penalty on distributions prior to 59 1/2
Can be rolled into IRA or Qualified Plans if withdrawal is allowed
AGGREGATED with other plan deferrals in applying annual maximums
Investment Choices limited to Mutual funds and Annuities
Governmental Section 457(b) Plan - features
used by government and certain non-profit organizations
Tax advantages:
pre-tax contributions
tax deferred growth and income
Salary reductions:
$20,500
50+ catch up: $6,500
Special catch up:
for last 3 years of service (at plan normal retirement age)
unused deferrals from the past
Up to twice the normal contribution limit ($41,000)
50+ catch up may NOT be used in same tax year as special catchup allowance is used
NO 10% penalty for withdrawal prior to 59 1/2
RMD @ 72
Can be rolled into IRA or Qualified Plans if withdrawal is allowed
Section 457 deferrals are NOT AGGREGATED with other salary deferrals in applying annual maximums
NOT considered ACTIVE PARTICIPANT for IRA deduction purposes
Capital Preservation Approach vs Purchasing Power Preservation Approach
Additional capital needed on day 1 of retirement to leave same amount at death as capital utilization approach requires
Begin with capital utilization annuity due PV (assume $1,000,000)
Nominal ROR = 7%
Inflation Adjusted ROR = 5.8%
20 years until retirement
$1,000,000 = FV 20N 7 I/YR 0 PMT PV ? $258,419, add to $1,000,000
Purchasing Power Preservation Approach uses inflation adjusted ROR rather than nominal ROR
Purchasing Power Preservation Approach
Qualified Plans: Defined Contribution Plan
sponsor defines contribution formula rather than a guaranteed final benefit
mandatory employer contributions, substantial & recurring (no annual mandate)
favor younger participants with more years to accumulate
6 types: 4 profit-sharing, 2 pensions
all profit-sharing are DC plans
pension plan may be DB or DC
annual additions limit includes:
employer contributions
employee elective deferrals
reallocated forfeitures
Profit-sharing plans
Traditional profit-sharing
401k
Stock bonus
ESOP
DC Pension Plans
Money Purchase Pension Plan
Target Benefit Pension Plan
Defined Contribution Plans - Features
Participant-directed accounts
Annual additions limit for combined EE/ER: $61,000
Maximum elective deferral: $20,500
Maximum compensation considered in benefit formula: $305,000
Participant bears investment risk
No guaranteed final benefit
Vesting must be at least as generous as 3-year cliff or 2-to-6-year graded
Maximum deductible ER contribution: 25% of covered payroll
Forfeitures may be reallocated or used by ER to offset plan expenses
Participant easy to understand
No PBGC insurance
Traditional Profit-Sharing Plan
All DC plan features +
Flexible year-to-year contribution, must be substantial & recurring (3 out of 5 years) but not every year
100% ER funded
Yearly profit not mandatory for contributions, can be made from cash flow or retained earnings
in-service loans and hardship withdrawals permitted
Can be 100% invested in ER stock
not subject to QJSA
age-weighted, can skew higher contributions to older participants
401k Plan
All DC plan features +
CODA provision added to underlying profit-sharing plan, stock bonus, or ESOP
EE can make annual elective deferrals up to $20,500 (catch up 50+ 6,500)
annual ER contributions not required but usual ER match, profit sharing contributions also possible
participant loans and hardship withdrawals permitted
ER contribution can be 100% ER stock
minimum of 3 diversification options for elective deferrals are required
participation in multiple 401ks: annual deferral limit is aggregated
EE contributions subject to ADP testing, ER contributions subject to ACP testing
Money Purchase Pension Plan
All DC plan features +
Mandatory annual ER contributions, 100% ER funded
ER contribution is typically a percentage of EE’s compensation
May invest in no more than 10% ER stock
No in-service withdrawals until 62
Subject to QJSA
Maximum retirement plan contribution for SE Owner
- Subtract 1/2 SE tax from net earnings from SE
- Multiply adjusted employer plan contribution rate
a. adjusted rate: ER contrib rate % / 1+ER contrib rate %
b. max rate of 25% becomes 20% for owner
c. rate adjustment does not apply to EEs (if plan contrib
rate is 25%, EE receives 25% contribution)
If plan contribution rate is 25%, can use shortcut of 18.49% of net earnings from SE.
Example with SE with $100,000 net earnings:
$100,000 - 7.65% = $92,350
0.25 / (1+0.25) = 0.20
$92,350 x 0.20 = $18,470 = max contribution
Shortcut: $100,000 x 18.49% = $18,490
SEP
easy to set up and maintain
ER with 1 or more EEs
No annual filing, can be established and funded up to ER’s tax return, incl. extensions
up to 20% of covered comp, not to exceed $61,000
ER discretion re: annual contributions
21 years old, 3 out of 5 years, comp of $650 or more
withdrawals permitted anytime subject to federal income tax and early withdrawal penalty, no loans
100% immediate vesting
Simple IRA
EE salary reduction, and ER contributions (mandatory!)
Little administrative paperwork
ER with up to 100 EEs, no other retirement plan
No annual filing requirement
Max deferral: $14,000, catch up 50+ $3,000
ER 3% match (can be reduced to 1% in 2 out of 5 years) or 2% of each eligible EE’s comp
EEs who have at least $5,000 of comp in any 2 prior years and reasonably expected to earn $5,000 in current year
Withdrawals permitted subject to federal taxes and early withdrawal penalty of 10%; if withdrawals within first 2 years penalty tax of 25%
No loans allowed
All contributions are 100% immediately vested
IRA Contribution Deduction Rules
Active Participation Status;
- Defined Contribution Plan: anyone who received annual additions (ER contributions, EE deferrals, forfeitures reallocated to remaining participants)
- Defined Benefit Plan: anyone who is eligible for the plan is accruing a benefit and is considered an active participant
- Participants in a SEP, Simple, Section 403(b) Plan (TSA) are active participants for IRA purposes
Participants in a 457 plan are NOT considered active participants for IRA purposes.
IRA and Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plan Rollovers
Traditional Rollover:
- one traditional rollover allowed per year
- plan administrator transfers vested account balance or portion to participant
- within 60 days participant deposits funds into IRA or different employer plan
- traditional rollover from qualified plan requires mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding by employer (not for IRA to IRA!)
- if withheld amount is not replaced and deposited with the rollover the withholding amount is considered distributed and subject to income tax and possible 10% penalty
Direct transfer rollover:
- no annual limit on number of direct transfers per year
- plan trustee transfers rollover directly to IRA or another employer plan
- participant does not take possession of the funds
- no mandatory tax withholding
Inherited IRA Distribution Requirements
Inherited traditional IRA, qualified plan, or tax-advantaged employer plan account
- Spouse beneficiary:
- has choice of being treated as IRA owner or beneficiary of an inherited IRA
- if spouse beneficiary chooses to be treated as owner, they may defer RMD until 72
- may combine (roll) inherited IRA with own IRA
- Non-spouse beneficiary / See-Through Trusts / Successor Beneficiaries:
- 10-year rule
- Eligible designated beneficiary: (distributions can be taken over life of beneficiary except for minor children, after maturity, 10-year rule applies)
- Spouse
- chronically ill beneficiary
- disabled beneficiary
- minor children (<18)
- beneficiaries no more than 10 years younger than IRA owner
- Non-Designated Beneficiary (Estate, Charities, Trust not qualifying as Designated Beneficiary):
- 5-year rule
Roth IRA:
NO RMD during life of owner
- Spouse beneficiary can become owner and forego RMDs for life
- Non-spouse beneficiary subject to RMDs
Exceptions to Early Withdrawal Penalties: Traditional IRAs, IRA ER-Funded Plans, QPs
10% penalty on withdrawals before 59 1/2 unless exception applies (SIMPLE IRA first 2 years 25% penalty)
Exception When QPs Trad. IRA/ER-Funded IRA
Medical unreimbursed expenses >7.5% of AGI Y Y
Education qualified higher education N Y
Age after 59 1/2 Y Y
Death participant/IRA owner’s death Y Y
Disability total & permanent participant/IRA owner Y Y
Health Ins. premiums while unemployed N Y
Equal Payments series of substantially equal payments Y Y
Home Buyers first-time homebuyer, up to $10k lifetime N Y
Sep. from Service at/after EE reaches 55 Y N
Penalty exception for separation from service applies to which types of retirement plan?
Qualified Plans only
Which early withdrawal penalty exceptions are ONLY allowed by an IRA?
qualified higher education expenses
health insurance premiums
first-time homebuyers
Roth IRA Distributions
Qualified distributions from a Roth IRA are TAX FREE
Qualified distribution requirements:
1. must be made after the 5-year period beginning with the first taxable year for which the individual made a Roth IRA contribution
AND
2. must occur in relation to one of the following:
- account owner’s death
- account owner being disabled
- first-time home purchase (lifetime $10k max)
- 59 1/2
Non-qualified Roth IRA distributions:
- account earnings: subject to regular income tax and 10% penalty
- Roth Conversion Contribution: no regular income tax, distribution within 5 years of conversion may be subject to 10% penalty
- Regular Roth Contribution: no regular income tax, no penalty