Retirement: 8 Deferred Compensation and Stock Plans Flashcards
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Employee taxation controls timing of your tax deduction
Lack of security for employees in an unfunded plan
Generally, more costly to employer than paying compensation currently
a. Advantages of NQDC plans
b. Disadvantages of NQDC plans
b. Disadvantages of NQDC plans
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
The American Jobs Creation Act (AJCA) was signed into law in 2004, and it created Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 409A, which was designed to create strict rules to govern deferred compensation. Unless an exception applies, the term “nonqualified deferred compensation plan” means any plan that provides for the deferral of compensation for any employee. A deferral of compensation generally occurs when a legally binding right to compensation arises in one taxable year and the compensation _____ be payable to employee in a subsequent taxable year.
a. May
b. Must
a. May
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
There are severe penalties for failure to meet the new Section 409A requirements including all amounts deferred under the arrangement becoming subject to immediate taxation, interest penalties, and a ____ additional tax on deferrals.
a. 10%
b. 20%
b. 20%
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Much of what is covered under Section 409A is beyond the scope of this module, but here are some of the basics:
Elections to defer compensation must occur in the year prior to the tax year of the delivery of services. When employees first become eligible to participate in a nonqualified plan during the current year (because they were recently hired or a new plan was put into place), they have __ days after they first become eligible to participate to make a deferral election under the plan for the current year.
a. 30
b. 60
a. 30
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Much of what is covered under Section 409A is beyond the scope of this module, but here are some of the basics:
Where compensation is performance-based (that is, under an incentive plan), the deferral election must be made no later than _ months prior to the end of the 12-month performance period.
a. 3
b. 6
b. 6
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Example. Jim Hopkins, age 64 and 8 months, has participated in the nonqualified deferred compensation plan of his employer for the last 23 years. Under the plan, he originally elected to have benefits paid in a lump sum at age 66, the age at which he would begin his Social Security and planned to retire. He now has decided to work until age 71, but isn’t exactly sure how long he will work. He wants to make a subsequent deferral so the original payment will be payable on the later of attaining age 71 or separation from service.
Jim’s new election will be valid if he makes the election on or before his 65th birthday since it will be at least 12 months prior to the original payment date, and any payments to Jim under the new election must be deferred at least ___ years from the previous payment commencement date specified by the plan.
a. 3
b. 5
b. 5
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Example. Lisa Littlehorn, age 63, participates in the Industrial Design Inc. nonqualified deferred compensation plan, and she has done so for over 15 years. Originally she elected to have her plan benefits paid in a lump sum at age 65. She is in excellent health and is concerned about outliving her retirement funds. She has decided to work until age 70, and wants her benefit to be paid over 25 years. She would like to make a subsequent deferral so the series of payments over 25 years will begin on the later of the date she attains age 70 or the date she decides to retire.
Lisa’s new election will be valid if she makes the election on or before her __th birthday since it will be at least 12 months prior to the original payment date and defers the new payment date at least five years. If Lisa terminated at age 67, her payments would begin at age 67, since she terminated.
a. 64
b. 65
a. 64
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
An employee (or beneficiary) may change a previously elected time or form of a payment, subject to certain limitations. A change in either the time or form of payment may not take effect for __ months and must provide for a new payment beginning date that is at least five years after the original beginning date. In addition, if the payment is made as an annuity or as installment payments, the election must be made 12 months before the date the first amount was scheduled to be paid.
a. 12
b. 24
a. 12
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Qualified vs. Nonqualified Plans
_____ allow for significant tax deferral, but must meet the stringent requirements of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), as well as those of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). The plan must be nondiscriminatory if it is to qualify for the tax benefits associated with qualified employee benefit plans. These include the ability of the employer to take an immediate deduction for a plan contribution regardless of whether it is included in the employee’s current income, and the deferral of taxation on plan earnings until they are distributed to the participant.
a. Qualified
b. Non Qualified
a. Qualified
Additionally, special tax rules relating to forward averaging and the ability to move assets to another tax-deferred arrangement such as an IRA apply only to qualified plan assets.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Qualified vs. Nonqualified Plans
A ____ is a contractual agreement between an employer and employee that specifies when and how future compensation will be paid. The plan represents an unfunded and unsecured promise to pay benefits in the future. In the meantime, plan assets remain within the reach of corporate creditors and the employer may not take an income tax deduction on monies set aside to informally fund the plan.
a. Qualified
b. Non Qualified
b. Non Qualified
Nonqualified plans are ideal for individuals such as business owners and key employees, who want to provide compensatory benefits for themselves without having to provide similar benefits to rank-and-file employees. These key employees are also looking to avoid the contribution and participation limits that apply to qualified plans. The price for this freedom of plan design is that the employer cannot take a deduction for payments to a nonqualified deferred compensation plan until the employee reports the payments in income, which is often at retirement. Also, the earnings on plan assets are not tax-deferred; instead, earnings are taxed annually to the sponsor or to the participant.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Easier and less expensive to implement and maintain than a qualified benefit plan
Can be offered on a discriminatory basis
Can provide unlimited benefits
Allows employer to control timing and receipt of benefits
Enables employer to attract and retain key employees
a. Advantages of NQDC plans
b. Disadvantages of NQDC plans
a. Advantages of NQDC plans
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Discrimination: Plan may not discriminate
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Discrimination: Plan may discriminate
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Compensation limit: Compensation limit applies
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Compensation limit: Compensation limit does not apply
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Benefit limitations: Applies to both defined contribution and defined benefit plans
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Vesting: Vesting schedules are required
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Vesting: Vesting schedules are not required
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Penalties and excise taxes: Penalties and excise taxes apply
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
Penalties and excise taxes: Penalties and excise taxes do not apply unless the plan violates AJCA (Section 409A)
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
ERISA requirements: Must satisfy ERISA requirements
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: IRC Requirements
ERISA requirements: Exempt from most ERISA requirements
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Employer’s deduction: Available in year of plan contribution
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Employer’s deduction: Available in year of plan contribution
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Employer’s deduction: Available in year employee is taxed on benefits
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Employee deferral: Tax deferred until plan distribution
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Fund earnings: Accrue tax deferred until distribution
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Fund earnings: Are currently taxable to the employer in most cases
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Distributions: Ordinary income tax rates apply; capital gains rates for net unrealized appreciation on employer securities
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Distributions: Ordinary income tax rates apply and benefits are taxed as wages
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Distributions: Ordinary income tax rates apply and benefits are taxed as wages
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Tax-free rollovers: Assets are fully portable and may be rolled over into an IRA or another qualified plan
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Tax-free rollovers: Assets are not portable and rollovers are not permitted
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Creditor protection: Benefits are protected from the claims of both the employee’s and the employer’s bankruptcy and nonbankruptcy third-party creditors
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
a. Qualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Comparison of Nonqualified and Qualified Plans: Tax Treatment
Creditor protection: Generally, benefits are fully subject to the claims of the employer’s third-party creditors; benefits are subject to the claims of an employee’s third party creditors after they become payable or are nonforfeitable
a. Qualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
b. Nonqualified Plan
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Generally the way that tax deferral occurs with nonqualified deferred compensation is not because of special tax laws, but because the individual has yet to receive anything on which to be taxed. There are two main ways this can occur. This first is that there has not been any money set aside exclusively for the individual, and it is just a promise to pay the employee, which may or may not happen. Typically this is because there are strings attached to the promise, such as having to complete three more years of service or any payment is forfeited. These so-called “strings” are referred to as a “_____” provision.
a. high risk of forfeiture
b. substantial risk of forfeiture
b. substantial risk of forfeiture
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
The other way that deferral of taxation can occur is that the money is “_____” and creditors may get to it before the employee does. Once the employee is vested, meaning the money is definitely theirs and cannot be taken away, then that is when they will be taxed.
a. risky
b. at risk
b. at risk
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
A nonqualified deferred compensation plan is considered _____ if the employer has irrevocably and unconditionally set aside assets in a trust for the payment of plan benefits. Such assets are beyond the reach of the employer and their creditors. In exchange for this security, however, these plans offer limited tax deferral opportunity and may be subject to all of ERISA’s requirements including rules governing administrations, reporting, disclosure, participation, vesting, funding and fiduciary activities.
a. funded
b. unfunded
c. informally
a. funded
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
In an ______ plan, the more popular plan, no funds are set aside by the employer. Employers favor this approach because cash is not tied up in plan investments, but remains available for ongoing business needs. In addition, these plans provide the benefit of tax deferral and avoid nearly all ERISA requirements (except minimal reporting and disclosure requirements). On the other hand however, this “pay-as-you-go” approach gives the employee little assurance that their promised payments will actually be received.
a. funded
b. unfunded
c. informally
b. unfunded
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
With an ______ funded plan the employer sets aside assets which to be used to pay its promises under the plan. The plan will be considered unfunded if these assets remain available to the employer’s general creditors.
a. funded
b. unfunded
c. informally
c. informally
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
As we have seen, individuals cannot defer more than $18,000 of annual compensation to a qualified 401(k) in 2016. Highly compensated individuals may wish to defer amount in excess of $18,000. A salary reduction plan, or pure deferred compensation plan, is a way to achieve this. These plans are funded with _____ money.
a. employee
b. employer
a. employee
The employee agrees to give up a specified portion of current compensation (salary, raise, or bonus); in turn, the employer can promise to pay a benefit in the future that is equal to the deferred amounts plus a predetermined rate of interest. The employer could also give the employee investment choices (oftentimes these can be the same as those offered in the company’s 401(k) plan) and credit the employee with whatever returns these investments may have. A salary reduction arrangement is sometimes called an “in lieu of” plan because the employee is receiving the employer’s promise to pay benefits in lieu of current income.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Because of its nature (i.e., it continues where the qualified plan leaves off), a popular form of nonqualified plan is the excess benefit plan. This plan is linked indirectly by benefit to the qualified plan or plans in place. It provides for benefits in excess of the amount to which the employee would otherwise be entitled through the plan formula as modified by the above contribution or benefit limits in the qualified plan or plans.
a. excess benefit
b. additional benefit
a. excess benefit
That is, the contribution or benefit provided to a participant by an excess benefit plan is the contribution or benefit that would apply if the Section 415 limits did not exist minus the Section 415 limited contribution or benefit provided by the qualified plan. The payment is typically made upon an employee’s retirement and is usually paid in the same manner that benefits are paid under a qualified retirement plan. The plan may be either funded (i.e., specific property is set aside to secure the obligation accruing to the employee) or unfunded (i.e., a mere promise is made).
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
If an excess benefit plan is _____, it is essentially exempt from all ERISA Title 1 requirements regarding funding, vesting, participation, and reporting requirements. Accordingly, for simplicity’s sake, these plans are often structured as unfunded and unsecured promises to pay an excess benefit at an employee’s normal retirement age.
a. funded
b. unfunded
b. unfunded
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
A _____ excess benefit plan is subject to ERISA’s reporting and disclosure requirements, specifications regarding fiduciary responsibilities, and administrative and enforcement procedures. Like an unfunded plan, however, it need not comply with the participation, vesting, and funding requirements of ERISA.
a. funded
b. unfunded
a. funded
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
In a supplemental executive retirement plan (SERP) the ______ makes a commitment to fund a specific deferred benefit.
a. employee
b. employer
b. employer
The employee does not forgo current compensation. This plan is sometimes referred to as a salary continuation plan. Such a plan might be considered an additional fringe benefit that the employer could offer to induce an executive to join or stay with the company. SERPs are often referred to as “golden handcuffs” because if the executive risks losing a substantial amount of retirement benefits by leaving the company, he may rethink a career move. As such, SERP that is designed with a delayed vesting schedule can be a very successful retention tool.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
An executive will not realize income under a nonqualified plan, even though he is vested, if the employer’s promise to pay future compensation is unsecured and unfunded.
Vested but unfunded SERP
Funded but not vested SERP
Vested but unfunded SERP
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
An executive will not realize income, even if the plan is funded, if the executive’s right to receive the future benefit is not transferable and is subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture.
Vested but unfunded SERP
Funded but not vested SERP
Funded but not vested SERP
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
The employer _____ permitted a current tax deduction for contributions to a SERP
a. is
b. is not
b. is not
Their deduction for contributions is deferred until these amounts are included in the executive’s income. When the benefit payments are included in the executive’s income, generally during the retirement years, then the employer may deduct the payments. In addition, earnings that accrue in a funded plan will be currently taxable to the employer.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
A ______ plan is a type of SERP established to provide unfunded deferred compensation benefits to a select group of management or highly compensated employees.
a. top hat
b. cowboy hat
a. top hat
Because a top hat plan is always unfunded it is not subject to ERISA’s fiduciary, participation, vesting, and funding rules. It is nevertheless subject to the reporting and disclosure requirements and to the enforcement and administration requirements of ERISA. These requirements, however, generally are not onerous and can usually be satisfied by a single filing of a brief informational statement with the Labor Department and by providing plan documents to the Labor Department if they are requested.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Important Characteristics of Excess Benefit Plans, Top Hat Plans, and SERPs
Participation Restrictions: Plan may be established for any employee (plan typically is established for highly compensated employees)
a. Excess Benefit Plans
b. Top Hat Plans and SERPs
a. Excess Benefit Plans
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Important Characteristics of Excess Benefit Plans, Top Hat Plans, and SERPs
Source of Benefits: Benefits generally are paid by the employer out of general assets
a. Excess Benefit Plans
b. Top Hat Plans and SERPs
both a. and b.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Important Characteristics of Excess Benefit Plans, Top Hat Plans, and SERPs
Type of Funding: May be funded or unfunded
a. Excess Benefit Plans
b. Top Hat Plans and SERPs
a. Excess Benefit Plans
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
A ______ trust is technically an unfunded plan, although it is often considered to be informally funded. This trust is established by an employer to informally fund their obligation to provide employees with benefits under a nonqualified deferred compensation plan. Such an arrangement is meant to provide employees with assurance that payment of the deferred compensation will in fact be paid when due.
a. secular
b. Rabbi
b. Rabbi
The first irrevocable trust approved in this scenario was sponsored by a synagogue for its rabbi, hence the name.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
As grantor and owner of the Rabbi trust assets, the employer may use these assets only to satisfy the obligation owed the executive. Plan assets are protected against a change of control, such as a hostile takeover, but are not protected if the employer becomes bankrupt or declares insolvency. In that case, the trust assets must be available to satisfy the general obligations of the employer’s creditors. Thus, the contributions and earnings on investments used to fund the trust are considered to have “_____” and are not currently taxable income to the executive.
a. high risk of forfeiture
b. substantial risk of forfeiture
b. substantial risk of forfeiture
Additionally, as per the definition of a grantor trust, the trust earnings are currently taxable to the grantor (or employer), rather than taxable to the grantee (employee).
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
A _____ trust is also an irrevocable trust established for the purpose of providing nonqualified plan benefits to an employee.
a. secular
b. Rabbi
a. secular
Secular trusts may be employer-funded or employee-funded. An employee-funded secular trust is a type of grantor trust that is established by an employee. (Income earned by a grantor trust is taxed to the grantor, the employee in this situation.)
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Unlike assets in a rabbi trust, employee-funded secular trust assets ____ subject to the claims of an employer’s creditors. The secular trust is designed to be the opposite of the rabbi trust.
a. are
b. are not
b. are not
The plan will not include a substantial risk of forfeiture provision, and the employee will be in constructive receipt of contributions made to the trust. Therefore, the employer’s contribution to the trust is immediately taxable to the employee and the employer receives an immediate deduction. Such contributions are considered wages and are subject to the normal withholding requirements, including FICA and FUTA. Often the employer will increase the participant’s compensation to offset the taxes on this imputed income.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
If properly structured, an employee-funded secular trust consists of a _____ arrangement on behalf of a named employee. Typically, assets in the trust are invested in tax-deferred assets such as permanent life insurance, tax-exempt securities, or other similar investments. Therefore, the increase in value of the tax-deferred assets usually will not be taxable to the employee-beneficiary until payments are made from the trust.
a. fully funded
b. unfunded
a. fully funded
One useful purpose of an employee-funded secular trust is to protect an employee-beneficiary from his or her employer’s failure to pay the promised benefits because of employer insolvency, employer bankruptcy, a change in ownership or control of the employer, or outright refusal by the employer to honor the agreement.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Example. BordCom Inc. offers certain employees a funded nonqualified deferred compensation plan, and all ERISA-eligible employees are in the plan. The plan uses an employee-funded secular trust to hold plan assets, which consist of a variable life insurance contract for each participant. The plan does not contain substantial risk of forfeiture provisions. Therefore, the contributions to the plan (used to pay premiums) will be taxed ______ and are subject to normal withholding, including FICA and FUTA.
a. each year as they are made
b. at distribution
a. each year as they are made
For this reason, the plan should not be subject to IRC Section 409A since the deferrals are includible in gross income and are not “deferred compensation.” The increase in value of the insurance contract is subject to tax once the payments from the secular trust are made to the employee beneficiary. A ratable portion of each payment is taxed as income (again, subject to FICA and FUTA), based on the increase in value of the insurance contract over the total contributions (life insurance premiums in this case) already taxed to the employee.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
There are other ways to benefit executives other than deferred compensation that is merely a promise to pay, or is at risk.
The concept of ______ involves an arrangement between two or more persons, or between a person and a corporation or other entity, to share (1) premium payments on a life insurance policy and (2) proceeds of the life insurance policy. This insurance is meant to replace income lost due to premature death. The employer recovers its cost at the premature death of the executive or when the policy is surrendered by the executive.
a. Split Dollar Life Insurance Plans
b. Key Employee Life Insurance
c. Death-Benefit-Only Plans
a. Split Dollar Life Insurance Plans
The employer receives its share of the death benefit tax-free, as does the executive’s beneficiary. The premium is not deductible to the employer, and the executive must pay tax on the economic benefit of the policy, as determined in IRS Table 2001, less any premiums paid by the executive.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
There are other ways to benefit executives other than deferred compensation that is merely a promise to pay, or is at risk.
An employer’s purchase of a ______ represents protection for the company, not the employee. Such a policy would be prudent if the company were obligated to pay a benefit at the key employee’s death under a DBO plan or under the death benefit provisions of a deferred compensation plan. Other reasons for such a policy could center on a company’s need for liquidity for purchasing an executive’s stock or funding ongoing operations of the company.
a. Split Dollar Life Insurance Plans
b. Key Employee Life Insurance
c. Death-Benefit-Only
b. Key Employee Life Insurance
Since there are no benefits paid to the employee, there are no tax consequences to the employee from a key employee life insurance policy. Nor is the employer entitled to a deduction for premiums paid on the policy, since the employer is the beneficiary of the policy.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
There are other ways to benefit executives other than deferred compensation that is merely a promise to pay, or is at risk.
______ are just what the name implies: The only benefit they provide is a death benefit to the employee’s designated beneficiary. A death benefit-only plan (DBO plan) is a type of ERISA welfare plan often misclassified as a nonqualified deferred compensation plan. (A welfare plan is an employer sponsored plan that provides, among other things, death, disability, sickness, accident, or unemployment benefits for its participants.)
a. Split Dollar Life Insurance Plans
b. Key Employee Life Insurance
c. Death-Benefit-Only
c. Death-Benefit-Only
A DBO plan is not considered to be an ERISA employee pension benefit plan because it does not provide retirement benefits, nor does it provide for the deferral of income. Welfare plans are subject to ERISA’s reporting, disclosure, fiduciary, administration, and enforcement requirements; however, they are not subject to ERISA’s participation, vesting, and funding requirements. A death-benefit-only plan is a valuable tax planning tool for a highly compensated employee who has a large estate that may be subject to significant federal estate taxes, even after the unified credit and marital deduction are taken into account. It’s valuable because a properly designed death-benefit-only plan is excluded from federal estate tax for a highly compensated employee who owns 50% or less of a closely held corporation’s (i.e., the employer’s) stock. All payments are taxed as ordinary income to the beneficiary.
Retirement 8-1 Nonqualified Deferred Comp
Example of Death-Benefit-Only benefit
Chuck Baines owns 48% of BioFuels Inc. The company’s estimated value is $12 million. Ted Dryden owns 40% and Mark Rule, a former employee, owns the remaining 12%. Ted has decided he needs to provide liquidity to his estate for tax and other reasons. The company will provide this liquidity through a death-benefit-only plan. Ted is 42 and will be covered by a $5 million policy; with the _____ as beneficiary of this policy
a. Ted’s designated beneficiary
b. the company
b. the company
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Case law and IRS rulings hold that an employee may be taxed on cash or property that is “received” in exchange for services rendered. This requirement is known as the _____ doctrine. The constructive receipt issue isn’t whether the taxpayer has actually received the income, but whether he has access to it.
a. constructive receipt
b. economic benefit
a. constructive receipt
Technically speaking, the constructive receipt doctrine taxes “income not actually reduced to a taxpayer’s possession yet otherwise made available to him so that he could have drawn upon it at his discretion.” To avoid constructive receipt, agreements usually contain specific provisions establishing substantial risk of forfeiture (funded plans) or availability of funds to the company’s general creditors (unfunded plans).
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
The _____ doctrine states that if any economic or financial benefit is provided to an individual as compensation immediate taxation will result. In other words, when the employee’s benefit has become substantially vested or essentially equivalent to the receipt of cash, current income taxation will result.
a. constructive receipt
b. economic benefit
b. economic benefit
In other words, when the employee’s benefit has become substantially vested or essentially equivalent to the receipt of cash, current income taxation will result. Economic benefit goes beyond the income-related issue of constructive receipt because it concerns anything that an employer might give to an employee as a substitute for cash.
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Because of the alternative minimum tax (AMT) provisions, a corporation may incur a tentative minimum tax liability on the buildup of cash value in corporate owned life insurance or on the proceeds received from a life insurance policy upon the death of an insured. For example, in certain situations it is possible for 75% of the life insurance proceeds received by a corporation to be subject to a tax based on the ___ AMT rate.
a. 15%
b. 20%
c. 25%
b. 20%
This results in an effective tax rate of 15% (the 20% AMT rate × 75%.)
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
The value of any death benefits payable to an employee’s beneficiary _____ includible in that employee’s gross estate for federal estate tax purposes.
a. are
b. are not
a. are
Accordingly, in some estates it will be important for the deferred compensation payments to qualify for the unlimited maximum marital deduction. The payments that qualify for this deduction are payments directly to the surviving spouse or payments directly to a marital deduction trust over which the spouse has a general power of appointment. Ultimately, the deferred compensation may have to be included in the gross estate of the surviving spouse, i.e., “the second to die.” It is the estate of the second to die that may have to pay all of the federal estate taxes attributable to the deferred compensation, unless the right to receive payments is non-transferable and expires after the death of the second to die. For example, single life annuity payments to a surviving spouse are not subject to estate tax.
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Deferred compensation is taxable as ordinary income to a deceased participant’s beneficiary. This is known as _____ in respect of a decedent
a. benefits
b. income
b. income
(IRD). The beneficiary is entitled to some relief in the form of an income tax deduction based, in part, on the amount of estate tax, if any, that results from inclusion of retirement benefits in the deceased participant’s estate. The beneficiary must itemize to be able to claim this deduction.
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Nonqualified deferred compensation defers wages, and “wages,” as defined in the Code, include all payments for services performed by an employee for his employer, including the cash value of all payments in property other than cash (including benefits). The general rule is that this “compensation” is subject to Social Security taxes as of the _____ of
- the date on which services are performed or
- when the deferred compensation is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture.
a. earlier
b. later
b. later
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Deferred compensation arrangements in _____ generally are unsuccessful deferral vehicles due to their adverse tax consequences.
a. closely held corporations
b. partnerships
b. partnerships
The IRS considers contributions to a partnership’s deferred compensation plan as income (compensation) to the partnership and, therefore, as currently taxable. Even when the benefit payments are forfeitable, contributions to such a trust are currently taxable to the partners.
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Problem Areas of Closely Held Corporations
During an audit, the IRS will carefully scrutinize a deferred compensation arrangement between a closely held corporation and its controlling shareholder.
a. Control issues
b. Unreasonable compensation
c. Accumulated earnings tax
a. Control issues
The IRS may argue that a controlling shareholder has complete power to accelerate or defer the income at will. Nevertheless, case law on this point generally supports the conclusion that such deferred compensation arrangements are valid. In particular, the courts have looked to determine whether the corporation involved is a valid legal entity. In general, a valid corporation will be recognized for tax purposes; however, a sham corporation or a corporation that has failed to comply with state corporation requirements and is essentially invalid will usually be disregarded for tax purposes.
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Problem Areas of Closely Held Corporations
If deferred compensation payments made to the majority stockholder of a closely held corporation exceed (along with previous compensation paid) “reasonable compensation” as determined by the IRS, the corporation’s deduction is denied. The IRS’s concern is that the payment may actually be a disguised dividend. This generally is only an issue with stockholder-employees in closely held, not publicly traded, corporations.
a. Control issues
b. Unreasonable compensation
c. Accumulated earnings tax
b. Unreasonable compensation
Retirement 8–2: Taxation of NQDC Plans
Problem Areas of Closely Held Corporations
The issue of whether a deferred compensation plan is, in fact, concealing dividends is central to the accumulated earnings tax issue of regular corporations. If the IRS determines that the deferred compensation plan is designed to avoid dividend distributions, then plan premiums and funding payments are subject to a penalty tax. The IRS’s decision regarding the plan will be based on whether earnings are, in fact, being accumulated in excess of “reasonable business needs.”
a. Control issues
b. Unreasonable compensation
c. Accumulated earnings tax
c. Accumulated earnings tax
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
- only vehicle that fully secures payments immediately
- only asset that builds a reserve sufficient to fund a sizable death benefit, however early death occurs
- waiver of premium available for disability protection
- settlement options available to meet payouts
- investment advantages: safety of principal, convenient units of purchase, guaranteed tax-free annual return, 100% collateral value, no investment management, asset diversification, possible large tax-free gain if the policy is held until the employee’s death
- the employer pays the premium and the proceeds in life or at death go to the employer; the employer makes a payment to the employee, then deducts the payment; the employee is taxed on the payment
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
_____ is under new regulations issued in September 2003. Except for grandfathered plans, it appears that its usefulness is very limited.
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
- the noncorporate employer is the owner and beneficiary of the annuity; the employee is the annuitant
- the employer pays out to the employee and deducts payments
- the Tax Reform Act of 1986 provides that non-individual (e.g., corporate) owners of deferred annuities are to be currently taxed on the increase in the cash surrender value; this has reduced the appeal of this funding vehicle (unless transferred into the name of the employee)
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
c. informal funding using an annuity
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
- benefits paid are measured by the value of shares in mutual fund or employer stock
- if employer stock is used, the employer credits the employee’s account yearly with a number of units, depending on the current value of the stock
- the employee does not actually receive or own any stock; the phantom stock is merely a measuring device
- on retirement, the employee’s units are revalued, and the value of the stock plus dividends can be paid over a period of years; the payments are taxed at ordinary income rates and deducted by the employer (withholding, FICA, and FUTA apply)
- frequently used in closely held corporations
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
also known as a shadow stock plan
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
- involves payout under a phantom stock plan; payments made in measuring shares of stock instead of cash
- the employee is taxed at distribution on the fair market value of the shares; the employer deducts the same amount
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
Retirement 8–3: Informally Funded Plans
- provides an immediate death benefit plus a retirement benefit that is responsive to market fluctuations through use of insurance and equities, such as mutual funds
- insured benefits are lower than if the plan were fully insured at the same cost
- the cash value of insurance can provide a guaranteed minimum retirement benefit
a. informal funding using employer-owned life insurance
b. informal funding using a split dollar insurance policy
c. informal funding using an annuity
d. informal funding using a phantom stock plan
e. informal funding using a deferred stock plan
f. informal funding using split or combination funding
f. informal funding using split or combination funding