Retirement Flashcards
Wage Replacement Ratio
(top-down approach)
- Subtract payroll tax (7.65%)
- Subtract savings amount
Wage replacement ratio
(bottom up approach)
- Budget for actual needs.
Capital Preservation Model
- Preserve capital at the beginning of retirement to have the same amount at death.
- N = Number of years of retirement
- i = interest rate
- FV = amount needed at death (from previously calculated amount needed at retirement)
- PMT = 0
- PV = ? Amount needed at retirement to create FV at death.
- Add FV (amount needed at retirement for life needs) + PV (amount needed at retirement to leave that amount)
Purchasing power preservation model
- Amount needed at death = inflation-adjusted amount necessary at retirement.
- Capital preservation model adjusted for inflation.
- N = number of years of retirement
- i = inflation adjusted rate ((1 + interest rate)/(1 + inflation rate) - 1) * 100
- PV = ? amount needed at death/retirement
- PMT = amount needed at first year of retirement.
- FV = amount needed at retirement without capital preservation.
- OR use: inflation-adjusted rate with the capital preservation model instead of regular interest rate.
Sensitivity Analysis
- Changes the variables toward increased risk.
Qualified Plan Compensation Limit
- $265,000
Work life expectancy
- Period during which one earns, saves and accumulates for retirement.
Retirement life expectancy
- How long someone will be retired until death.
Annuity Method of Capital Needs Analysis
- Determine WRR
- Determine gross dollar needs in today’s dollars.
- Reduce by expected SS
- Inflate dollar needs by inflation rate (or CPI) - BEGIN MODE
- N = remaining work life
- i = inflation rate
- PV = retirement needs in today’s dollars
- PMT = 0
- FV = ?
- Determine present value at retirement:
- N= years of retirement
- i = inflation adjusted rate )(1 + interest/1 + inflation) - 1)) * 100
- PV = ? Amount needed at retirement
- PMT = FV from last step (inflated need)
- FV = 0
Monte Carlo Analysis
- Randomized generator of variable outcomes.
Calculate retirement needs
- BEGIN MODE
- Use cash flow to determine NPV of necessary amount adjusted for inflation
- Inflate that amount by interest rate to determine future value of that amount at retirement.
- N = number of years to retirement
- i = interest rate (not inflation-adjusted
- PV = NPV from last step
- PMT = 0
- FV = ?
Types of Pension Plans
- Defined contribution plans: money purchase pension plans, target balance pension plans.
- Defined benefits plans: defined benefit pension plan, cash balance pension plan.
Profit sharing plan
- All defined contribution plans
- Stock bonus plans
- ESOPs
- 401Ks
- Thrift Plans - after-tax
- Age-based profit sharing plans
- New comparability plans
Defined benefit pension plans
- Defined benefit pension plan and cash balance pension plans
- annual contribution limit is not less than the current liability to pay out benefit (actuary determines) - amount contributed depends on investment performance, etc.
- Employer assumes investment risk
- Subject to Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. (insurance with caps)
- forfeitures cover plan costs
- no separate accounts
- credit can be given for prior service from prior to plan set up.
Defined contribution pension plans
- Money purchase pension plans
- Target benefit pension plans
- Contribution amount is defined in plan document.
Pension plan
- pays pension at retirement - legal promise
- no in-service withdrawals (can take lump sum if leave company and can take partial if 62 or over)
- mandatory funding
- 10% can be invested in employer securities (if defined contribution plan, participants can diversify investments)
- Qualified Joint Survivor Annuity & Qualified Pre-retirment Survivor Annuity - surviving spouse gets paid
Profit sharing plan characteristics
- Deferral of compensation
- in-service withdrawals allowed after 2 years
- no mandatory funding for employer- funding only has to be substantial and recurring.
- use a predetermined formula for funding, but it is not a fixed amount
- can fund from 0 - 25%
- must be nondiscriminatory or meet a mathematical formula that allows discrimination
- can invest up to 100% in employer securities
- can be contributory or noncontributory (by employee)
- no Q joint survivor Annuity or QPSA
Defined Contribution Plan
- includes all profit-sharing plans and
- includes money purchase plan and target benefit pension plans
- employer’s annual contribution limit is up to 25% of covered compensation
- employee assumes investment risk - controlled by employee
- forfeitures (unvested money) are allocated to employees or offset plan costs
- not subject to Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. benefit
- Separate investment accounts
- no credit for prior service.
Qualified plan advantages
- income tax deferred
- payroll taxes avoided for employer contributions
- ERISA creditor protection (protected from bankruptcy)
- Special tax treatment for lump sum distributions
Qualification requirements for qualified plans
- must have plan document
- must have eligibility requirements
- must have coverage requirements
- vesting requirements
- special qualification requirements when plans get top-heavy (key employees)
- there are limitations on benefits and contributions
Plan document
- terms of the plans
- must be consistent with IRC qualification requirements
- must be in writing and signed for plan year
Qualfied plan eligibility
- employees who are 21 and over and have 1 year of service (1,000 hours in one plan year) must be eligible
- special election to require 2 years of service, but 100% vesting is required immediately (not available to 401K’s)
- tax-exempt educational institutions can require 26 years old
- plan must have at least 2 entrance dates per year. (can’t make ppl wait more than 6 months)
Qualified plan coverage can exclude
- can exclude
- ineligible employees
- unionized employees
- nonresident alien employees who do not perform services in the US
Qualified plan coverage discrimination tests
- plans must be nondiscriminatory
- must meet 1 test:
- Safe harbor test:
- must cover at least 70% of non highly compensated employees
- Ratio % test:
- % of NHC covered/% of HC covered is at least 70%
- Average benefits test:
- avg. benefits of NHC covered/ avg. benefits of HC covered is at least 70%
- Safe harbor test:
Defined benefit plan add’l coverage requirement
- In addition to 70% test, DB plan must pass:
- 50/40 test: people first, % second
- plan must cover the lesser of:
- 50 non-excludable employees
- 40% of non-excludable employees
- plan must cover the lesser of:
Highly compensated employee
- owner-employees: who own at least 5% of company this year or last year and attributed shares to his/her family (even if not actively involved)
- owner or non-owner employees with salaries over $120K last year and,
- if elected, in top 20% of employees ranked by salary. “20% election” (instead of 120K - owners always included)
- ineligible or noncovered employees not included in this
Vesting Defined Contribution Plan
- 2-6 year graduation (starts in year 2)
- 3 year cliff (100% vested after 3 years of service)
Vesting Defined Benefit Plan
- 3-7 year graduated (begins in year 3)
- 5 year cliff (0% vested until 5 years, then 100% vested)
Top heavy definition
- Defined Benefit plan - present value of accrued benefits of key employees exceeds 60% of accrued benefits for others.
- Defined contribution plan - aggregate account balances of key employees exceeds 60% of aggregate accounts of all
Key employee
- greater than 5% owners
- greater than 1% owner with salary of 150K or more
- officer with compensation in excess of 170K
- a key is top heavy - have the keys to executive bathroom.
Top Heavy DC Plan funding
- Must provide non-key employees with a contribution of at least 3% of comp (except if key employee contribution is less than 3%)
Top heaving DB plan funding
- must provide non-key employees with a benefit equal to 2% per year of service (limit 20%) time annual comp
- must use 2-6 graduated funding or 3-year cliff (same as all DC plan funding)
Covered Compensation Limit
- for both DB and DC plans, compensation of $265,000 or less can be considered when determining benefits.
Defined benefit annual payout limit
For DB plans, the benefit that can pay out is the lesser of:
- $210,000
- 100% of average annual salary for 3 highest consecutive years
Defined contribution plans contribution limit
Lesser of:
- 100% of employees comp
- 53K plus catch-ups (must have sufficient earned income for catch-ups)
Includes:
- employer contributions
- employee contributions
- forfeitures allocated to employee
(265K covered comp limit)
AKA Annual addition limit
Multiple plan contribution limits
The greater of:
- 25% of employee covered compensation
- the required minimum funding standard of the DB plan.
Life insurance investment in pension plan
- employer gets deduction
- “pure economic value” is taxable to participant
- must be convertible to cash or annuity/
- must be incidental investment. Pass either:
- 25% test:
- Term/Univ. LI premiums can’t exceed 25% of employer contrib.
- Whole LI premiums can’t exceed 50% of employer contrib.
- 100 to 1 ratio test
- death benefit limited to 100 times monthly accrued benefit in the plan.
- usually only used for DB pension plans
- 25% test:
412 (e)(3)
- specific type of DB plan that is funded entirely by a life insurance contract or annuity.
Actuary
- determines how much funding is necessary for defined benefit plan
- required annually:
- defined benefit pension plan
- cash balance pension plan
- required once:
- target benefit pension plan
Investment risk holder
- Defined benefit plans: employer assumes risk
- Defined contribution plans: employee assumes risk.
Allocation of forfeitures
- Defined benefit plan: used to decrease future funding requirement
- Defined contribution plan:
- used to pay plan costs
- allocated to existing employees (nondiscriminatory)
Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation
- Federal corp that insures benefits for lower paid employees
- Plan sponsor pays premiums into PBGC
- Max annual benefit: $60,136
Accrued benefit vs. Account balance
- Defined benefit plan: present value of the vested future payments
- Defined contribution plan: vested account balance
Credit for prior service
- Defined benefit plans: may give credit for service provided before the plan start
- Defined contribution plans: no credit for prior service.
Social Security Integration Excess Method
- Funding formula
- Excess method: provides an excess benefit (addition of benefit for amount of comp. over max SS comp)
- can be 2 times regular contribution up to 5.7% on comp over 118,500) to those participants whose earning are in excess of SS wage base (integration level)
- Can be used for both DB and DC plans
Social Security Integration Offset Method
- Plan funding formula
- Reduces the benefit to those employees whose earnings are below the SS wage base
- Used only by DB plans
Plans with no SS integration
Plans with elective deferral portions
444 STRES
- 401K
- 457
- 403b
- Sarsep
- Trad IRA
- Roth IRA
- ESOP
- SIMPLE
Plans with SS integration
- All other QP’s
- SEP’s
Defined Benefit Pension Plan
- Mandatory funding
- Pension benefit based based on defined funding formula
- flat amount
- flat percentage
- unit credit formula - Years * % * salary
- Commingled accounts
- Favors older plan entrants
- Eligibility/vesting (3-7; 5 year)/coverage - based on qualified plan
- Top heavy: 2-6; 3 year cliff; minimum funding = 2%
Cash balance pension plans
- DB plan hybrid
- Mandatory funding
- Benefit is based on annual guaranteed contribution rate and guaranteed earnings on contribution.
- Actuary
- commingled accounts
- participants can see hypothetical account balance
- Favors younger plan entrants (need longer timeline in the plan)
- Vesting: 3-7 year graded; 3-year cliff
- DB plans can convert to cash balance plans
Money purchase pension plans
- Defined Contribution pension plan
- mandatory annual funding
- fixed contribution of comp. up to 25%
- investment choice made by employee/separate accounts
- favors younger plan entrants (longer timeline to grow) - no prior service
Target benefit pension plan
- special type of money purchase plan
- determines contribution ased on the employee ages
- participant bears investment risk
- separate accounts
- favors older plan participant
- pension vesting
Profit Sharing Plans Contribution Employer Contribution Limit
- per employer: 25% of total employer covered compensation (max $225K)
- per employee limited to the lesser of 100% of comp or $53,000 for contribs. plus catch up. Employer, employee, and forfeitures.
Profit Sharing Plan Contribution Deadline
Income tax return due date with extensions.
Profit sharing plans standard allocation
Equal percentage to all participants
Profit sharing plans SS integration
- Provides higher allocations for comp over SS max level.
- PSPs can only use excess method.
Age-based profit sharing plan
- Uses a combination of age and compensation to allocate the plan contribution per employee
- Can discriminate as long as it’s based on actuarial assumptions or mathematical formulas
- Based on the present value of $1 at presumed retirement age.
New Comparability Plan
Classification by job position: e.g owner, long-time employee, rank-and-file
401K
- Cash or Deferred Arrangements (CODA)
- Have to be tied to profit sharing plan or stock bonus plan
- Employee deferrals of up to 18K or 24Kfor 55 or over
- Employee contributions are subject to payroll tax
- NOT eligible for SS integration
- covered comp: 265K
- additions limit: 53K
- Can’t be established by gov’t entities
- Age 21 and 1 year of service max. for eligibility
- No deferred eligibility (2 years)
- Employer contribs: max of 2 to 6 year or 3 year cliff
CODA nondiscrimination Testing
Actual Deferral Percentage Test/Actual Contribution Percentage Test
Negative elections: employee is deemed to be in the plan unless opts out.
Limits HCE deferrals to percentage of NHCE deferrals.
(greater than 5% owner or comp in excess of 120K)
If Avg. elective derferral of of NHCE’s is:
- 0-2%, HC’s can only defer 2 X that %.
- 2-8%, HC’s can only defer that % plus 2%
- 8% or over, HC’s can only defer 1.25 X that %.
PLUS CATCH-UP Contribution
Failing the ADP test
- Decrease ADP of HC - corrective distribution
- Recharacterize contributions from pre-tax to post-tax
- Increase ADP of NHC - non-elective contributions by NHC
- 100% vested to all elgible employees
- Matching contributions to NHC
- 100% vested to employees who elected to defer in current year
Actual Contribution Percentage test
- Percentage NHC contributions of all contributions
- takes into account: employer after-tax contribs and matching contribs
- same scale as ADP test and same corrective procedures except recharacterization may not help (since after-tax contribs accounted for)
Safe Harbor 401K
- not required to pass ADP or ACP
- employer must provide 100% vested:
- 3% nonelecitve contribution to all eligibile employees
- Matching contrib:
- 100% up to 3% and
- 50% from 3-5%
Qualified Automatic Contribution Arrangement (QACA)
- Plans that contain qual. automatic enrollment meets ADP, ACP and top heavy rules.
- Must have:
- automatic deferral: EE in unless opt-out, not excess of 10% and at least:
- year 1: 3%
- year 2: 4%
- year 3: 5%
- year 4 and after: 6%
- matching (similar to Safe Harbor schedule) or nonelective contribution
- notice to employees
- automatic deferral: EE in unless opt-out, not excess of 10% and at least:
- employees w/at least 2 yrs service must be 100% vested.
Proft Sharing Plan hardship distribution
- To pay:
- Medical expenses
- Purchase of principal residence
- Tuition and fees
- Preventing eviction
- No other sources of funds available
- Taxed at OI but usually no penalty (sometimes 10% penalty)
- Suspended from making contribs for 6 months
Catch-up contributio
6K if 50 or older
Stock Bonus Plans
- DC plan (eligibility, vesting, top heavy)
- Employers contribute stock to the plan
- Contributions are discretionary
- Can be non-contributory or contributory by employee
- Allocations must be non-discriminatory
- Pass-through voting rights to employees
- Employees have the right to demand employer securities when taking a distribution
- Employees have right to sell securities back to employer upon distribution (put option) - assumes non-public co.
- Distributions must start within one year of retirement and must be completed within 5 years.
- Private companies generally need to be valued annually to determine share value.
Stock Bonus Plan advantages/disadvantages
- Value of employer stock contributed is tax-deductible to employer
- Give employees vested interest in company performance.
- Employee has risk of non-diversified portfolio
- Put option could represent cash-flow problem for employer
- Valuation is expensive
Stock Bonus Plan/ESOP Portfolio Diversification in public companies
- Employee elective deferrals have the right for immediate diversification (treated like 401K)
- Can diversify employer contributions for participants with 3 or more years of service
- No requirement to allow diversification for employees with less than 3 years of service.
Net Unrealized Appreciation
- Must be a lump-sum distribution of employer securities to qualify for this tax treatment.
- usually from a stock bonus plan or ESOP
- Only available if coming out of qualified plan
- Basis is FMV at employer contribution date. Gain is FMV at distribution date plus gain/loss between distribution and sale date.
- Amount up to basis treated as Ordinary Income and taxed in year of distribution.
- Gain (NUA) between contribution and distribution treated as LT Cap Gain.
- Amount of gain or loss AFTER distribution normal LT or ST gain/loss - holding period begins at distribution.
- If distribution before 59.5, penalty tax on basis.
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)
- DC profit sharing plan/type of stock bonus plan
- Participants receive shares of employer stock through ESOP/trust.
- Employer received tax dedcution for amount of stock contributed to the plan or principal/interest payments for loan used to purchase company stock (leveraged ESOP)
- Often used in case of company difficult to sell.
- Employer can sell shares to ESOP and employees then own company through plan.
Leveraged ESOP
- Bank loans the money to ESOP Trust
- Trust buys stocks from primary shareholder (owner usually)
- Company contributes cash to the Trust every year to pay loan.
- Stock of company stays within ESOP and is allocated to employees.
ESOP Employer Advantages
- creates market for closely held stock
- helps retain employees
- improves employee performance
- employer-owners can diversify portfolio w/out capital gain.
- corp can borrow against stock
- corp can improve cashflow by taking deduction on stock contributions
ESOP Employer Disadvantages
- dilutes company ownership
- adminitrative costs (valuation)
- may strain cash flow with put options
- personal liability for ESOP trustees
- uncertain cash flow for future.
ESOP employee advantages/disadvantages
- improves morale
- favorable tax treatment - NUA
- Put option available
- employee bears risk of employer insolvency
- stock not liquid
- value subject to fluctuation
ESOP Non-recognition of gain for owner requirements
- ESOP must own 30% of corp’s stock immediately after sale
- seller(s) must use proceeds to purchase qualified replacement securities w/in 12 months of sale and hold such securities for 3 years
- Cannot be publicly traded stock (any class)
- Sellers/family/more than 25% owners can’t receive stock allocation inside ESOP
- ESOP can’t sell the stock for 3 years (holding period)
- must be common or convertible stock and have been held by owner for at least 3 years prior to sale.
ESOP Voting Rights
- Privately held corps: Participants can vote in major corporate decisions; small decisions handled by trustee (who also sits on Board)
- Publicly traded corps: Voting rights just like other shareholders’ voting rights.
Contrubutions to ESOPs
- can be cash or stock
- tax deduction up to 25% of total covered comp
- if leveraged ESOP, can go above 25% if the extra is an interest payment.
- For C-Corp dividends paid are deductible to employer
- For S-Corp dividends not deductible
- Dividends are included in OI of employee.
ESOP employee allocations
- can be age-based
- can’t use SS integration
ESOP Distributions
- Employee can demand distribution
- Participant can elect substantially equal periodic payments elected by participants for no longer than 5 years (more time for amounts larger than $1,070,000 for up to 10 years)
- Can elect lump sum (distribution within 1 year) for NUA treatment.
ESOP Put Option
- If employee elects for employer to buy back stock but happen within 60 days of distribution or within a 60 day period the following plan year.
ESOP Diversification Requirement
- A qualified participant - 55 years or older and 10 years plan participation can force diversification within his account.
- Qualified election period - 6 plans years after becoming qualified participants
- may 25% diversify post-1986 stock balance for first 5 years of qualified election period.
- 50% in 6th year.
- Based on number of allocated shares less any distribution, past diversification, etc.
- Diversification can be satisfied thru distribution, transfer to another qualified plan, or within ESOP.
ESOP Trustee
- Must act in best interest of participants and beneficiary
- Fiduciary duty
ESOPs and S Corps
- Pass-thru entities allowed to create ESOPs in 1996.
- ESOPs only count as 1 shareholder
- Not required to make distributions in the form of securities bc may lose S Corp status (if more than 100 shareholders or held by non-resident alien, etc.)
Qualified plan selection
- Employee status: Looks at employee age, compensation, tenure in company, HC employees, key employees.
- Cash flow considerations: cash flow problems = profit sharing plan
- Administrative costs - actuary, valuation expert, testing, etc.
- Owner’s business and personal objectives
Pension plans distributions
- No in-service withdrawals
- QPSA if participant dies before retirement, surviving spouse - annuity
- QJSA - annuity payment for lifetime of surviving spouse
- At disability, distributed to participant
- If terminate employment before retirement, lump-sum possible.
- Rollovers possible to IRA or other qualified plan
- Some must be taken as annuity
Profit sharing plan distrbutions
- May permit in-service withdrawals after 2 yearss
- 401K’s may permit loans
- At termination:
- lump-sum
- rollover
- purchase annuity
Taxation of distributions
- Ordinary income tax
- except:
- rollover
- annuity
- lump-sum option
- if after-tax contributions had been made
- QDRO
- taxable distributions from qualified plan (not rollover) are subject to 20% withholding
Rollovers to IRA’s cause loss of
- ERISA protection - though rollovers are proteted from bkcy
- 10-year forward averaging
- NUA
- Pre-1974 Capital Gain treatment
Direct rollover
Distribution from a qualified plan trustee to the trustee of the recipient account
No income tax witholding
Indirect Rollover
A distribution to the participant with subsequent transfer to another account
20% tax witholding (when that amount is replaced into account within 60 days, that amount is then refunded as tax refund)
Lump-sum distribution
- distribution of entire account balance within 1 taxable year
- caused by:
- death
- attainment of 59.5
- separation of service
- disability
- employee participated for 5 years
10 year forward averaging
- participant born prior to 1/2/1936
- tax calculated using 1986 rates
- must be lump-sum distribution in 1 calendar year
- divide amount by 10 and apply rates. Then multiply total by 10.
Pre-1974 Capital Gain Treatment
- participant born prior to 1/2/36
- lump sum distribution
- pre-1974 portion of capital gains taxed as 20% long-term capital gains.
- remaining portion eligible for 10-year forward averaging
NUA inheritance treatment
- NUA does not receive a step-to fair market value at death
- Heirs maintain same NUA treatment - taxed as LT CG
- any additional gain beyond the NUA gain is stepped to FMV.
- IF lump-sum distribution has been made prior to death and stock is still held.
Qualified Domestic Relations Order
- Order, judgement, decress set forth for child support or divorce
- Nontaxable distribution as long as assets are deposited into an IRA or other qual. plan for benefit of the other party.
- Can be:
- shared payment - each person get a portion of the distributions - usually DB plan
- separate interest - account separated into portions
- To former spouse: If not deposited into qualified plan, then 10% penalty
- Distribution to child: not eligible to rollover; child is not taxed; participant is taxed
*