research methods. Flashcards
What 2 ways can research data be classified into?
- primary and secondary data.
- quantitative and qualitative data.
What is meant by primary data?
Information collected by sociologists themselves for their own purposes.
[obtain a first-hand picture of a group or society or to test a hypothesis]
How can primary data be collected?
- social surveys.
- participant observation.
- experiments.
How are social surveys conducted?
Asking people questions in a written questionnaire or an interview.
How are participant observations conducted?
The sociologists joins in with the activities of the group they are studying.
Which experiments do sociologists use?
Sociologists rarely use lab experiments but they sometimes use field experiments and the comparative method.
What are the advantages of using primary data?
- able to gather precisely the information they need to test their hypotheses.
- more accurate and reliable.
- updated information.
- more control over data as research can be manipulated to help them to obtain correct feedback.
- privacy is maintained.
What are the disadvantages of using primary data?
- costly.
- time-consuming.
- experienced person is needed for the analysis.
What is meant by secondary data?
Information that has been collected or created by someone else for their own purposes but which the sociologists can then use.
How can secondary data be collected?
- official statistics.
- documents.
How are official statistics conducted?
Produced by government on a wide range of issues such as education, crime, divorce and unemployment as well as other statistics produced by charities, businesses, churches and other organisations.
What examples of documents?
- letters.
- emails.
- diaries.
- photographs.
- official reports.
- novels.
- newspapers.
- the internet.
- tv broadcasts.
What are the advantages of using secondary data?
- time-saving.
- cheap.
- easily accessible.
- allows for the generation of new insights from previous analysis.
- anyone can collect the data.
- large quantity.
What are the disadvantages of using secondary data?
- those who produce may not be interested in the same questions as sociologists so exact information may not be provided that sociologists need.
- no control over data quality.
- may be biased in favour of person who collected.
- may be out of date.
- anyone can access.
What is meant by quantitative data?
Information in a numerical form such as official statistics (girls passed 5 or more GCSEs) and the percentage (marriages ending in divorce or number of unemployed people).
What is meant by qualitative data?
Describes qualities or characteristics giving a feel for what something is like such as what it feels like to get good GCSE results or for divorce.
What are the advantages of using quantitative data?
- can be tested and checked as the way it is collected can be replicated as well as the results.
- straightforward analysis.
- larger sample size.
- increased representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of using quantitative data?
- does not consider the meaning behind the numbers.
- sometimes obtained in unnatural environments.
- individual characteristics do not always apply to the general population.
What factors may influence the choice of methods?
- practical issues.
- ethical issues.
- theoretical issues.
What are the examples of practical issues?
- time and money.
- requirement of funding bodies.
- personal skills and characteristics.
- research opportunity.
- subject matter of study.
What are the advantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- practical.
- reliable.
What are the disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- ethical.
- validity.
- representativeness.
What are the practical advantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- small samples may make it easier for variables to be controlled.
What are the reliable advantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- allows experiments to be replicated easily.
- detached method so researcher’s personal opinions and feelings are disregarded.
What are the practical disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- complex as not all variables are identified or controlled.
- past cannot be experimented and variables cannot be controlled.
- small samples results in difficulty to investigate large scale nature of lab experiments.
What are the ethical disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- lack of informal consent.
- deception.
- harm mentally or physically.
What are the reliable disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- rarely used in sociology.
What are the validity disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- artificial settings producing unnatural behaviour.
- free will therefore cannot be compared to plants.
What are the representativeness disadvantages of laboratory experiments in T&M?
- small samples.
Do interpretivists favour or reject laboratory experiments?
REJECT
- fails to achieve their main goal of validity.
- artificial and produces unnatural behaviour.
Do positivists favour or reject laboratory experiments?
FAVOUR
- achieves their main goal of reliability.
however
- used less.
- impossible or unethical to controll all variables.
- not representative or generalisable.
What is meant by T&M?
Theories and methods where research methods are applied in all situations.
What are the disadvantages of field experiments in T&M?
- practical.
- ethical.
- reliable.
What are the validity advantages of field experiments in T&M?
- takes place in natural surroundings.
- no hawthorne effect.
- unsure that they are subjects to an experiment.
What are the practical disadvantages of field experiments in T&M?
- less control over variables due to realistic experiments.
What are the ethical disadvantages of field experiments in T&M?
- not aware that they are subjects of an experiment so there is no consent.
What are the reliable disadvantages of field experiments in T&M?
- cannot be carried again exactly the same way.
Do interpretivists favour or reject field experiments?
FAVOUR
- achieves their main goal of validity.
- more representative.
- natural setting.
Do positivists favour or reject field experiments?
REJECT
- fails to achieve their main goal of reliability.
- hard to replicate.
- less control.
What is meant by MIC?
Research methods in context of education.
What are the advantages of field experiments in T&M?
- validity.
What are the advantages of using qualitatitve data?
- gives the researcher an insight on the participants thoughts and feelings.
- can save money as it uses a smaller sample size.
- provides participants with flexibility.
- provides detail-oriented data.
What are the disadvantages of using qualitatitve data?
- not statistically representative form of data collection.
- requires an experienced researcher.
- hard to replicate.
- can be misinterpreted.
- may be costly as it will require an experienced individual to analyse.
- may be influenced by reasercher bias.
- time-consuming.
What are the advantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- reliable.
- representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- practical.
- ethical.
- validity.
- representativeness.
What are the reliable advantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- experiments like Harvey and Slatin’s can be reused to be replicated.
What are the representativeness advantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- pupils used in the Harvey and Slatin experiment were of different backgrounds allowing its results to be applied.
What was the aim of the Harvey and Slatin experiment?
Used lab experiments to investigate teacher expectations where they examined whether teachers held fixed ideas about pupils of different social classes.
How was the Harvey and Slatin experiment carried out?
The teachers were represented with photographs of children from different social class backgrounds and then asked to rate them based of their performance, parental attitudes to education, aspirations and so on.
What were the results of the Harvey and Slatin experiment?
Lower-class students were rated less favourably.
What are the practical disadvantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- large and complex where many variables may go uncontrolled such as class size, streaming or type of school.
What are the ethical disadvantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- deception.
- lack of informed consent.
- psychological damage when pupils are used such as in the Charkin et al experiment.
What was the aim of the Charkin et al experiment?
Used lab experiments to examine whether their expectations could be passed on to pupils through non-verbal communication.
How was the Charkin et al experiment carried out?
Used a sample of 48 university students who each taught a lesson to a 10 year old boy.
- one third were told the boy was highly motivated and intelligent.
- one third were he was poorly motivated and with a low IQ.
- one third were given no information.
What were the results of the Charkin et al experiment?
Those in the high expectancy group made more eye contact and used more encouraging body language than the low expectancy group.
When was the Charkin et al experiment carried out?
1975.
[1970s]
When was the Harvey and Slatin experiment carried out?
1976.
[1970s]
What are the validity disadvantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- artificial experiments therefore results lack ecological validity.
What are the representativeness disadvantages of laboratory experiments in MIC?
- teachers may not have been of different backgrounds.
What are the advantages of field experiments in MIC?
- reliable.
- representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of field experiments in MIC?
- practical.
- ethical.
- reliable.
- validity.
What are the reliable advantages of field experiments in MIC?
- simple and easy to repeat such as the Rosenthal and Jacobson experiment.
What was the aim of the Rosenthal and Jacobson experiment?
To test the self-fulfilling prophecy theory.
How was the Rosenthal and Jacobson experiment carried out?
Teacher were told in Oak school that the children will be given an IQ test which was perfect as it was likely that none of the teachers would be familiar with it.
18 of the teachers were told that the kids in their class were at the top 20% meaning they were expected for greatness that school year.
The teachers did not know the list was randomised and there were no difference the students.
What were the results of the Rosenthal and Jacobson experiment?
The students classed at the top 20% showed greater gains than everyone else.
When was the Rosenthal and Jacobson experiment carried out?
1968.
[1960s]
What are the representativeness advantages of field experiments in MIC?
- different people mean different cultures.
- more generalisable.
What are the pratical disadvantages of field experiments in MIC?
- lack of control over variables.
What are the ethical disadvantages of field experiments in MIC?
- children were educationally held back such as the spurters in Rosenthal and Jacobson’s experiment.
- deception from researchers.
What are the reliable disadvantages of field experiments in MIC?
- can not be replicated exactly.
What are the validity disadvantages of field experiments in MIC?
- observations claim that teacher’s expectations were passed on through differences in the way they interacted with pupils which was not carried out.
What is meant by the comparative method?
An experiment carried out only in the mind of the sociologist which does not involve the actual experimenting of real people.
What is the use of the comparative method?
To discover cause-and-effect relationships.
How are the comparative method experiment carried out?
- identify 2 groups of people that are alike in all major respects except for the 1 variable we are interested in.
- compare the 2 groups to see if this one difference between them has any affect.
What is an example of the comparative method?
Emile Durkheim’s study of suicide.
When was Emile Durkheim’s study of suicide carried out?
1897.
[1890s]
How was Emile Durkheim’s study of suicide carried out?
Had a hypothesis that low levels of integration of individuals into social groups caused high rates of suicide.
- argued that Catholicism produced higher levels of intergration than Protestantism.
- predicted that Protestants would have higher suicide rate than Catholics.
How was Emile Durkheim’s study of suicide tested?
Comparing the suicide rates of Catholics and Protestants who were similar in all other important aspects such as terms where they lived or whether in a relationship.
How was Emile Durkheim’s study of suicide supported?
By official statistics which showed Catholics have lower suicide rates.
What are the advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- practical.
- ethical.
- reliable.
- validity.
- representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- practical.
- reliable.
- validity.
What are the practical advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- quick and cheap.
- large quantity of people.
- no need to recruit interviewers or train as it is completed and returned by respondents.
- processed quickly by computers creating relationships between different variables due to closed questions.
What are the ethical advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- no obligation for questions to be answered.
What are the reliable advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- can be repeatedly used.
- no researcher to influence answers.
- allow comparisons.
What are the validity advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- hypothesis on cause and effect relationships between different variables are useful.
- minimum personal involvement from researcher.
What are the representativeness advantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- larger quantity of people so increases representativeness.
- more attention is payed to ensure representativeness.
What are the practical disadvantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- limited and superficial data
↳ tend to be brief as people are less likely to complete long time-consuming questionnaires. - incentives may be offered for encouragement adding costs.
- not sure who completed it.
- not sure if it reached them.
- low response rate.
- inflexible.
What are the reliable disadvantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- respondents may lie, have forgotten or answer desirably.
What are the validity disadvantages of questionnaires in T&M?
- detached method
↳ inability to get close to the subjects of study and share meaning.
➝ no way of knowing whether respondent and researcher interpret the questions or answers in the same way. - answers may be lies.
- respondents may have forgotten.
- right answerism.
Do interpretivists favour or reject questionnaires in T&M?
REJECT
- fail to achieve their main goal of validity.
- argues that it lacks validity.
- does not give a true picture of what has been studied.
- impose the researcher’s framework of ideas on respondents.
Do positivists favour or reject questionnaires in T&M?
FAVOUR
- achieve their main goal of reliability, generalisability and representativeness.
- standardised questions and answers produce reliable data.
- quantitative data.
- more representative.
What are the advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- practical.
- ethical.
- reliable.
- validity.
- representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- practical.
- validity.
What are the practical advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- large quantity.
- quick and cheap way to gather information such as in Michael Nutter’s case.
- using schools to distribute questionnaires is efficient.
What are the ethical advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- anonymous so respondents may be more comfortable answering.
What are the reliable advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- can be repeated.
What are the validity advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- anonymous so more honest answers may be produced.
What are the representativeness advantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- sampling by sociologist can be done to ensure all types of teachers and pupils are involved/represented.
- no researcher’s input.
- overcomes status differences of adult researcher and younger respondent.
- higher response rate may result in higher representativeness.
What are the practical disadvantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- access to information on pupils may be denied.
- results are limited and superficial.
- those unale to read or with learning difficuties may be unsuitable.
- children have a shorter attention span resulting in questionnaire reading needing to be brief decreasing amount of information collected.
What are the validity disadvantages of questionnaires in MIC?
- respondents may fail to answer the questions due to the complexity of sociological terms
↳ oversimplifying the questions may cease to have any sociological data. - responses may be discussed between pupils beforehand.
- results are limited and superficial
↳ no explanation to correlation from data collected. - lack of experience may result in the inability to answer.
- formality may cause children in anti-school subcultures not cooperating or seriously answering.
Do interpretivists favour or reject questionnaires in MIC?
REJECT
- believe developing a rapport with participants is important.
- difficult to establish.
- young people may be less likely to give full and honest responses.
Do positivists favour or reject questionnaires in MIC?
FAVOUR
- high level of representativeness.
What are the advantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- practical.
- ehical.
- reliable.
- representativeness.
What are the disadvantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- validity.
- representativeness.
What are the practical advantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- inexpensive and straightforward to train interviewers.
- large sample size.
- quick.
- fairly cheap.
- straightforward way of gaining information.
- easily quantified due to closed questions making it suitable for hypothesis testing.
What are the ethical advantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- no obligation for questions to be answered.
- less intrusive.
What are the reliable advantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- easily controlled.
- standardised.
- easily compare answers to identify similarities and differences.
- easily replicable.
What are the representativeness advantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- large sample size.
- higher response rate such as for Young and Willmott where they approached 987 people and only 54 refused to be interviewed as it is harder to turn down a face-to-face request.
What are the validity disadvantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- closed questions restrict interviewees to choosing from limited number of pre-set answers.
- invalid data if answers provided do not match interviewees’ personal answer.
- little freedom to explain answers or clarify misunderstandings.
- lies or exaggeration can produce false data.
- interviewer may influence answers.
- does not reflect interviewee’s concerns and priorities.
- fail to capture real life.
- participants may try be socially desirable.
What are the representativeness disadvantages of structured interviews in T&M?
- those interviewed may not be generalisable as they may be the few who are lonely and have time on their hands.
Do interpretivists favour or reject structured interviews?
REJECT
- fails to achieve their main goal of validity.
- lacks validity.
- not a true picture of what is being studied.
- researcher’s framework of ideas may be imposed on respondents.
- feminist criticism - Hilary Graham (1983).
Do positivists favour or reject structured interviews?
FAVOUR
- achieves their main goal of reliability, generalisability and representativeness.
- standardised questions and answers produce reliable data.
- quantitative data.
- more representative.
What are the advantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- ethical.
- validity.
What are the disadvantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- practical.
- reliable.
- validity.
- representative.
What are the ethical advantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- no obligation for questions to be answered.
What are the validity advantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- open questions allow a relationship to be built between interviewer and interviewee which may allow more information to be obtained due to respondent being more comfortable
↳ William Labov (1973) - interview of black american children.
➝ Dobash and Dobash - study of domestic violence. - prioritises interviewee’s priorities and concerns.
- interviewer’s probing can help formulate and develop interviewees’ thoughts more clearly.
- low chance of misunderstandings.
- flexibility.
What are the practical disadvantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- small sample size due to in-depth interviews.
- more thorough training required.
- costly to conduct.
- good interpersonal skills are needed from interviewers.
- lack of quantitative data makes it less useful for establishing cause and effect relationships and hypothesis testing.
What are the reliable disadvantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- not standardised therefore interviewers are free to ask any questions they may feel is relevant.
What are the validity disadvantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- lies or exaggeration can produce false data.
- interviewer may influence answers.
What are the representativeness disadvantages of unstructured interviews in T&M?
- small sample.
- harder to make valid generalisation.
Do interpretivists favour or reject unstructured interviews?
FAVOUR
- achieves their main goal of validity.
- high validity.
- rapport built therefore a real life image can be made.
- qualitative data.
Do positivists favour or reject structured interviews?
REJECT
- does not achieve their main goal of reliability and representativeness.
- less representative.
- qualitative data.