Remedies Flashcards
Remedy Causes of Action
- Contract
- Tort
- Property
- Quasi-Contract/Unjust Enrichment/Restitution
Contract Legal Remedies
- Compensatory Damages
- Equitable Remedies
- Provisional Remedies
Expectancy Damages
Benefit of the Bargain Damages.
Seeks to put parties in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed.
Damages = Market price [-] Contract Price
UCC cover - cost of replacing the goods
cost of cover [-] contract price
Lost Volume Seller
Someone who can sell as many of an item as they can find buyers.
If buyer repudiates purchase, damage is the lost profit on the item, even if that particular item is resold to another buyer
Consequential Damages Analysis
- Causal - damages would not occur but for the breach
- Foreseeable - at time of contract
- Certain
- Unavoidable - duty to mitigate
Consequential Damages
Logically flow from a breach of the contract other than the cost of sale, profit, and purchase price.
Contract Analysis.
If damage is lost future profits beyond profit from immediate transaction, even though benefit of the bargain, use four part analysis if profit is based on projections.
Reliance Damages
Seeks to put the party in the position they would have been in had the contract not been formed in the first place
Out of pocket costs incurred by a party before the contract is actually performed.
Only available if benefit of the bargain damages are too speculative, otherwise, such damages are possible expectancy damages
Incidental Damages
Expenses reasonably incurred in shipping, care, and custody of goods and, for the seller, in re-selling the goods after a breach
Liquidated Damages
Parties stipulated-to amount.
Upheld if damages will be extremely difficult to ascertain and the stipulated amount is a reasonable forecast of the damages.
Look at proportionality of the stipulated amount to the possible level of damages
Otherwise, void as a penalty
Specific Performance
Enforcement of the contract after a breach.
ELEMENTS:
1. valid and enforceable contract, with definite and certain terms
- party has met all the conditions required or performance of the conditions is excused
- legal remedy is inadequate
- remedy is feasible
TRO and Preliminary Injunctions
Solely in aid of specific performance or replevin.
To preserve subject of contract from imminent sale or transfer.
Subject of contract must be unique
Preliminary Injunction Elements
- Irreparable Injury
- Likelihood of success
- Balance of hardships favors the injunction
TRO
- Irreparable Injury
- Likelihood of success
- Balance of hardships favors the injunction
- Immediacy of harm
Rescission
Undoing of a contract due to mistake or misrepresentation
Rescission by Mistake
Mistake must be as to a material fact (basis of the bargain)
if mistake is unilateral:
- majority: non-mistaken party knows of mistake
- minority: balance harms to each party
Rescission by Misrepresentation
False representation/omission of a material fact
D knew (intentional); should have known (negligent) was false OR innocently made (innocent misrepresentation).
P reasonably relied to his detriment
Reformation
Requires valid prior agreement.
Grounds:
- Mutual mistake (scrivener’s error);
- Unilateral mistake; and
- Fraud
Declaratory Relief
Determines rights and obligations of the parties to a contract
Compensatory Damages
- Expectation Damages
- Consequential Damages
- Reliance Damages
- Incidental Damages
- Liquidated Damages
Equitable Remedies - Contracts
- Specific Performance
- Rescission
- Reformation
- Declaratory Relief
Provisional Remedies
- TRO
2. Preliminary Injunctions
Tort Damages
- General damages foreseeable from the injury (pain and suffering)
- Special damages that could not have been foreseen from the mere occurrence of the wrong (medical expenses, lost wages)
- Punitive damages
ELEMENTS:
- Causal (but for)
- Foreseeable - at time of breach of duty (relaxed for intentional torts)
- Certain
- Unavoidable
Special and punitive damages must be pleaded in the complaint.
Punitive Damages
Awarded for willful and wanton conduct amounting to fraud, oppression, or malice
Fraud - intentional misrepresentation, deceit, or concealment of a material fact known to D with intention on the part of D of depriving person/property or legal rights or otherwise causing injury
Oppression - despicable conduct that subjects a person to cruel and unjust hardship in conscious disregard of that person’s rights
Malice - conduct intended by D to cause injury to P or despicable conduct which is carried on by D with a willful and conscious disregard of the rights or safety of others
Subject to due process issues - invalid if grossly excessive
Notice Factors:
- reprehensibility of D’s conduct;
- disparity between actual or potential harm suffered and the punitive award;
- difference between punitive award and criminal or civil penalties authorized for comparable misconduct
Equitable Tort Remedies
- Provisional Remedies
2. Permanent Injunction