Remedies Flashcards
Remedies
Compensatory damages in torts
goal is retrospective
- pain and suffering (must experience; in CA includes hedonic loss (loss of enjoyment of the value of life)
- Emotional distress (requires physical injury or outrageous or intentional conduct; includes anxiety, emotion al distress caused by fear, humiliation, loss of freedom)
- past, present, and future medical expenses
- present and future loss of income
Remedies
damages in contracts
goal is prospective
- Expectation damages (MP-KP) + (C/I D) - ($ saved)
- Reliance damages
- Restitutionary damages
- Nominal damages
- Punitive damages
- Bargained for liquidated damages
Remedies
consequential damages def
any damages that naturally result from the seller’s breach
Remedies
incidental damages def
costs leading up to the breach in reliance on the contract
Remedies
UCC buyer’s remedies
- do nothing and sue for expectation damages
- cover and sue for expectation damages
(CP-KP) + (C/I D) - ($ saved) - accept non-conforming goods and sue for breach of warranty
(value as warranted - value as accepted) + (C/I D) - ($ saved)
Remedies
what is included in reliance damages?
expenses made in preparation for performing the contract and expenses in performing the contract
Remedies
when are reliance damages preferred?
Compensatory damages are preferred. Reliance damages may be preferred when:
1) P cannot prove profit
2) P has a problem with substantive part of a k claim (k not valid, not enforceable)
3) compelling public policy reasons for limiting expectation damages
4) P cannot prove reasonable expectation damages with certainty
Remedies
what is included in restitutionary damages?
benefits conferred on D by P’s conduct
Remedies
when are restitutionary damages appropriate?
where there is a total breach of k by D that results in D being in a better position
Remedies
when are nominal damages appropriate in tort or k?
when P has established all other elements of a cause of action but cannot show great harm or loss.
Nominal damages are not available when the c/a requires P to establish more than nominal damages
Remedies
when are punitive damages available in tort?
1) when P has compensatory damages,
2) there is a need to punish and deter D from future violations, and
3) the punitive damages do not impose a grossly excessive punishment under the 14th amendment DP clause
Remedies
punitive damages factors
whether excessive:
1) reprehensibility
2) Proportionality: difference between harm suffered and damages awarded,
3) difference b/w this award and the civil penalties in similar cases
Remedies
punitive damages factors: reprehensibility
1) whether harm was physical rather than purely economic
2) whether tortious conduct demonstrated indifference to or reckless disregard of health and safety of others
3) vulnerable victims
4) repeated violations- deterrence of others
5) intent rather than mere negligence
Remedies
Punitive damages factors: proportionality
there must be a single digit ratio between the compensatory damages and the punitive damages
Remedies
Punitive damages factors: ability to pay
D’s ability to pay
Remedies
Punitive damages in k
Commonly awarded
1) if D’s conduct is both tortious and a b/k
2) where there is a dead body or body parts involved
need to hook to other damages, like nominal damage award
Remedies
liquidated damages def
damages agreed upon (bargained for) by the parties in the formation of the k