Remedies Flashcards
Compensatory Damages
“Benefit of the bargain” damages
-Puts the part back where she would have been absent the breach.
Expectation damages: cost to purchase a substitute.
Reliance: if costs are too speculative to calculate expectation, include damages incurred in dealing with breach (shipping, storage, etc.) CANNOT have both expectation and reliance.
4 Elements of Damages
- Causal: caused by the breach
- Certain: not speculative
- Foreseeable: at the time of contracting
- Unavoidable: cannot be mitigated
UCC: Buyer’s Damages for Seller’s Non-Delivery
Buyer receives damages of the difference between contract price, and cost of replacement at time of breach or market price at time of breach.
UCC: Buyer’s Damages if Seller Delivers Non-Conforming Goods
If buyer accepts the goods, damages are the measure of the difference between value delivered and value under the contract
UCC: Buyer’s Damages if seller Anticipatorily Breaches
Measure of damages is the difference between price at the time buyer learned of the breach, and the contract price.
UCC: Consequential Damages
Consequential damages are generally not recoverable under the UCC, unless the seller knew or had reason to know of the buyer’s particular requirements, and subsequent loss cannot be prevented by cover.
UCC: Seller’s Damages if Buyer Repudiates
In addition to incidental damages, seller can recover the difference between the market price at time of delivery and the contract price
If LOST VOLUME seller, can recover expected profit
Incidental Damages
Damages incurred in dealing with the breach, such as finding a replacement
Punitive Damages
Typically not available in contracts cases; punitives are designed to punish D for his wrongful conduct.
Factors the court will consider include: degree of reprehensibility of defendant’s conduct, ration of puintives to compensatory damages, and civil or criminal penalties for the offense. Possible 8th Amendment implications.
Nominal Damages
May be awarded where a breach is shown, but there are no actual damages or losses
Liquidated Damages
A contract may contain a liquidated damages clause, which stipulates the damages in event of a breach.
Awarded if damages for breach are difficult to estimate or ascertain at the time of contracting, and the agreed upon amount is a reasonable forecast of compensatory damages.
Specific Performance (Restitutionary Remedy)
Requirements:
- Valid and enforceable contract
- Definite and certain terms
- Inadequate legal remedy (non-breaching party is insolvent, or the good is rare/unique/land)
- Satisfaction of conditions: has non-breaching party actually paid the purchase price? Condition can be excused by anticipatory repudiation
- Feasibility of enforcement
- Inapplicability of defenses
Rescission (Restitutionary Contract Remedy)
Rescission is an undoing of the contract, whereby the original contract is considered voidable and rescinded and the parties are left as though it never existed.
No meeting of the minds (as opposed to reformation, where meeting of the minds but document does not reflect it).
Grounds for rescission include:
- Mutual mistake as to the basis of the bargain
- Unilateral mistake, if other party knew or should have known of the mistake, and hardship is so extreme that it warrants remedy
- Misrepresentation of a material fact that was relied upon
- Undue influence, duress, illegality, etc.
Defenses to Rescission
Unclean hands, laches
Reformation (Contract Remedy)
The writing setting forth the agreement between the parties is changed so as to conform to the parties’ original intent. Requires an otherwise valid contract (meeting of the minds)
-Reformation is typically based on mutual mistake, such as a scrivener’s error
Replevin (UCC Remedy)
Permitted in a contract for the sale of goods:
- Buyer may replevy undelivered, identified goods if, after a reasonable effort, they are unable to cover
- If buyer has made at least partial payment and seller has not delivered, can replevy if seller becomes insolvent within 10 days, or goods were for personal/family/household use
Interlocutory Injunctive Relief (Equitable)
Refers to either a TRO or a preliminary injunction. Both require a showing of irreparable harm if the injunction is not granted, and a reasonable likelihood of success on the merits.
TRO: typically granted within 24 hours, and lasts until preliminary hearing or injunction. Emergency order; can be imposed ex-parte if notice would hasten the harm.
Preliminary Injunction: granted after a preliminary hearing, and remains in effect until conclusion of full trial or dissolution by court.
Permanent Injunctive Relief (Equitable)
Can be obtained upon a showing of:
- Inadequate legal remedy
- Feasibility of enforcement (courts more inclined to order a negative injunction than a mandatory injunction)
- Balancing of hardships
Laches
Equitable defense; applies when a party unreasonably delays in bringing an equitable action and the delay prejudices the defendant.