PR Flashcards
Unauthorized Practice of Law
A non-lawyer may not engage in, nor may a lawyer assist a non-lawyer in engaging in, the practice of law, which is defined as that involving the professional judgment of a lawyer.
ABA: Rules prohibit a lawyer from practicing law in a Jx where they are not admitted, and prohibit a lawyer from helping him.
CA: constitutes a misdemeanor.
Exceptions to Ban on UPL
Where professional judgment is not involved (ex: paralegals, law clerks).
Multi-Jurisdictional Practice
Generally, a lawyer who is not licensed in a particular Jx may not open a law office there, hold herself out as practicing there, or establish systematic and continuous presence in the other Jx without becoming licensed.
CA: exception for in-house counsel.
Temporary Multi-Jurisdictional Practice
- Association with a local lawyer
- Pro hac vice admission
- Alternative dispute resolution
- Out of state practice is reasonably related to the in-state practice
Law Firm Naming
A lawyer must not use a firm name that is false or misleading; the name of a lawyer holding public office may not be included during any substantial period in which the lawyer is not practicing.
Partnership With Non-Lawyers
A lawyer may not partner or share profits or legal fees with a non-lawyer, unless the payment is for money after lawyer’s death, pursuant to compensation agreements, or for rent.
Supervisory Partners or Lawyers
A lawyer will be responsible for another lawyer’s violations of the RPC if he orders or ratifies the conduct, or has supervisory authority and is aware of the conduct at a time when it could have been avoided.
The actor may not be liable if they are directly following orders of a supervisor, and the ethical violation was debatable.
Restrictions on the Right to Practice
A lawyer must not make a partnership or employment agreement that restricts the lawyer to practice after termination of the relationship, except if concerns retirement benefits, or settlement of a controversy between private parties.
Sale of a Practice (ABA)
A lawyer is permitted to sell a law practice or an AREA of practice, if:
- Sold to one or more lawyers or law firms,
- Seller ceases private practice of law, or at least in that area,
- Client fees do not increase, and 4. Seller notifies clients of their right to hire a different lawyer.
Sale of a Practice (CA)
Differs in several respects from the ABA rule:
- Notice requirements to clients are more complicated
- Seller does not have to stop practicing in the geographic area
- CANNOT sell an area of practice
- Seller can retain a few clients, who pose a conflict for the purchaser or who have a long relationship with the seller
Advertising, in General
Advertising is a general attempt to obtain business, which includes things like TV and radio ads, newspapers, etc. Each advertisement must be labeled as such, and contain the name and office address of at least one lawyer or firm responsible for its content.
Advertising - False and Misleading
Advertising that is false and misleading may be banned; factors to consider include: whether the statement contains a material misrepresentation of law or fact, or omits information necessary to make the communication as a whole not materially misleading.
CA Restrictions on Advertising
A lawyer is prohibited from making advertisements that contain:
- A guarantee or warranty of the outcome
- Words or symbols suggesting quick cash or settlement
- Impersonation or dramatization that is not properly labeled as such
- Contingent fee offers that do not warn that a client who loses may still have to pay court costs.
The following materials are presumptively false and misleading: delivered to a client in the hospital suffering from physical or mental stress, mailings seeking fee paying work not labeled as such, or those containing testimonials or endorsements without disclaimer
Solicitation, in General
Solicitation involves directed contact with a particular person or persons, designed to induce the person into hiring the lawyer
Solicitation (ABA)
A lawyer must not seek fee paying work by initiating personal or live telephone contact, or real time electronic contact, with a specific person who is not a lawyer and with whom the lawyer has no prior relationship.
Solicitation (CA)
Prohibits all telephone contact, not just “live” telephone contact, as well as solicitation when the lawyer knows the person is already represented by counsel; however, does not specifically prohibit electronic communications.
Potential Conflicts
Those that do not yet exist. Spell out what could go factually wrong, and obtain the consent of clients.
Concurrent Conflicts
A lawyer must not represent a client if the representation creates a concurrent conflict of interest, which exists when representation of the client will be directly adverse to that of another client, or there is a significant risk the representation will be materially limited by the lawyer’s personal interests or those of another/former client.
Client Consent to Concurrent Conflicts (ABA)
A lawyer may undertake representation if he reasonably believes he can competently and diligently represent each affected client, the representation is not prohibited by law and does not involve direct assertions by one client against another, and each client gives informed, WRITTEN consent.
Client Consent to Concurrent Conflicts (CA)
Differs slightly from the ABA standard; does not contain a “reasonable lawyer” standard, applies to potential and actual conflicts, and only requires informed, written consent if the conflict is between clients (if between lawyer-client, written disclosure)
Representation of Multiple Parties
A lawyer should not try to defend criminal co-defendants.
A lawyer may represent two parties or clients whose interests are potentially in conflict, if she concludes that she can do so. Lawyer must obtain informed, written consent and make it clear that confidentiality might not apply.
Ownership or Financial Interests (Conflicts)
A lawyer must not enter into a business transaction with a client or knowingly acquire a pecuniary interest adverse to the client, unless the transaction and terms are fair and reasonable to the client, fully disclosed, client is advised of desirability of obtaining independent counsel, and client gives informed consent.
Improper Use of Information Adverse to a Client (Conflicts)
A lawyer must not use information relating to the representation of a client to the disadvantage of that client, without informed, written consent.
Designating Oneself as Beneficiary (ABA/CA)
ABA: lawyer must not solicit a substantial gift from a client or prepare an instrument giving a gift; CA: prohibited from inducing the gift.
Both raise a statutory presumption of undue influence.
Literary or Media Rights (ABA/CA)
ABA: a lawyer must not obtain media rights prior to the conclusion of the representation
CA: contains no comparable provision, but the judge must be satisfied that the defendant understands the conflict of giving away media rights based on representation.
Financial Assistance to Clients (ABA)
A lawyer must not provide financial assistance to a client IN CONNECTION WITH LITIGATION, except: may advance court costs or pay fees if client is indigent, and may advance court costs contingent on the outcome.