Remedies Flashcards
NONMONETARY REMEDIES
- There are 2 broad branches of remedies available in BOK situations: nonmonetary & monetary.
- Primary nonmonetary remedy: specific performance
- Art 2 has a # of other specific nonmonetary remedies for certain situations involving SOGKs
Specific Performance
- If legal remedy (money damages) is inadequate, nonbreaching party may seek specific performance (order from ct to breaching party to perform/face contempt charges)
Tip
Watch for fact pattern where party is seeking to specifically enforce a K containing liquidated damages clause (does not make the legal remedy adequate)
Available for Land and Rare or Unique Goods
- Specific performance is always available for land sale Ks
- Also available for goods that are rare/unique at time performance is due (ex. rare paintings, gasoline in short supply b/c of oil embargoes, etc.).
- Not available for BOK to provide services, even if services are rare/unique.
Injunction as Alternate Remedy
- Ct may enjoin a breaching employee from working for a competitor throughout duration of K if services contracted for are rare/unique
Covenant Not to Compete
- Most cts will grant an order of specific performance to
enforce a K not to compete if:
(1) services to be performed are unique (thus rendering money damages inadequate); and
(2) covenant is reasonable.
To be reasonable:
(1) Covenant must be reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate interest of person benefited by the covenant (employer/purchaser of covenantor’s business);
(2) Covenant must be reasonable as to its geographic scope & duration (it cannot be broader than benefited person’s customer base & typically cannot be longer than 1/2 years); and
(3) Covenant must not harm the public.
Equitable Defenses Available
.
- In addition to standard K defenses, an action for
specific performance is subject to equitable defenses of:
(1) Laches (claim that P has delayed bringing action & delay has prejudiced D);
(2) Unclean hands (claim that party seeking specific performance is guilty of wrongdoing in transaction being sued upon); and
(3) Sale to a bona fide purchaser (claim that SM has been sold to person who purchased for value & in good faith)
Buyer’s Nonmonetary Remedies: Cancellation
- If buyer rightfully rejects goods b/c they are nonconforming, buyer can cancel K.
Buyer’s Right to Replevy Identified Goods
—
On Buyer’s Prepayment
- If buyer has made at least part payment of purchase price of goods that have been identified under K & seller has not delivered goods, buyer may recover goods from seller in 2 circumstances:
(1) Seller becomes insolvent w/in 10 days after receiving buyer’s 1st payment; or
(2) Goods were purchased for personal, family, or
household purposes.
- In either case, buyer must tender any unpaid portion of purchase price to seller.
On Buyer’s Inability to Cover
- In addition, buyer may recover undelivered, identified goods from seller if buyer, after reasonable effort, is unable to secure adequate substitute goods (cover).
Buyer’s Right to Specific Performance
- A right closely related to buyer’s right to replevy is
the right to specific performance “where goods are
unique or in other proper circumstances.” - Ct may order specific performance even where goods have not yet been identified to the K by seller.
Seller’s Nonmonetary Remedies: Seller’s Right to Withhold Goods
- If buyer fails to make a payment due on/before delivery, seller may w/hold delivery of goods.
- Seller may also w/hold goods when goods are sold on credit and, before goods are delivered, seller discovers that buyer is insolvent.
- However, in such a case, seller must deliver goods if buyer tenders cash for their payment.
Seller’s Right to Recover Goods
Right to Recover from Buyer on Buyer’s Insolvency
- If seller learns that buyer has received delivery of goods on credit while insolvent, seller may reclaim goods upon demand made w/in 10 days after buyer’s receipt of goods.
- However, the 10-day limitation does not apply if a misrep of solvency has been made in writing to particular seller w/in 3 months before delivery.
- Right to Recover Shipped or Stored Goods from
Bailee
On Buyer’s Insolvency
-Seller may stop delivery of goods in possession of a carrier/other bailee if they discover that buyer is insolvent.
- Of course, seller must deliver goods if buyer tenders cash for their payment
On Buyer’s Breach
- Seller may stop delivery of carload, truckload, planeload, or larger shipments of goods if buyer breaches K/seller has a right to w/hold performance pending receipt of assurances.
Seller’s Ability to Force Goods on Buyer Limited
- Seller’s ability to force goods on buyer is limited to an action for price when seller cannot resell goods at reasonable price.
Right to Demand Assurances
- Where party to a K but don’t CLEARLY indicate that performance will not occur may not be treated immediately as an anticipatory repudiation
- Instead, if there are reasonable grounds for insecurity w/ respect to party’s performance, other party may demand in writing assurances that performance will occur at proper time.
- Until they receive adequate assurances, party may suspend their own performance.
- If proper assurances are not given w/in a reasonable time (w/in 30 days after demand for assurances), they may then treat K as repudiated.
- What constitutes adequate assurance depends on facts
Tip:
Be sure you understand difference between circumstances giving rise to a right to demand assurances & those constituting anticipatory repudiation. The right to demand assurances arises when there are reasonable grounds for insecurity—something makes a party nervous that other will not perform. Anticipatory repudiation requires much more than nervousness; there must be a CLEAR indication that other party is unwilling/unable to perform. Ex. “I’m not going to perform” is an anticipatory repudiation, but “I’m not sure if I can perform” most likely is only a reason to demand assurances.
MONETARY REMEDY—DAMAGES
- Damages can be recovered only to extent they can be proved w/ REASONABLE CERTAINTY & could not be avoided w/ REASONABLE EFFORT
Compensatory Damages
- The usual goal of damages for BOK is to put nonbreaching party in position they would have been in had the promise been performed, so far as money can do this.
“Standard Measure” of Damages—Expectation
Damages
- “Expectation” damages: sufficient to buy a substitute performance.
- Also known as “benefit of bargain” damages.
Reliance Damage Measure
- If P’s expectation damages are too speculative to measure (ex. P cannot show w/ sufficient certainty the profits they would’ve made if D had performed the K), P may elect to recover those based on their reasonable reliance on the K.
- Reliance damages awards P cost of their performance (they are designed to put P in the position that would have been in had K never been formed.
Incidental Damages
- Compensatory damages may also include incidental damages.
- Incidental damages are associated w/ SOGs & typically include expenses REASONABLY INCURRED by buyer REASONABLY INCIDENT to seller’s breach, & by seller as a result of buyer’s breach.
Consequential Damages
- Consequential damages are special damages & reflect losses over & above standard expectation damages.
- They arise b/c of nonbreaching party’s particular circumstances, & most often they consist of LOST PROFITS.
- May be recovered only if, at time K was made, a REASONABLE person would have FORESEEN damages as PROBABLE result of a breach.
- Foreseeability is key
- To recover consequential damages, breaching party must have known/had reason to know of special circumstances giving rise to damages.
- Note that in SOGs, only buyer may recover consequential damages.
Certainty Rule
- P must prove that losses suffered were certain & not speculative.
- Traditionally, if breaching party prevented nonbreaching party from setting up a new business, cts would not award lost profits from prospective business as damages, b/c they were too speculative.
- However, modern cts may allow lost profits as damages if they can be made more certain by observing similar businesses in the area/other businesses previously owned by same party
Punitive Damages
- Punitive damages are generally not awarded in K cases.
Nominal Damages
- Nominal (token) damages (ex. $1) may be awarded when a breach is shown but no actual loss is proven
Liquidated Damages
- Parties to a K may stipulate what damages are to be paid for a breach.
- Liquidated damages must be for a REASONABLE amount in view of actual/anticipated harm caused by breach.
Requirements for Enforcement: LD
- Liquidated damage clauses - 2 requirements are:
(1) Damages for contractual breach are difficult to estimate AT TIME K is formed; and
(2) Amount agreed on is a REASONABLE forecast of compensatory damages for breach. - Reasonableness test: comparison between amount of damages prospectively probable AT TIME of K formation & liquidated damages figure.
- If liquidated damages amount is unreasonable, cts will construe this as a penalty & will not enforce provision.
Recoverable Even If No Actual Damages: LD
- If above requirements are met, P will receive liquidated damages amount.
- Even if no actual money /pecuniary damages have been suffered
SOGKs - Buyer’s Damages : Seller Does Not Deliver or Buyer Rejects/Revokes
- If seller doesn’t deliver, or buyer properly rejects goods/revokes acceptance of goods, buyer’s basic damages consist of difference between K price & either:
(1) market price or
(2) cost of cover, plus incidental & consequential damages (if any) minus costs saved due to seller’s breach
Difference Between Contract Price and Cost of
Replacement Goods—“Cover”
- If buyer chooses cover measure (difference between K price & cost of buying replacement goods), buyer must make a reasonable K/substitute goods in good faith & w/out unreasonable delay.