Relevancy Flashcards
what is relevant?
It has a tendency to make something more or less probable than it would be without the evidence
even if relevant what are ways it can still not come in?
You can exclude for prejudice (jury would put too much emphasis on it), would waste time, or would mislead or confuse the jury
Authentication?
Need to to authenticate writings, documents, x-rays, etc. Need to prove item is what you say it is.
how to authenticate?
- Direct testimony
- BIG WAY: testimony from someone that is directly familiar with that piece of evidence based on their own person knowledge. “i know that signature”
Self authenticating documents?
Any kinds of official papers, notarized docs, seals
Look for official pieces of paper
Character evidence?
About bad things one of the parties did in the past
IS character evidence admissible?
Generally no, because its prejudicial
How to determine if something is character evidence question
On trial for murder, prosecution wants to introduce evidence that D did a bad thing in his past
Character evidence in civil cases
Character evidence is admissible when it is at issue. it is at issue when:
- Defamation
- Custody
- Negligent entrustment
Character evidence in criminal trial
Generally not admissible except
- When D opens door with evidence of their GOOD character
- If on trial for violent crimes, allowed to bring in reputation or opinion evidence about your peacefulness.
1. bring in people to give their opinion that youre chill 2. CANNOT say “john did this one time’. has to be REPUTATIONAL
- If the crime is to truthfulness, you can bring in evidence of your truthfulness
Allowed to bring up padt crimes for character?
- IF past crime went to truthfulness then yes always
- IF its a felony and less than ten yeats old, then yes
Can bring in circumstantial evidence of things john has done in the past to show MIMIC:
- motive
1. Can bring in evidence that you had a motive - Identity
1. can bring in evidence to show it was John
2. want to show you had a special scar, etc - Mistake
1. Absence of mistake - Intent
1. Intent to commit crime - common plan or scheme
1. A red scarf was at the teller. the last 5 times John robbed a bank there was a red scarf there.
Character evidence in self defense
Can bring in evidence that P was the aggressor in self defense cases
If D is accused of molestation character evidence
evidence of other offenses are admissible