relevance Flashcards
discretionary exclusion of relevant evidence
probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice
relevant evidence
evidence is relevant if it tends to make the existence of any fact of consequence more or less probable than it would be without the evidence
evidence of liability insurance
not admissible to prove fault or a party’s ability to pay damages; admissible for anything else
evidence of subsequent remedial measures
evidence of repairs or other remedial measures taken after an injury is inadmissible to prove fault, defect, or inadequate warning; admissible to rebut a defense that there was no feasible precaution
evidence of compromises/settlement offers (civil)
inadmissible to prove liability or fault; doesn’t include statements made before the claim or threat of litigation was asserted
evidence of plea bargaining (criminal)
pleas, offers to plea, and related statements are inadmissible to prove guilt
evidence of payment/offers to pay medical expenses
inadmissible when offered to prove liability for injuries; related statements (incl. factual admissions) are admissible
similar occurrences
evidence of prior similar occurrences concerning the time, event, or person in the present controversy is often inadmissible as irrelevant ora s presenting an unfair risk of prejudice
admissible uses of similar occurrence evidence
1) causation
2) prior accidents demonstrating pattern of fraudulent claims or
preexisting conditions
3) intent/absence of mistake
4) rebut defense of impossibility
5) value
6) industry custom
7) business routine
habit evidence
a person’s habit may be relevant and admissible to show that the person acted in conformity with that habit on a given occasion; conduct must be highly specific and frequently repeated