Reason and Experience Flashcards
What is an analytic statement?
A statement which is true or false just from the meaning of the words.
What is a synthetic statement?
A statement which is true or false depending on the world.
Give an example of an analytic statement
All squares have four sides
Give an example of a synthetic statement
All tomatoes are red
What is a priori knowledge?
Knowledge of a proposition that does not require sense experience to be true
What is a posteriori knowledge?
Knowledge of a proposition that can be established through experience
Give an example of a priori knowledge
Bachelors are unmarried
Give an example of a posteriori knowledge
Snow is white
How are all analytic statements known?
All analytic statements are known a priori (do not require experience to be true)
What do rationalists believe?
That we have innate knowledge and that we have synthetic a priori knowledge about the world.
What do empiricists believe?
That we do not have innate knowledge, and that priori knowledge is analytic.
If we have knowledge that doesn’t come from sense experience, then where does it come from?
Rationalists would say that we have a form of rational intuition or we know certain truths innately as part of our rational nature
Who came up with the Tabula rasa concept?
Locke
What is Locke’s definition of an innate idea?
An idea which a person is conscious of from birth.
What is John Locke believe?
That all ideas were derived from experience
What is Locke’s argument against Innate ideas to do with consciousness?
That for an idea to be in the mind, the mind or person would have to be conscious of it. But we are not conscious of our ideas at birth.
What is Locke’s argument against Innate ideas to do with assented truths?
If we were all born with the same innate ideas, then there would be truths that we all assent to, but since there arent, there cannot be innate ideas.
How could Locke accept innate ideas? And why doesn’t this work?
If there were innate concepts, there could be innate propositions. However, there are no innate concepts which the mind has from birth, so there are therefore no innate propositions.
What is the rationalist argument against Locke’s argument? (we have no innate ideas because were are not conscious of them from birth)
Rationalists say that experience triggers our awareness of innate truths and concepts. Must be exposed to stimuli.
What example could rationalists use to illustrate the arguments that experience triggers awareness of innate truths?
Children would never learns a language unless they were exposed to it.
Argument against sense experience
Examples such as unicorns and god, they do not correspond to anything in experience.
How to empiricists respond to the argument that there are things which do not correspond to anything in experience
All complex ideas (Unicorns & God) are composed of simple ideas. And all simple ideas are composed of impressions.
What example may an empiricist use when arguing that complex ideas are composed of simple ideas.
Take the case of a unicorn, we have seen horns and we have seen horses. We just put them together to get a unicorn
Descartes is a …
Rationalist
Locke is a …
Empiricist
Hume is a …
Empiricist
Libeniz is a …
Rationalist
What things to rationalists believe we have synthetic a priori knowledge on?
Maths and morality
Quote from Locke about innate ideas
‘No proposition can be said to be in the Mind, which it never yet knew, which it was never conscious of.’
What is nativism?
the claim we have certain concepts or knowledge innately
How do we gain concepts according to Locke?
As we come to remember experiences through repetition we stater to label them. The senses let in ideas.
According to Hume, what are ideas?
faint copies of expressions
How does Hume think we acquire ideas?
By copying them from expressions
What are some simple concepts?
single colour, single shapes, single smells
How do we make complex ideas?
By uniting simple ideas
How do rationalists define innate knowledge?
Concepts or propositions whose content cannot be gained from experience, but which are triggered by experience
According to Hume what two things do we have knowledge on?
Matter of fact
Relations between ideas