Realism Flashcards
classical realism not
precise in defining its core assumptions- that human nature is what drove the international system
Key classical realists
Thucydides, Machiavelli and Hobbes.
Loas of realists
look at how individual actors/agents influence the state and state actions
Neorealists focus on structure to
explain state behaviour
core ideas of realism
- anarchy, in a way, dangerous enviro
- States are understood as unitary actors.
- Survivial (Governments striving for survival had to follow the principle of self-help).
- Self-help (This makes cooperation neither likely nor stable and, therefore, not reasonable. ) security dilemma. 5. Core interest: relative gains (compared to other rival states), not in absolute advantages (as NL believe)
20th century classical realists
Morgenthau, Schelling and others.
Neorealist thinkers
Waltz and Mearsheimer.
Thucydides
Melian Dialogue (Peloponnesian War)- highlighted human nature’s innate egotistical drive for power as an explanation for why IP is characterised by power & governs state behaviour. (also Machiavelli)
WHo reveals a belief in the primordial character of power and ethics, emphasising that patriotism is necessary for states to survive?
Thucydides
Hobbes viewed that
humans were egocentrical and that conflict would always arise unless there was a system for peaceful existence
Hobbes
established the social contract theory in Leviathan
Hobbes
established the social contract theory in Leviathan
Main critiques of realism
- Globalisation- very problematic to assume that states are the key actors
- Failure to predict & explain CW
- the unitary actor thesis is hardly “realistic”. Still, there are some interesting contributions from neo-realist thinkers. The prediction in the early 1990s that the bipolar Cold War system was more stable than the new (dis) order that replaced it has some merit.
economic policy of realists
they don´t like free trade, they believe the importation of foreign goods pollutes that state, and that in terms of self’intrests states should not engage in that much free trade.