Real Property Flashcards
Fee Simple Absolue
Largest estate
Can be sold, divided, devised, or inherited
Indefinite or potentially infinite duration
Presumed absent express contrary intent
Defeasible Fees
Fee simple estate which is terminable
Fee Simple Determinable
Terminates upon occurrence of stated event Automatic reversion (Possibility of Reverter) "for so long as"; "while"; "during"; or "until"
Possibility of Reverter
Grantor automatically retains possibility of reverter
Transferable, descendible and devisable
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent
Fee simple estate where grantor reserves the right to terminate upon occurrence of a stated event
“upon condition that”; “provided that”; “but if”; and “if it happens that”
Right of Entry
Accompanies fee simple subject to condition subsequent
Must be expressly reserved
Does not arise automatically
Most say devisable and all say descendible
Fee Simple Subject to an Executory Interest
Fee Simple terminates upon happening of STATED event
Void per public poilicy if penalizes marriage/encourages divorce
Purpose to support till marriage is ok
Fee Tail
Estate where inheritability is limited to lineal heirs
Created by words “to A and the heirs of his body”
Most have abolished and will recognize fess simple
Life Estate
Measured by the live of person or persons
Dower and curtesy can create-largely abandoned (AR still has)
Life Estate Pur Autre Vie
Life measure by life other than grantee’s
Life estate when life tenant transfers interest
Rights & Duties of Life Tenant
Entitled to ordinary uses
Cannot injury remaindermen’s interest
Types of Waste
Affirmative/Voluntary
Permissive Waste
Ameliorative Waste
Affirmative Waste of Natural Resourses
Generally no
Except when necessary for repair and maintenance; suitable only for such use; or expressly/implied permitted
Open Mines Doctrine: mining may continue if already open
Permissive Waste
Tenant obligated to preserve land and structures in a reasonable state of repair; pay interests on mortgages; pay ordinary taxes; and pay special assessment for public improvements of short duration
Limited by extent of income or profits
Ameliorative Waste
Change that benefits property economically
Actionable at common law, but now life tenant can alter or demolish buildings if: market value future interests not diminished and either, remaindermen do not object or substantial and permanent change in neighborhood conditions has deprived property reasonable productively or usefulness
Types of Future Interest
Reversionary–Possibility of Reverter and Rights of Entry
Remainders
Executory Interests
Reversion
Reversion is estate left in grantor who conveys less than they own–i.e. a life estate
Reversions are alienable, devisable, and inheritable
VESTED, i.e. not subject to Perpetuities Rule
Remainders
Future interest in third person which becomes possessory on natural expiration of preceding estate
Must be expressly created
Indefeasibly Vested Remainder
Vested remainder is one created in an existing ans ascertained person and not subject to condition precedent
Right to immediate possession upon normal termination
Indefeasibly vested remainder is a vested remainder that is not subject to divestment or diminution
Vested Remainder Subject to Open
Created in a class Certain to become possessory but subject to diminution
Vested Remainder Subject to Total Divestment
Vested Remainder Subject to Condition Subsequent
Contingent Remainder
Contingent Remainders are created in unborn or unascertained persons subject to a condition precedent
Subject to Condition Precedent
Condition precedent must be satisfied before remainderman has right to possession
Destructibility of Contingent Remainders
At CL destroyed if failed to vest before termination of preceding freehold estate
Most states have abolished–converts to executory interest
Doctrine of Merger
one person acquires all present and future interest in land except contingent remainder under CL contingent remainder was destroyed
Rule in Shelley’s Case
A.k.a–Rule Against Remainders in Grantee’s Heirs
CL if same instrument created life estate and gave remainder to heirs remainder was not recognized and A took life estate and remainder
Abolished in Most States
Doctrine of Worthier Title
A.k.a. Rule Against Remainders in Grantor’s Heirs
Remainder in grantor’s heirs is invalid and becomes a reversion in the grantor
Treated as rule of construction–applies only to inter vivos transfers and only if heirs is used
Executory Interest
Future interest in third parties either divest transferee’s preceding freehold estate or follow a gap in possession or cut short a grantor’s estate
Springing if divests grantor’s estate
Shifting if divests transferee’s preceding estate
Not subject to perpetuities
Transferring Remainders
Vested Remainders are fully transferrable
At CL: Contingent Remainders/Executory Interests were not transferable inter vivos
Today descendible and devisable provided survival is not condition
Class Gifts
children, nephews, grandkids, kids of the baby momma
May be vested subject to open or contingent
Rule of Convenience: Class Gift Rule
Absence of express contrary intent class closes when some member of the class can call for distribution
Trusts
Trust is a fiduciary relationship wherein trustee holds legal title to property subject to enforceable equitable rights in a beneficiary
Application of Perpetuities to Trusts
Generally applicable to future interest of beneficiares; note charitable trust exception
Charitable Trust Requirements
Must have charitable purpose
Differ in three ways: must have indefinite beneficiaries; may be perpetual; and cy pres doctrine allows alternative charity if purpose becomes frustrated
Perpetuities
“No interest is valid unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest.”
Interest is void if any possibility might vest beyond 21 years
Look for interest triggered at 25 bday
Only offending interest is striken
When Perpetuities Begins to Run
Will–runs from date of the testator’s death
Deeds–date of delivery
Irrevocable Trust–date of creation
Revocable Trust–when it becomes irrevocable
Interest Exempt from Perpetuities
Except for vested remainders subject to open, does not apply to vested interests
Charity to Charity Exception
Common Pitfall Cases in Perpetuities
Executory Interest following a defeasible fee Age contingency beyond twenty one in an open class Fertile Octegenarian (baby in the womb shit) Unascertainable Widow or Widower Options to purchase unless current lessee
Bad as to One, Bad as to All
Too remote of a vesting, the whole class gift fails
Class must be closed and all conditions precedent must be satisfied for every member
Gift to Subclass Exception
Per Capital Gift Exception
Rule Against Restraints on Alienation
Any restriciton on transferability of legal interest in void
Three types to look for: disabling restraints, forfeiture restraints, and promissory restraints
All fee simple estate restraints are void unless limited time and reasonable purpose
Concurrent Estates
Tenancy in Common
Joint Tenants
Tenancy by the Entirety
Joint Tenants
Distinguished by right of survivorship
Created only if four unities–time, title, interest possession
All interests must be equal
Modern law requires clear expression of right of survivorship or presumed to be tenancy in common
Severance of Joint Tenancy
Voluntary or involuntary conveyance by joint tenant of undivided interest destroys joint tenancy–transferee takes as tenant in common
Judgment liens doe not sever joint tenancy
Mortgages do not sever a joint tenancy
Tenancy by Entirety
marital estate akin to joint tenancy
CL arises presumptively in any conveyance to a husband and wife
Death, divorce, mutual agreement or execution by joint creditor of both husband and wife can sever
Individual spouse cannot convey or encumber
Rights and Duties Co-Tenants
Each entitled to right to possess all portions of property but no right to exclusive possession
Cannot bring action until ouster
Most states right to retain profits own use, exclusive until ouster or contrary agreement
Must share net rents
Effect of Co-Tenant Encumberance
May not encumber interest of other co-tenant
Mortgage can only foreclose on that tenant’s interest
Co-Tenant Remedy of Partition
Any co-tenant has right to judicial partion either in-kind or by sale and division of the proceeds
Expenses for Preservation
Contribution Right
Co-Tenant paying more than pro rata share of necessary repairs entitled to contribution provided notification to other tenants
No right to cost of improvements unless partiion
Can be demanded for taxes or mortgage payments paid on entire property
Duty of Fair Dealing
Confidential relationship exists
Leasehold Interests
Estate in land which tenant has a present possessory interest in leased premises and the landlord has a future interest (reversion)
Types of Tenancy
Tenancy for Year (Fixed Period)
Periodic Tenancies
Tenancies at Will
Tenancies at Sufferance
Tenancy for Year
This is for fixed period
Usually created through written leases
Automatically at its termination date
Breach by tenant provides landlord with right of entry, e.g. terminate lease & obtain possesion
Beach of Leasehold Agreement
Failure to pay rent
Surrender–tenant surrenders and landlord accepts
Periodic Tenancies
Continues for successive periods
e.g. month to month
Upon proper notice either party may terminate
Creation: Periodic Tenancies
Express Agreement
Implication; or
Operation of Law
Tenancies at Will
Tenancy at will is terminable at will of either landlord or tenant
May be terminated at willy by giving notice and a reasonable time to terminate
Similar right will not be in favor of landlord
Tenancies at Sufferance
Tenancy at sufferance arises when tenant wrongfully remains in possession after the expiration of a lawful tenancy
Termination last only until landlord takes steps to evict the tenant
Hold-Over Doctrine
Applies when tenant continues possession after right to possession
Landlord may: evict; bind new periodic tenancy
Terms and conditions expired apply
Commercial tenants likely new year to year, or period term based on frequency of rent payment if less than year
Residential month to month
Hold-Over Exceptions
Remain only a few hours or leaves articles of personal property; delay is not the tenant’s fault or seasonal lease
Leases
Contract governing landlord tenant relationship
CL: one breached, other could recover damages but still had to perform and could not terminate
Excpetions: Actual and Constructive Eviction Actions; Implied Warranty of Habitability
Types of Tenant Waste
Voluntary/Affirmative Waste–intent or negligence for damages & minerals
Permissive Waste-fails to take reasonable steps to protect premises from damages; liable for ordinary wear and tear
Ameliorative Waste-tenatn alters leased property and increased value; tenant liable for cost of restoration; exception if long term tenant and change reflects neighborhood
Destruction of Premises: Without Fault Landlord Tenant
CL: Neither party has duty to restore premises in absence of language but tenant must continue to pay
Most states now give tenant option to terminate lease
Tenant’s Liability for Covenants to Repair
Landlord remains liable for repairs if in lease
Implied Warranty of Habitability
Nonresidential obligated to perform covenants; not liable to rebuild structural damage or casualty destruction unless expressly includes
Illegal Purposes Uses
Landlord may terminate lease or obtain damages and injunctive relief
Duty to Pay Rent
CL: Due at end of leasehold term
Statutes provide payable at some other time
Landlord not permitted to retain security deposit beyond damages suffered
Landlord Remedies
Tenant Fails to Pay Rent; Evict or Sue for Rent
CL: provided cause for damages but not eviction
Modern: provides right to evict (“unlawful detainer”)
Tenant Abandons
Do Nothing or Reposses
Tenant Unjustifiably Abond the property–landlord duty to mitigate damages through releasing
Tenant liability depends on whether landlord accepted the surrender
Landlord Duties & Tenant Remedies
CL: Landlord had no duty to repair or maintain
Duty to Deliver Possession of Premises–actual
Quiet Enjoyment–implied covenant neither landlord nor paramount title holder will interfere with quiet enjoyment and possession of the premises
Actual Eviction
Occurs when landlord or hold over tenant excludes tenant from entire premises; terminates obligation to pay rent
Partial Eviction
Tenant is physically excluded from part of leased premies
By the Landlord: relieves tenant of obligation to pay rent entire premises
By a Third Party: apportionment of rent
Constructive Eviction
Premises Unsuitable for Occupancy
Tenant must prove: landlord breached duty; substantially and materially deprived tenant of her use and enjoyment of the premises; gave notice and reasonable time to repair; and tenant vacated lease
Implied Warranty of Habitability
Most jurisdictions imply covenant of habitability into residential leases
Nonwaivable
If breached, tenant may: terminate lease; make repairs and offset the cost w/future rent; abate rent; or remain pay in full and sue for damages
Retalitatory Eviction
Many states landlord may not termiante lease or otherwise penalize tenant in retaliation for exercise of legal rights
Presumed retaliatory motive if within 90 to 180 days
Must show valid, nonretalitary reasons for actions
Assignment
Complete transfer of tenants rights
Sublease
Tenant retains an interest
Consequences of Assignment
Assignee stands in the shoes of original tenant, i.e. direct relationship with landlord–“privity of estate”
Each liable on all covenants in lease that “run w/land”
Covenants Running with the Land
“Touches and concerns”
Benefits landlord and burdens the tenant or vice versa with respect to interest