Real Property Flashcards
Concurrent Estates
An estate in land can be held concurrently by several persons, all of whom have the right to enjoyment and possession of the land.
(3) Forms of Concurrent Ownership
(1) Joint Tenancy - (2) or more own w/ the right of survivorship;
(2) Tenancy by the Entirety - A protected marital interest between spouses w/ the right of survivorship;
(3) Tenancy in Common - (2) or more own without the right of survivorship.
Joint Tenancy
(1) Right of survivorship (Deceased JT’s shares goes automatically to surviving JT);
(2) JT’s interest is alienable inter vivos (Transferrable during JT’s lifetime);
(3) JT’s interest is neither devisable nor descendible (Can’t transfer through a will/pass to JT’s heirs because the share automatically passes to the surviving JT)
How to Create a Joint Tenancy
The Common Law requires (4) unities:
T-TIP
(1) Time (same time);
(2) Title (same deed, will, or other document of title);
(3) Identical w/ equal interests; and
(4) Rights to Possess the whole.
Each JT has identical interests and equal shares.
Severance of Joint Tenancy
(1) Sale;
(2) Partition; or
(3) Mortgage.
Sale Severance of Joint Tenancy
(1) JT may sell/transfer during lifetime (they can sell/transfer without the others knowledge or consent);
(2) When a joint tenant conveys his interest in a joint tenancy to a third-party, that party takes the property as a tenant in common. If there are only two joint tenants, the joint tenancy is severed. However, if there are more than two joint
tenants, the joint tenancy remains, but only among the other
joint tenants.
Partition Severance of Joint Tenancy
(1) Voluntary - Amicable end;
(2) Judicial - In kind (physical division); forced sale (division of proceeds)
Mortgage Severance of Joint Tenancy (2) Types
A mortgage is a lien on title.
(1) Lien Theory (Majority) - Does not sever a joint tenancy;
(2) Title Theory (Minority) - Severs a joint tenancy.
Joint Tenant’s Murdering Another
Under the Uniform Probate Code and modern statues, when a beneficiary unlawfully and intentionally kills a joint tenant, any joint property is transferred into a tenancy in common (TIC)
Tenancy by Entirety
(1) Between married partners only;
(2) Right of survivorship;
(3) Arises presumptively in any conveyance to married partners unless the language of the grant clearly indicates otherwise;
(4) Protected form of co-ownership - creditors of only (1) spouse can’t touch this tenancy;
(5) One (1) spouse acting alone cannot sever the right of survivorship by unilaterally conveying to a third party.
(6) Severance - Divorce, death, execution of lien by a joint creditor of both spouses.
*On divorce, the tenancy by entirety becomes tenancy in common (TIC)
Tenancy in Common
(1) No right of survivorship;
(2) Co-tenant owns individual part and right to possess whole;
(3) Can have unequal shares;
(4) Each interest is devisable, descendible, alienable (no survivorship rights between TIC)
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants in TIC
(1) Possession;
(2) Rent from Co-Tenant;
(3) Rent from a 3d Party;
(4) Adverse Possession;
(5) Carrying Costs;
(6) Reimbursement Repairs;
(7) Unilateral Improvements;
(8) Reimbursement for Mortgage & Tax Payments;
(9) Waste
(1) Possession (TIC)
Each co-tenant has the right to possess all portions of the property but has no right to exclusive possession of any part. If (1) co-tenant wrongfully excludes another co-tenant from possession of the whole or any part, they’ve committed ouster.
*Ouster - Actionable wrong.
(2) Rent from Co-Tenant
An out-of-possession co-tenant
DOES NOT have the right to receive rent from the inpossession
co-tenant, UNLESS the in-possession co-tenant
wrongfully ousted the out-of-possession co-tenant from the
property.
In other words: co-tenant in exclusive p;ossession need not share profits with other co-tentants absent an ouster or agreement to contrary.
(3) Rent from a Third-Party
If an in-possession co-tenant rents
the property to a third-party, the out-of-possession co-tenant
is entitled to his fair share of the rent paid by the third-party.
(4) Adverse Possession
Unless they’ve ousted the other co-tenant, the co-tenant in exclusive possession for the statutory adverse possession period cannot acquire title to the whole to the exclusion of the other co-tenant.
(5) Carrying Costs
Each tenant pays his fair share of the carrying costs (Mortgage and Taxes). Fair share is calculated based upon the co-owner’s individual share in the whole.
(6) Reimbursement for Repairs
A co-tenant is entitled to
reimbursement for the costs of necessary repairs that the cotenant
paid for, UNLESS there has been a wrongful ouster.
The amount of reimbursement is determined by the
percentage share each co-tenant owns in the property (i.e. if a
co-tenant owns a 50% share then the co-tenant is obligated to
pay 50% of the repair costs).
(7) Unilateral Improvements
A co-tenant who makes
improvements to the property is NOT entitled to reimbursement from the other co-tenant(s), UNLESS there is a separate agreement to the contrary.
*At the end of the co-tenancy
(i.e. a partition or sale of the property), the improving co-tenant bears all the downside risk of the
improvements (debit), but also has all of the upside gain. Thus, if the property appreciated because of the improvements, only
the improving co-tenant is entitled to that increase in value.
(8) Reimbursement for Mortgage & Tax Payments
All co-tenants are responsible for their proportionate share of
mortgage, tax payments, or assessments (includes all
payments that could result in a lien on the property if unpaid). HOWEVER, in most states, a co-tenant that is in sole-possession of the property CANNOT recover for such payments unless the payments exceed the reasonable rental value of the property.
(9) Waste
A co-tenant must NOT commit waste. During the life of the co-tenancy, a co-tenant is permitted to bring an action for waste against another co-tenant.
(1) Voluntary - Willful destruction;
(2) Permissive - Neglect;
(3) Ameliorative - Unilateral change increasing value. (Must be able to quantify damages - including those linked to sentimental value)
Partition - Remedy available for JT or TIC
Joint tenant or tenant in common has a right to bring an action for partition.
Partition includes:
(1) Voluntary agreement;
(2) Partition in kind; and
(3) Forced Sale.
*Courts prefer partition in kind but will permit partition by sale when a fair and equitable physical division of the property cannot be made.
Effect of One Concurrent Owner’s Encumbering the Property
Joint tenant or TIC may encumber her interest but may not encumber the interest of other co-tenants. i.e. By mortgage or judgment lien.
Under JT, a mortgage or lien does not sever the JT but a foreclosure will.
Duty of Fair Dealing
A confidential relationship exists among co-tenants; for example, one co-tenant’s acquisition of an outstanding title or lien that may affect the estate is deemed to be on behalf of other co-tenants.
* This is also why it’s difficult for one co-tenant to adversely possess against other co-tenants.