Race and Politics Flashcards
Case regarding AA at Texas uni - what did it uphold?
- Fisher v University of Texas (2013 + 2016)
- In 2013, they ruled that AA must fulfil strict scrutiny in order to be constitutional.
- In 2016, they ruled that their AA plan did fulfil strict scrutiny.
- Upheld Grutter v Bollinger 2003.
Case concerning Michigan’s state constitution
- Schuette v Coalition to defend Affirmative Action 2014
- Ruled that Michigan’s state constitution banning of AA was constitutional.
Case that partly dismantled the 1965 Voting Rights Act
- Shelby County v Holder 2013
- Made it so states that used to have to get pre-clearance on any changes to their voting systems because of a racist history would no longer have to do so.
Stat about the impact of Shelby County
- 5 years later over 1000 polling stations were closed in areas of majority African American population.
- Immediate impact seen in Texas and North Carolina.
- In North Carolina they implemented strict new voting laws like getting rid of same day voter registration and voter ID standards. this “targeted African Americans with surgical precision.”
Case Segregating schools
Plessy v Ferguson 1896.
schools must be “separate but equal”
Case de-segregating schools
Brown v Board of Education 1954
Case against Michigan university for AA where university won
Grutter v Bollinger 2003. 5-4 in favour of uni
Case against Michigan university for AA where university lost
Gratz v Bollinger - 2003
6-3 in favour of Gratz as AA wasn’t ‘narrowly tailored enough’
Muslim ban case
- Trump v Hawaii 2018
- Case on trump’s executive order.
- After trump adjusted it a few times it was deemed constitutional.
- TALK ABOUT HOW THIS AFFECTS PEOPLE WITHIN THE US.
- Eg people can not be visited by family or friends and it affects the image of muslim Americans.
Obama’s constitutional immigration Executive order
- DACA
- Trump tried to rescind but the Trump v NAACP 2020 case ruled in favour of DACA.
- Unlike proposed Dream act they would not have got citizenship, but work permit.
Obama’s Unconstitutional immigration Executive order
- DAPA - temporary ban put in place by lower courts
- then a split 4-4 decision in US v Texas so the ban was left in place
- Rescinded by Trump
Citizenship Question
- Department of Commerce v New York 2019.
- Deemed unconstitutional
- but not because it would have made many states underfunded and because it was a direct attack on illegal immigrants
- but because the department lied about their intentions of the question and it violated the APA.
School case about assignment plans of racial segregation
- Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District 2007
- Court ruled that the schools plans were not* *narrowly tailored enough and therefore unconstitutional
- School were trying to increase diversity.
Court case about the firefighters promotion
- Ricci v DeStefano 2009
- Firefighters took test but were passed up for promotion because the black firefighters did not do well.
- Court deemed this unconstitutional as they considered race too highly
Congress’ two most famous acts to protect minority rights
- Voting Rights act 1965 - Prohibits racial discrimination in voting.
- Civil Rights Act 1964 - any discrimination illegal
Congress’ act protecting minority religious groups
Religious Freedom Restoration act 1993 - prohibits any religious discrimination.
Gang of 8 Immigration Bill (didn’t pass)
Stat on how much it would have reduced US deficit.
- Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernisation Act of 2013.
- Passed in the senate 14 republicans supporting, good bipartisan support but the house would not consider it as they were more right wing.
- Estimated that it would have reduced the US deficit by $197 Billion by 2023.
Comprehensive immigration bill that didn’t pass
- Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2006.
- Would have increased security at the border while also implementing ways for illegal immigrants to gain citizenship.
- Didn’t pass as House and Senate could not reach an agreement.
Trump’s wall
- affects people within the US.
- Uses money that could be spent elsewhere
Trump’s comments in election
- trump’s comments throughout his campaign against muslims, Mexicans etc indicates a disregard for minorities.
- Then becomes mirrored in his supporters and slowly America in general
Trump’s comments on BLM
- Calling BLM a symbol of hate, a marxist group
- promised to declare Antifa a terrorist organisation while the KKK is not considered one.
Congress - House attempt at police reform
- George Floyd Justice in Policing Act of 2021 -
- Attempted in 2020 but would have never passed the senate.
- Reintroduced in 2021, passed in the house and will be heard in democrat controlled Senate but likely to be fillibustered.
- Contains the illegalisation of certain policing techniques like the choke hold etc.