Race Flashcards
What % of the UK is white (Census 2011)?
86%
What % of the UK is Asian (census 2011)?
7.5%
What % of the UK is Black (census 2011)?
3.3%
How many times more likely are blacks stopped and searched than whites?
7 times
How many times more likely are asians stopped ad searched than whites?
2 times
Blacks are … times more likely to be arrested than whites?
3 times
BME groups are over-represented in arrests for what offence categories?
ALL - especially fraud, robbery and drug offences
Are Asians over-represented in arrest statistics?
No
Compared to whites, are blacks more likely to be charged?
Yes
Compared to whites, are blacks more likely to be cautioned?
NO - less likely
Racial ‘stereotyping’ or ‘profiling’ is…
a common problem apparent in the Police
Over-representation of black people CAN or CANNOT be explained primarily by cumulative discrimination at each stage of the CJS?
CANNOT
There IS or IS NOT evidence of racial prejudice in Police culture?
THERE IS
The so-called ‘dark figure’ of crime means that…
accurate comparison of crime levels between different ethnic groups is problematic/not possible
A problem with ethnic categories is that…
they are so broad they become meaningless
Direct discrimination (in stop and search) would be…
An officer racially stereotyping an individual e.g. stop Asian with bacpack
Indirect discrimination (in stop and search) would be…
Higher number of BME individuals stopped in London - cos there are more BME individuals there
Graham and Bowling (1995) self report study found that young black men…
reported similar levels of offending to whites, young asian men reported less offending
Is there a significant difference in overall crime risk between groups (although ‘mixed’ group at higher risk)
2004/5 BCS shows little significant difference - but ‘mixed groups’ have hiher risk
For violent crimes, the rates of victimisation are…
similar: whites & blacks - 4%, Asian - 3% and Mixed - 7%
For household crimes … and … have slightly higher rates than … and …
asian and mixed are higher than white and black
How many times more likely are Blacks victims of homicide?
5 times
How many times more likely are Asians victims of homicide?
2 times
A high proportion of gun crime has…
black victims (1/3 in total)
racially-motivated crime victimisation is significantly higher for … and …
blacks and asians
Statistics suggest that SOCIAL BACKGROUND is more predictive of victimisation than…
ethnicity
social background factors are…
socio-economic status, lifestyle, occupation, area of residence, demographic factors e.g. age
What are the 3 theories of crime related to Race?
- Right realism - Murray
- Radical Analyses - Gilroy, Hall
- Left Realism - Lea and Young
What is Right Realism? (Murray)
Poor people are bound to offend by their nature/unstable family/employment/ chaotic livelihood
What are the radical analyses? (opposite of right)
moral panic surrounding offenders and media creates ‘folk devils’
What is left realism? (most British criminologists)
emphasise the reality of crime for working class people - the vicious cycle of disadvantage-offending-labelling-disadvantage. want to reduce social exclusion of BME and racial inequality
The role of socio-economic disadvantage is that…
Ethnic minorities are over-represented in those social groups (unemployed, low income etc) and in those geographical areas (inner-cities) that have both elevated offending rates and are more likely to be caught and labelled by the CJS
Urban conflict 1970’s-2011 has resulted in…
tense, mistrusting, suspicious relations between the police and BME groups
Reiner’s (2010) definition of cop culture
“The way that police officers view their social world and their place in it”
Core values of cop culture are…
Mission Suspicion Social isolation Group solidarity Conservatism Machismo Racial prejudice
cop culture is oral which means…
and…
disparity between what they say (in the canteen) and what they do
AND it differs to rank/location/specialism
BME officers are severely under-represented in the police - true or false?
TRUE (but it is getting better slowly)
What % of Police are from ethnic minorities?
5% (compared to 7% of the working population)
Is under-representation worse at senior levels?
Yes
At recruitment level, what causes under-representation?
Disproportionately low rate of applications from BME communities
Of all applicants, is it true that BME success rate is lower than whites?
Yes, 20% vs 25%
Retention and BME…
BME officers are ml2b dismissed or forced to resign than white officers (Runnymede Trust, 2009)
BME officers ml2 resign because… (5 reasons)
- face racial abuse or ‘banter’ from colleagues,
- lack of support when racial complaints are made
- Disproportionately investigated in internal misconduct investigations
- Promotion/move to specialist squads if restricted
- Marginalisation/isolation
Vertical segregation affects BME officers…
fewer are promoted and later into their career (it takes longer) as they are less likely (or encouraged) to apply, and less likely to pass required tests
Horizontal segregation affects BME officers…
underrepresented in elite squads and over-represented in community relations, patrolling posts
Direct discrimination in employing BME officers occurs at recruitment, promotion stages? (difficult to prove!)
recruitment - UNLIKELY as Police under pressure to recruit BME people
promotion - anecdotal evidence suggests YES
BME officers are ml2 face disciplinary/tribunals?
TRUE
Direct and Indirect discrimination are both…
ILLEGAL
Types of indirect discrimination are…
rules such as minimum height (anti asian) and must wear hat (made turbans)
lack of support and training with BME groups
How are the Police trying to improve institutional discrimination?
- Recruitment - targeted camp
- Training - community and race relations
- More disciplinary/investigation for discrimination
- Trying to improve their image with BME
Legal policies to improve BME relations
Race Relations (Amendment) Act 2000 - Equalities Act 2010
Crown Prosecution Service is fairly well represented at … %
The Judiciary is…
And for Senior judges
15%
even lower, 4%
even lower!
2%
Magistrates court deal with … % of crime?
95%
Crown court deals with …% of crime?
5% - more serious crimes so ml2be longer sentences
Discrimination occurs where … is high
discretion
Judicial discretion results in…
more opportunities for discrimination as Judges can be biased
Overall the prison population is…
GROWING - regardless of ethnicity, if people are guilty they are likely to go to prison for longer
at the prosecution stage, there is…
limited discretion so discrimination is minimal
CPS objections to bail are slightly higher for…
black offenders