R5 Flashcards
substantial authority
> 33% but less than 50%
more likely than not
> 50% (most stringent)
reasonable basis
> 20% (least stringent)
tax practitioner vs. tax preparer
preparer = compensation
listed transaction vs. reportable transaction
- listed transaction = tax avoidance related
* reportable transaction = tax avoidance and tax evasion related
basis or authority to avoid unreasonable position
Non Tax Shelters:
- undisclosed - substantial authority
- disclosed - reasonable basis
Tax Shelters
3. more likely than not
confidence level needed for reliance opinion
more likely than not
evidence needed for board to revoke license
more likely than not
*not beyond a reasonable doubt as in criminal cases
Form used when taxpayer and revenue agent reach an agreement
Form 870
Courts available for a taxpayer with a notice of deficiency
- U.S. Tax Court
- U.S. Court of Federal Claims
- U.S. District Court
Who can initiate court proceedings for tax matters?
the individual or the IRS
In general, who has the burden of proof for tax court cases?
the party bringing the case
bringing = burden
Is payment of tax required when litigating in a U.S. Tax Court?
No, it is the only court where you do not have to pay
What does the taxpayer need in order to proceed to the court system?
a notice of deficiency
Unique aspects for each court:
- U.S. Tax Court
- U.S. District Court
- U.S. Court of Federal Claims
- do not have to pay tax liability
- one judge, can request jury
- must be a federal claim for money damages against the United States (nationwide) (16 judges, no jury) (follows decisions of Federal Court of Appeals, not geographic)
From which courts can you appeal to the U.S. Courts of Appeals?
- U.S. Tax Court
2. U.S. District Court
From which courts can you appeal to the Federal Court of Appeals?
U.S. Court of Federal Claims only
writ of certiorari
U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear your case
Exceptions to penalty for individual taxpayers on making estimated income tax payments
- current year’s tax minus withholdings is less than $1,000
- estimated payments of at least 90% of the current year’s tax
- estimated payments of at least 100% of the prior year’s tax (110% if over $150,000)
Failure-to-file penalty
5% per month up to 25% of tax due
decreases for months where both file and pay penalties apply
Failure-to-pay penalty
1/2 of 1% per month up to 25% of unpaid tax
Negligence penalty for understatement of tax
20%
The failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, and negligence penalties are all assessed on what amount?
Tax liability - withheld - paid = tax due
Best defense (in most cases) for negligence
reasonable basis
Penalty for substantial understatement of tax
20%
Defense basis for penalty for substantial understatement of tax
- disclosed - reasonable basis
- undisclosed - substantial authority
- tax shelter - more likely than not
Burden of proof needed in the federal court system for civil tax cases
preponderance of the evidence
Fraud penalty
75%
Burden of proof needed in the court system for criminal case
beyond a reasonable doubt
not frivolous
< 20%
Covered Opinion
1. listed transaction or 2. tax shelter (avoidance or evasion) or 3. reliance opinion or marketed opinion
Accuracy-related penalties are made on:
- negligence
2. substantial understatement of income tax
ordinary negligence
failure to exhibit ordinary care
Two guidelines in determining to whom the duty is owed for negligence.
- majority rule - clients and limited foreseeable class of persons who will be relying on the CPA’s work
- Ultramares decision - persons in privity of contract and intended third-party beneficiaries (similar to breach of contract)
Best defense for negligence
due diligence (GAAP and GAAS + workpapers)
To whom is the CPA liable for cases of fraud?
Anyone who can prove the elements of fraud; general public
Best defense for fraud
lack of scienter