quiz #3 Flashcards
P/T ‘Inferior’ Court
- lowest level
- nearly all criminal cases begin and end here
- administered by the P/T government
- judges appointed by the P/T government
- no jury trials
what cases are heart in P/T ‘Inferior’ courts?
- Jurisdiction over majority of criminal offences
- Exceptions: s. 469 indictable offences
- Hear preliminary hearings in serious cases determine whether there is sufficient evidence to proceed to trial
P/T ‘Superior’ Courts
- Administered by the P/T
- Judges are appointed federally
- Trials can involve judge alone or judge and jury
What cases are heard in P/T ‘Superior’ Courts?
- Deals with the most serious criminal cases
- Can hear criminal/civil appeals from the P/T inferior court.
- Accused or crown formally request a change
P/T Court of Appeal
- Highest court in the province
- One court of Appeal in each P/T
- Administered by the P/T
- Judges are federally appointed
- Panel of 3 or 5 judges
What cases are heard in P/T Court of Appeal?
- Hears criminal appeals from inferior or superior P/T courts
- Hears civil appeals from superior P/T courts
Appeal Process
- the defense and Crown can appeal the decision
- Appeal can be directed at the verdict or the sentence (or both)
- Oral arguments made by lawyers for both
Supreme Court of Canada (SCC)
- Final Court of Appeal [“court of last resort”]
- Administered by the federal government; located in Ottawa
- Panel of 9 judges
- Judges are federally appointed
- Hear written/oral arguments of lawyers
What cases are heard in the SCC?
- Usually must be granted “leave to appeal.”
- Cases that have national importance
- Will also hear reference cases (legal opinion on an important legal question)
3 Classifications of Criminal Offences
- Summary Offences
- Indictable Offences
- Hybrid Offence
Summary Offences
- Trials are always heard in P/T Inferior Court by a judge alone.
- Charges must be laid within 12 months
Indictable Offences - 3 types
- Absolute (lowest level)
- Exclusive (judge & jury)
- Electable (accused has a choice)
Absolute Jurisdiction of P/T “Inferior” Courts
- less serious indictable offence (e.g., theft under $5000)
- Must be tried in P/T inferior court
Exclusive Jurisdictions of P/T “Superior” Courts
- Most serious offence (e.g., murder)
- Must be tried by a judge/jury in P/T superior court
- Can request judge only
Electable Indictable Offences
- All other indictable offences fall into this category.
- Majority of indictable offences in Canada
- Accused can choose to have the trial by a:
- P/T Inferior Court without a Jury
- P/T Superior Court without a Jury
- P/T Superior Court with a jury (Only available if max sentence 5+ years)
Hybrid Offences
Allows prosecutors the discretion to decide to proceed with a case as a summary conviction or an indictable conviction
crown charge approval
crown counsel can decide:
- no charges should be laid
- charges should be laid (what the charges are)
- an alternative to the court process, like alternative measures
bail hearing
to determine whether the accused should be held in custody until trial or whether they should stay in the community (with or w/o conditions)
charge assessment guidelines
- Is there a substantial likelihood of conviction based on the evidence presented in the RCC?
- Is a prosecution in the public interest?
what are the 3 grounds for detention
- primary ground
- secondary ground
- tertiary ground
primary ground
detention is necessary to ensure attendance at court