Quiz 1 Flashcards
Why was the Milgram Experiment (think nazis) a poor example of a study?
- Trained trauma for the participants and they weren’t given any reversing therapy
What is the point of the Research Ethics Board?
To make sure that every research experiment, for the sake of the participants, has certain basic ethical protocols
For REB : what does the delegated review do?
It means that the approval process is faster
John wants to investigate the use of keywords in the table of contents have changed over time. He plans to collect the table of contents from texts of different decades from Amazon Kindle books which provides the table of contents for free. Do you think John needs to apply for an institutional ethics approval?
A. Yes
B. No
C. Not sure
B. No - these are public files on a public application
In which of the following research scenarios would ethics review most likely be required?
A. Creating a linguistic database of publicly available news articles.
B. Observing children in daycares to investigate language acquisition milestones.
C. Analyzing sound patterns in Na’vi, a constructed language.
D. Transcribing podcast interviews of famous actors.
B. Observing children in daycares to investigate language acquisition milestones.
T or F : Linguistic subfields would not vary considerably in terms of the information they provide before obtaining consent.
F
Why do experimenters intentionally conceal information knowledge?
So that it doesn’t shake/affect the results negatively
T of F : depending on the situation, you don’t need to always debrief the information that may have been concealed (the experimenters, at times, can keep that to themselves)
F : ALWAYS debrief
Which of the following is NOT a procedure for a consent form :
- Voluntariness
- Compensation
- Assessment of risks
- All of the above
- None of the above
- None of the above
Power asymmetry - Consent
When a participant may feel the obligation to participate simply because a person of greater power is telling them to
A student is planning to research social inequalities and the oppression of marginalized groups. For data collection, they intend to travel to a country
where the oppression of women is so severe that physical harm against wives is culturally accepted. The student’s research will involve interviewing women about domestic abuse to better understand societal attitudes and structures, with the goal of advocating for social justice. They plan to
audio-record the interviews using their phone, with a translator present, and will obtain informed consent through a formal consent form.
Explain some ethical issues
- Translator miscommunications
- Bias
- Danger to community
- Lack of understanding of consent
What are a few examples of ‘giving back’ in experimental designs?
- For the continuation of studying a language, leaving trained people there
- Putting in more efforts for the revitalizing of a language (more resources)
- Direct compensation - money
Describe a few general ethical dilemmas in linguistic research
- What kind of data was collected
- What level of privacy sensitivity we are dealing with
- HOW to give back properly
- How consent forms are obtained
Why is sampling so important?
Helps us to get a general idea of the entire population if we sample from careful data points –> it needs to be representative though
The more ______ the sample is to the pop., the more _______ it is
similar; representative
Prob methods of sampling : simple random sampling (2 pros 1 con)
- everyone has an = chance
- best way to get a represen. result
- Costs more $
Prob methods of sampling : stratified random sampling (3 steps)
- Pop is divided intro stratas - groups of people put together because of common characteristics (sex, age, race, etc.)
- FROM each strata, random people are picked
- Data is collected from these individuals
T or F : In a strata, if chosen from a pop, EVERYONE is chosen
F -just the individual picked