Quiz 1 Flashcards
What are meta-ethics?
Transcendent realm of ethical existence; abstract
Meta-physics: beyond physical realm
Metaphor: beyond literal meaning
Normative ethics
General guidelines for how we conduct ourselves in a moral world
- Manuals for how to act
- Realm in which we come up with ethical guidelines & moral principles
Applied ethics
Related to everyday existence, apply normative ethics to specific situations
Involves application of normative guidelines to specific, concrete situations
How did philosophers think before the 17th century?
Plato = "justice" Aristotle = "virtue"
Not in terms of “moral ethics”
Who was Plato?
Student of Socrates, wrote Socrates’ dialogues, author o the Republic
Describe Glaucon’s idea of justice in Book II of Plato’s Republic?
If we could get away with being unjust we would
Humans are inclined to be unjust –> more success –> get what you want
BUT people won’t trust you if they know you’re unjust
Everyone wants to be treated justly
If you are just and are perceived as just you won’t vain as much as someone who is only perceived as just
If you are just but are suspected of being unjust – worst case scenario
Ideal situation is to be unjust but have people think you’re just
Describe Socrates’ rebuttal to Glaucon’s argument in Book II
Human soul requires justness to be well/healthy
Unjust soul is sick/unhealthy vs. just soul is healthy
If you are unjust you aren’t good to yourself/aren’t being healthy
Basic views of Aristotle
Humans are by nature virtuous (many kinds– political, rationality, etc)
Similar to Socrates
Not engaged in virtuous activity is not flourishing in life –> not living to ones full potential
Humans are flourishing most when engaged in virtuous activity
Basic views of Stoics
ONE distinct feature of humans is virtue
Have to be virtuous to be human
Virtue is THE distinctive trait
What did the ancients emphasize?
Self-interest (not the same as selfishness)
Interest of the moral agent
What happened in the 17th century?
Emphasis shifted from virtue/justice to morality
Morality as something obligatory regardless of self-interest
Historical shift towards the development of individual identity and conscience
Do things because they’re the right thing to do not because of self-interest
Internalization of right and wrong
What philosophers were influential in the 17th century shift?
John Locke- Human understanding
Thomas Hobbes- Leviathan
Sam Puffendor
Introduced morality as something obligatory regardless of self-interest
What does morality signify?
Sense that we ought to do certain things regardless of self-interest
What are Kant’s basic beliefs?
German
Focused on obligatory aspects of morality
Categorical Imperative- unavoidable, urgent, of paramount importance, you have to do regardless of personal interest, morally binding command, humans MUST follow
Hypothetical imperative- gauge choices in terms of potential good outcome (gauge self interest)
MORAL REASONING
Categorical Imperative
Unavoidable, urgent, of paramount importance, you have to do regardless of personal interest, morally binding command, humans MUST follow
Always wrong no matter the circumstance.
If we say that “torture is wrong” is a categorical imperative, it wouldn’t matter if the info was important it would never be morally justifiable.
Hypothetical imperative
Gauge choices in terms of potential good outcome (gauge self interest)
Prudential judgment
Like Kant’s hypothetical imperative
Prudence
Made from self-interested POV
Moral Judgment
like Kant’s categorical imperative
made from a more dissinterested/more impartial POV
Singular Moral Judgment
deals with a specific instance, draws on applied ethics
may use moral principles to come to conclusion, more like normative ethics
Conscience
Not transparent/obvious, historically inflected
Emerged with 17th century understanding of morality
Conscientia (latin) –> consciousness, awareness
Latin term embraces sense of ourselves as conscience
Locke instrumental in formulating idea of conscience in his Essay on Human Understanding
Acts as a moral guide/source of knowledge
Who was instrumental in formulating the idea of conscience?
John Locke
_____ had a large influence on the development of morality/conscience as a source of knowledge
Christianity
Christianity gave us what moral idea
our knowledge of right and wrong was implanted in us by God.
Draws on natural reason
Great Historical Shift
Command mode of morality –> self-governance mode of morality
Sense of right and wrong not imposed from the outside–> internalization of right and wrong + trust individuals to know morals
Shift towards ____ in the west
secularism
During shift towards secularism, knowledge of right and wrong comes from where
reasoning not from god, still required reason, but it’s not natural (god given) reasoning –> not dependent on divine
Principal of individual moral insight
we each have the ability ot know as individuals what is right and wrong
Consequentialism
evaluation of things in terms of consequence
Deontology
emphasizes sense of “ought” or obligatory aspect of morality
Kant
Intuitionism
Moral realists
Presume that moral truths (especially basic moral truths) are self-evident
Self-evident
universality, true in all circumstances, needs no supporting evidence, basic and requires no more rational justification
Ross
pluralist, intuitionist, multiple (7) basic moral principles
____ is not consistent though time
morality
cultural and individual morality change
Moral realists
objective reality where things are right or wrong
Structure of arguments
syllogism
What are the three major parts of a syllogism
- major premise (all humans are mortal)
- minor premise (Larry is a human) (secondary importance)
- conclusion (larry is a mortal)